Tuesday, April 28, 2009

I talked too much today

On more than one occasion today, I was talking and realized the person I was talking to wasn't listening. They were doing that head nodding thing I do when I feel like I have to make eye contact and get nervous about what I should be doing and stop listening to what the other person was saying. Then I took a good listen to myself and realized I was barely listening to what I was saying. I'm such a windbag. Bummer. To atone, today's blog will be short. The end.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

Fun with words

So Steven was teasing me and I called him a jackass. Then he says:

S: Replace that j, with an l.
R: lackass?
S: now replace that k with an e
R: Laceass?
S: Now replace that a with an o.
R: Loceass?
S: Now another o.
R: Looceass?
S: ... ummm... get rid of that o.
R: Ok back to loceass
S: Now replace that c with a v.
R: Loveass?
S: That's right. I'm a loveass. Because I love you. With all of my ass.

Thursday, April 2, 2009

Charisma

I gave a presentation the other day and it went really well. I prepared general guidelines for myself, but I mostly wanted it based upon questions from the audience. The crowd had lots of questions (there was maybe a ten second pause after 45 minutes, followed by more questions for the rest of the hour), so most of my talking was impromptu. I was joking and people were laughing and I felt like I made a good impression even on people who had never spoken to me before. I think I sounded well informed and gave good advice that would actually be useful to them.

So how did I do that?

Honestly, I consider myself to be a shy person. I sometimes find it very hard to speak in front of people (which ironic since I'm going to be a teacher). Sometimes when I have something to say in research group, I will get everyone's attention (like by saying, "wait a sec", or "I have a question") and then I will have to physically force myself to start talking. I want to have my sentence thought out before I begin so I don't stumble all over myself. It sometimes takes a second or two of dead silence before I can get myself to start speaking. I usually get myself off the ground before it becomes awkward or anything, but I'm very conscious of the difficulty I have in speaking up. In this talk that I gave the other day, I really didn't prepare much of anything. I had a few things to say if no one had any questions, but if those things hadn't sparked any questions from anyone, there would have been a lot of dead space.

I think I owe a lot of my success in my talk to my audience because of how inquisitive they were and how many questions they wanted to ask, but a lot of it was me too. This isn't the first time something like this has happened, where I've felt like I was the charismatic center of the room, full of interesting anecdotes and funny comments. Those situations are lovely, but they also aren't the norm. Most of the time, I feel like I make a negative first impression. My usual opinion of myself is that people have to warm up to me because I'm kind of abrasive at first. I think I come off as harsh or critical. Maybe I am. In my talk from the other day, I criticized myself and my research nontrivially (my design was awful, my decisions the day of were questionable, and my findings didn't really show much), so any criticism I had of other people was probably not taken poorly. I think I criticize or tease often, but most people don't realize I either don't mean it, or I don't mean it to be so harsh. I criticize myself as well and it doesn't stop me from thinking highly of myself.

I think part of it was also that I was just being myself. I feel like I give off the worst impression when I'm trying to impress someone or when I feel like I have to behave a certain way. I came into this talk with a fairly low level of stress since it wasn't exactly being graded or anything and I wanted it casual. I noticed that in my classroom as well. When I stopped acting "like a teacher" and started acting like myself, it seemed to flow a lot better. Of course, if you take this tact and then someone dislikes you, then you can't rationalize their dislike away. It can be a little upsetting sometime to bare yourself and then get shut down.

I don't know. I guess I have to keep thinking about it and trying things out. I would love to be that charismatic person more often, especially since job interviews are coming up (ahhhh!!!).

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Aging

It may be weird to blog about aging when I'm only 23, but I've been thinking about it a little. My perception of time is extremely limited. It's better than it was. When I was in high school, time felt like it lasted forever. Once I got into the routine of a certain semester, it felt like I had been doing that forever. Then it felt the same the next year. I was very focused on the present. It may have looked like I was focused on the future and motivated to look forward since I was trying to get into a good college, but kids don't really understand what that means. I definitely didn't. I was really just a kid who knew how to do well in school and got praised for it. The immediate rewards meant more to me than the future. I didn't know what I wanted to do with my life and I didn't particularly care. That was something I'd think about later. My focus was on the things I was told I had to do right then.

Even in college my vision was pretty narrow and focused on the present. I had classes to take and do well in, so I poured my attention into that. My tone seems to be downplaying the importance of that, but it's not exactly unreasonable. I didn't have a lot of experience to compare things. There are so many things that take a long time to repeat and I just hadn't seen enough of them. One example would be presidents. I kind of remember Clinton, but I wasn't old enough to vote when he was being elected, so I didn't pay much attention. There's not a whole lot of point when you don't have a say in it. This has been my first change of presidency really. The difference is rather remarkable.

However big the change is, the presidency is a pretty lame example of what I'm talking about. I'm really thinking of things that take much longer than 4 years. I realized the other day that I have almost no insight into processes that take 20 or 30 years to mature. I was thinking about our board games and how we'll play them with our kids when they are old enough (and exist). Then I realized that a few pieces of cardboard that might not get frequent use in the meantime will be in pretty ragged shape in 20 years. It occurred to me then, all the things around me are going to decay over the course of my lifetime. There are a good many things that I take for granted and they just won't be around forever, or at least won't be in good shape. As a little kid, you go nuts when some of your possessions are lost (especially important ones). You think they're going to be there forever and it's a shock when you realize they are not a permanent part of your landscape. I think I have realized to certain extent that things have a certain impermanence, but I'm not sure I've ever really been aware of the inevitability of it. I'd say I'm still not.

I also haven't really failed enough to be compassionate. This past year, I've failed a lot. I compare myself now to myself a year ago and I cringe at how cocky I was. You haven't tried enough things at my age to realize how difficult some things are. Most things are difficult. Living is difficult. And when you see someone else fail, it's easy to criticize. I've learned to criticize a lot less I feel. One of the first year MACSMEs hasn't really been humbled by the whole experience yet. I worry for her because she's going to have it the hardest. She's been having a few difficulties, but I can tell it hasn't really hit home yet. Even though she's not the one who's been practically crying during supe group each week, I have the most concerns for her development. Oh well. The learning will come in time. It took me a while too. A few years ago, I think I would have had difficulty spending time with this person. Even today, I notice her little faux pas, but they don't really bother me. I know her realizations will come, and she's really not that bad in the meantime. No worse than I was certainly.

My thoughts have rambled away. And so I end.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Economic Crisis

I had an extended discussion with Steven the other day about the current economic crisis. It helped solidify my knowledge of the causes, but I tend to think a lot better when I write as opposed to just talking out loud. Also, I kind of want a record of my perception of this crisis.

So here goes.

It all began when certain home lending institutions began a new practice: selling mortgages. Their whole business model was based around this. They would give someone a loan to buy a house and then sell the loan to some investor. In effect, that random investor was giving someone a loan and paying the lending institution a finder's fee as the middle man. This means that these lending institutions were lending out other people's money. Once they had sold the loan, they didn't care if it was paid back or not. They still got their finder's fee regardless. So of course, it was in their best interests to find lots and lots of people and collect more and more finder's fees. The lending institutions found people who had never been offered loans before (usually for good reason) and gave them the opportunity to buy a house that they really couldn't afford. Of course, these people jumped at the chance. Huge sections of the population who had been kept away from the "American Dream" all of a sudden found it attainable. There were all kinds of creative payment plans cooked up so that people thought they might actually be able to pay their loans back. Most people were pretty willing to be convinced. It didn't matter if they had a plan where their payments increased over time or a plan that prevented them from saving a dime; they figured their salaries might increase or the value of their home would go up and somehow it would all work out. It doesn't matter if the lending companies thought it would work out as long as they could convince people to accept the loans, which generally wasn't very difficult.

It's not hard to imagine how these bad mortgages were created. I might have made the same mistake in their place if I thought I could actually have a house after being denied one for so long. The part that gets tricky is how these loans were sold. I mentioned before that lending companies were using other people's money to sell these loans, but I conveniently glossed over how they convinced people to buy mortgages that were so incredibly likely to be defaulted. The simple answer is that no one knew who the loans were being given out to. They didn't realize that everyone from the minimum wage earners to migrant workers had been offered loans. The total picture is a bit more complicated than that though. Very few investors are willing to buy something they know so little about. However, many also aren't willing to research their stocks in extremely great depth. That's why stock rating systems were devised. The ratings measure how safe or low risk a stock is. So now the lending companies were faced with the task of making their investments appear safe so that they could get more money to loan and then get more finder's fees. How do you make such and incredibly risky investment appear like a conservative, safe way to store your money? One way was to insure the mortgages. If the person who received the loan defaulted, then the insurance company would pay. Of course, insurance companies make you pay very high rates if they think their insuring something risky, so the lending companies were again left with the problem of making their stocks appear safe. Then some horrible genius came up with the idea of tranching. They divided up all the mortgages into groups called tranches. Often there would be about 20 tranches or more. Let's look at an example of a lending company with 20 tranches. The first tranche would be the first 5% of the mortgages to default on their loans. If even 5% defaulted, you would get no money at all. It was definitely a risky investment. The next tranche would pay out full returns unless more than 5% of the total mortgages defaulted. So if 5% of all the mortgages defaulted, you would be fine. If 6% defaulted, you would take some losses. If 10% or more defaulted, you would get nothing. Again, a risky investment considering that foreclosure rates were about 20% historically. But now imagine that you're in the 15th tranche. More than 70% of all the loans this company gave out would have to default before you'd even have to think about it. Even lower tranches than that looked pretty appealing. Imagine how safe and secure the 20th tranche must have looked. Everyone would have to default before you'd have to worry about a thing. Thus, stock rating companies were deceived and most of the crappy loans earned the safest rating, AAA. People gladly paid big bucks to buy something unbelievably secure with high rates of return that was also insured. You could put your life savings into something that secure and then not have to worry about money at all. Little did they know that the people who could afford loans were usually going to banks, not these lending institutions. People who could actually afford loans are a harder sell. People who never had a chance at a house will jump at the opportunity. You can move people through much more quickly and collect more finder's fees if you give loans to people who have never had money before. The 15th tranche wasn't safe. Even the 20th tranche didn't deserve a AAA rating. Almost every one of those crappy loans ended up defaulting. Nearly all the investors lost all of their money. But how could they lose everything? The investments were rated as being so safe, and weren't those loans insured? Unfortunately for the insurance companies, they were. The insurance companies were some of the first to go under (remember AIG?).

This is how the downward spiral began, but the spiral has much, much farther to go. A few investors losing their savings is certainly tragic for them, but it doesn't destroy a whole economy. Even a major insurance company going out of business isn't more than a ripple in the whole US economy. There are several other factors that set the stage for the huge downfall that ensued. Again, it begin with the lending companies that sold mortgages. Here, the focus shouldn't be on who they sold the loans to, but rather on how many people ended up with loans. From out of nowhere, the demand for houses went through the roof. Many people who had previously never had the opportunity to enter the home buying market were now seriously shopping. Here is a classic case of supply and demand influencing cost. Even with companies building houses as fast as they could, there was no way anyone could match the rate at which lending companies were giving out loans. Demand was increasing far faster than it ever had before. You would think people would get suspicious when their home values began to grow exponentially, but most people just saw it as a great windfall. Real estate agents were certainly enjoying the boom and housing developers didn't have time to consider why housing prices were soaring when other housing developers were getting filthy rich with their newly constructed houses that were being sold as fast as they could be built. As a result of the soaring prices, loans for houses needed to get larger and larger for people to be able to afford one. Even people who could normally afford a house were faced with extremely daunting loans that even they would be hard pressed to pay back. People who tried waiting for housing prices to come down again often panicked as the prices kept going up and up. "Priced out" was a common phrase back then. If you didn't stretch your means and buy a house now, the prices would soar and soar until you no longer had the option even to stretch. To avoid being priced out, people rushed to their banks (and also to those lending institutions) clamoring for loans that they could less and less afford. Even without the lending institutions giving loans to people certain to default, the foreclosure rate would have still skyrocketed because of the unreasonably high cost of housing and the large number of people making sacrifices to buy a house while they could. Now even banks that didn't sell away their mortgages (and so actually screened their loans to increase the chances of being paid back) would be faced with more losses than usual.

As you can see, an enormous problem was already looming on the horizon, but another new lending policy made the problem even worse: the home equity loan. Because of the rising prices of housing, there was now a huge section of the population that looked rich on paper but didn't have a dime in cash. They had spent every penny on buying their house and paying back their enormous mortgage, and now they had nothing with which to buy a car or start a business. Even though they had no liquid assets, many families had a house that was worth much more than when they bought it. It was probably frustrating to have that much net worth and be unable to buy some of the necessary things to live and have a family. So in comes another horrible genius. Why not turn their non liquid assets (in almost all cases, their homes) into cash and then make a profit off of the transaction? People were now able to trade in their mortgage that they had stretched to pay for earlier for an even bigger one plus some cash upfront. If someone wanted to start a business, but didn't have the cash to do so, this was an excellent opportunity. With a brand new successful business, they could afford a larger mortgage. What they really needed was the cash upfront, and now their house could give it to them. Banks liked the deal because they made a lot of money in the process. People liked the deal because they could go from living like paupers in an expensive home to living like they were used to and having the opportunities they would have had if houses had been available that they could have afforded.

And it wasn't just banks and individuals who benefited from home equity loans. The whole economy surged because now people who had never had access to money not only had a house, but a lot of cash from the house's equity that they could now spend. For a few years, the economy experienced an almost unprecedented surge. More people were able to spend than ever before. Most companies tried expanding to meet the growing demand for products and experienced record profits. For a short time, the American dream was attainable and everyone was able to be middle class, even on minimum wage salaries.

The the first foreclosures started to happen.

At first, a few of the most obviously bad loans foreclosing was not a problem. Only the first tranches were affected, and pretty much everyone knew the first tranche was not a good deal anyway. Then more and more tranches were left with no returns. People who had felt very secure were left with nothing. The price of all of these "secure" stocks plummeted. No one was willing to invest in the lending companies or their tranched loans anymore. With no more influx of other people's money, the lending institutions were forced to slow down their loans and eventually halt them entirely. Countrywide and many other companies specializing in quick turnover of home loans began to cease operations. The insurance companies began to crash along with them. Housing prices suffered a commensurate crash since all of a sudden, the supply of available houses was much higher than it had been before. Investors also began to suffer. Individual investors lost whatever they had put into purchasing those loans, but individuals weren't the only investors in the lending companies. Some banks, such as Bear Sterns, were also investors. Bear Sterns was one of the first actual banks to suffer devastating losses. The government didn't want to see the 4th largest bank in the US to go under because they feared that the people would lose trust in the economy and cause it to tank. They did what they could the bandage the situation, but there were many other problems on the horizon that they couldn't foresee.

With the price of homes dropping drastically, home equity loans began to look like a very bad idea. They increased the projected earnings of the banks tremendously and caused their stocks to go through the roof, much to the glee of stockholders. However, the banks were suddenly realizing that those projected earnings weren't going to happen. Housing prices began dropping back down to sane levels and banks realized that they had given people money for something that was no longer worth what they had paid. For many people, their mortgage was now actually higher than the value of their house. Normally, when someone defaults on their mortgage, the banks take a loss, but it is usually in expected profits. They will also often sell a house for less than it is worth because they would rather have cash. If someone has a $500,000 house and still owe $200,000 on it when they find they are unable to continue paying their mortgage, the bank sells the house (let's say for $450,000), keeps the $200,000 plus interest that they are owed, and then gives the rest to the poor defaulted family who often quickly use it up paying the bills they've accrued that caused them to go bankrupt in the first place. That was the old model before home equity loans. It's not great for the banks, but they survive. But now imagine a house that was worth $500,000. Pretend this family also had a $200,000 mortgage, but they needed some cash, so they got a home equity loan raising their mortgage to $400,000. Now imagine if housing prices dropped drastically. This family's $500,000 home could be worth as low as $300,000, perhaps lower in some areas. Some people in this situation chose to default on purpose because they didn't like the idea of paying a mortgage worth more than the cost of their home. By declaring bankruptcy, they would have a bad credit rating for a while, but they could start over fresh without an overwhelming debt that they got from buying an overpriced house. That situation did happen, but I believe that most people continued to struggle to make ends meet and pay exorbitant rates for their house which was steadily decreasing in value. However, when a family couldn't pay any more (perhaps there was a death in the family or a source of income dried up), the bank was unable to recoup their losses. They might be able to sell the house, or they might not. With more houses than there were buyers, a lot of banks couldn't turn over their foreclosed houses, even at a loss. Even if they did manage to sell the house, say for $250,000, that only pays for $250,000 of the now $400,000 mortgage. The bank doesn't get back what it lent and the family gets nothing. And if the family gets nothing, none of their bill collectors get anything either. Credit cards, which had been freely given out during the boom, were now creating losses for companies everywhere.

While companies did receive a blow from the families defaulting on their debts, the real blow came when the home equity loans stopped. The cash from those home equity loans had been stimulating the marketplace significantly and many companies had expanded in response to that. When that cash flow suddenly dried up, companies were suddenly left with an excess of employees and a lack of profits. Hard times hit on Wall Street and one of the first responses was layoffs. So many families were struggling to make ends meet to pay for their expensive houses and they couldn't afford to have a major breadwinner unemployed for long. Many families were stretched so thin they were living paycheck to paycheck. When they got laid off, they were forced to default, which made the situation even worse. It made housing prices drop just a little more since there was a larger supply and less demand. Banks took even more losses from failure to sell houses. Creditors had to erase the profits they had made on paper when they lent these families money. And most importantly, people who used to be shopping and consuming no longer had any money with which to do so, which reduced company profits even more. This, of course, meant more layoffs and the cycle continued.

Everything I've described above affected a large number of people, but many members of the general populace hadn't realized yet how dire the situation was. The general public started to really notice how bad things had gotten when banks started to go under. At first, everyone thought the Bear Sterns bailout was bizarre and unusual. Then other banks started to go under as well. Banks were some of the first institutions hit and they lost the most. Some people started to panic. A few made runs on the banks withdrawing all their cash above $100,000 (the maximum amount the government had insured at that time), which made the banks' situations even worse. Banks that didn't own any crappy mortgages and that had made fewer home equity loans started buying up all the floundering banks that had. Fortunately for people who had their money in banks, very few banks went under. Most were simply bought at a fraction of their real value. If they hadn't been, the situation would have been much, much worse than it is today.

Not many normal banks declared bankruptcy (the same cannot be said of investment banks), but they had all been dealt a serious blow. Very few banks were willing to give out loans anymore, even to families that would normally be able to pay them back. Even middle class families that should have been safe investments were defaulting because they had paid too much for their houses. As more and more people began to be laid off, even someone with a good salary was no guarantee. As banks became more and more reluctant with their loans, housing prices continued to fall. Now when layoffs happened, banks hurt even more. And layoffs were becoming more and more common. The unemployment level was rising steadily. As more people got laid off, fewer people were left to buy products, which lead more companies to lay off their employees. Even people who weren't laid off began to curtail their spending. Everyone realized that their jobs were not safe and they would need as much savings as they could if they wanted to keep their houses. At this point, even people who were relatively safe or who had never applied for a home equity loan started tightening their belts and reconsidering expected purchases. Now the crisis began really touching people who weren't even in the housing market. People who had never had anything to do with bad mortgages and had lived within their means found that they could no longer get credit. Credit card rates increased across the board. People were losing jobs right and left, and even families with savings couldn't afford the loss of income for long. With fewer and fewer companies hiring and more and more layoffs, the number of people unable and unwilling to spend just kept increasing. Then even large companies started going bankrupt (Circuit City, Mervyn's, etc.) and more jobs were lost. Anyone who took out their home equity loan to start a business was faced with a hostile market. More foreclosures ensued.

At this point, the cycle has gone on long enough that the entire country developed a recession mindset. Most people don't feel comfortable spending money, and rightly so. Secure jobs are in high demand. As more secure jobs start flooding the marketplace (from the stimulus package, for instance), the economy will improve slightly, but it will take a while for people to feel comfortable spending again, and the economy won't change until that happens.

Whew! That was long! I'm glad I wrote it down though. It's hard to keep track of it all without seeing it. It's easy to forget how complicated this all is. I think I may also have some parts wrong, but not many. This is the gist of it and I am satisfied. I hope I didn't miss anything.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Emotional turmoil

I feel so crappy right now. Yesterday, I found out that my master teacher Nicole is out sick for the rest of the semester. Now they're looking for a replacement teacher. I am the obvious first choice since I know all the students and taught them already for a while. I think I've already made my decision not to do it. It's an incredibly bad idea for my personal well being. I have to finish PACT, my master's project, the tech portfolio, and plan for a wedding. I don't have that kind of time. But if not helping out is such a good idea for my personal well being, then why do I feel so much like crap? I just feel awful for my algebra 2 students. I saw who their sub is (at least for today)- it's a random foreign language teacher who subbed for Philippe's alg 2 once- he doesn't know any of the math. It's sad to think they're not going to be getting a good education this year, but when I think of individuals, I start feeling really awful. Rosa is probably really scared right now, and that makes her angry and lash out. She knows that she needs to know this stuff and there's no way she can do it. I can only imagine her frustration. And then there's Lannysha- she could have passed second semester and have her first semester grade bumped up to a C retroactively. Nicole would have done it. And Lannysha was working so hard at the end. She could have done it, but I don't think she'll be able to now. And then there's Langston. I have so many regrets about Langston. He worked so hard- he went from doing no homework to doing most of it. I called his mom and told her how great he was doing, but I never really told him. I think he might have known. And then when he cheated on a test, I couldn't bear to call his mom (and he had done well on the parts of the test where I don't think he was cheating), so I gave him a zero on the parts where he had cheated, spoke to him, and then let it slide. And he felt so awful. He apologized, sincerely. I could tell he really meant it. And he promised not to cheat again. And then kept doing all his homework. And then he got a 3 out of 25 on the next quiz. Why didn't I follow up on that? He was doing so well! And he stopped doing homework after that. If i could do it over, I would have handled that so differently. This could be my chance to handle it differently. They're still there and they need a teacher.

It would have been so much easier if this had been a clean break, if the class hadn't lingered on after I left. There are so many regrets that I have and there's this horrible could hanging over my head telling me that I have the chance to right those wrongs and cleanse those regrets, but only if I act now. But I really can't act now. I have to graduate, and that's no small task.

I'm not going to do it. I know I'm not. Next year I'll be an even better teacher. I did the best I could in the given circumstances. I really shouldn't regret anything, and honestly I don't. I think I did pretty well there at the end. And all along, I did the best that I could do at the time. But there are so many things I could do better now and maybe that could make up for some of the things I did wrong before. And I feel really bad for my students not getting the education they deserve. They were an amazing group of kids. I really cared about them (still do). I'd even go so far as to say I loved them, and I do not use that word lightly. I remember I didn't tell my grandparents I loved them for a long time as a kid because I wasn't sure if I did. It's not that I was mad at them or anything. They were very important to me, but it took a while before I felt comfortable with the word "love." In the end, I decided it would make them happy and I might love them, so I should just say it. That's probably how it'll be with Steven's mom, who tells me she loves me, but I haven't reciprocated. I might love her. I do like her a lot. But love? Anyway, I feel like I did love my students. There were some who had just started to open up and there were some who were working so hard and there were some that didn't get what they deserved (none of them now). It tears me up to turn my back on them. Dan says that kids can recover from one year of chaos. Two years and they can't, but one year and they can. They'll be a little behind next year, but they'll make it. It just feels so hard to turn away from helping someone you love. My mom always bends over backwards for her loved ones. I want to do the same. But you can't take care of other people unless you can take care of yourself first. You always have to be your first priority. It's a hard, emotional truth, but it is a truth. I'm really not available to help. I think I just have to face it and come to terms with it. I care about these kids a lot, and it might be in their best interest for me to teach them this semester, but I think I have to pass. If I can get a lot of work done this week (and I mean a LOT), then maybe... but it will mean working around the clock. For them, I might be able to do it...

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Dilemma

I'm taking this class right now, Urban Education, that's pretty interesting. Our main assignment in the class is this mapping project where we have to map something in a certain neighborhood. One example she gave was a group who mapped all the pumpkins in a neighborhood around Halloween. It correlated strongly which which areas were higher income. It was pretty interesting. My group has decided to focus a little more around public transportation. We're still a little confused about what we're looking for, but we're making some progress.

The mapping project, however, is not my dilemma. The class as a whole is not a dilemma at all. It's covering some interesting subject matter. The problem is the teacher. I have this class (which happens to be three hours long) right before another class (also 3 hours long, coincidentally), and our teach keeps us late almost every week. The first week, she kept us over by a minute. Ok, fine. It happens. The next week she kept us over by 3, and didn't seem to concerned about it. I came up to her after class and said she really couldn't keep us over like that since half the class (all the MACSMEs) had to go to another class afterwards. She pretty much blew me off in response. "It's only 3 minutes." You know, if I didn't have a class afterwards, I might not be so hard on her, but no, it is not only three minutes when that 10 minute break is all you get.

Even though she blew me off that week, the following week she let us out on time, so I thought maybe she had listened after all. Psych! The week after that she kept us over by 5 minutes! This was the day we started really getting in to racism and white supremacy, so it might be a topic she's really into, but that's no excuse. To make matters even worse, she spends her ill gotten minutes just talking and talking and talking- she never lets up! I raised my hand to ask a question 3 minutes before class ended. She said she noticed my hand and would get to it when she finished her thought. That took 4 minutes. Keep in mind, she had been talking for 15 straight right before that. When she finally finished talking, she said, "You have a question?" I said no. She asked if I was sure and I said "yeah. I'm sure" and I have to admit I said it with every ounce of frustration you can see in this blog. When I said no, it was a little bit of a cross between a "no" and a bitter laugh. She might be so oblivious that she didn't notice, but maybe not. In any event, part of the reason I didn't ask my question was because she was already over by a minute and I was starting to get pissed. So I didn't ask my question, thinking we could finally go, but apparently having no questions meant she should go off on another tirade for another three minutes. I have no idea what she said. I was seeing red by that time. I've stopped bothering to listen while she talks anyway. Most people just surf the internet, except that she told us to put away all laptops today so that "everyone in the room will know you are present. Even if you're taking notes, just take them on a sheet of paper." She also sent out an email asking us to put away cell phones during class or she would call us on it publicly.

My first thoughts, of course, were what a bitch she was, how unhelpful this is to our education, how much she ruining the subject matter by being a total dick, etc. But then I started thinking a little more about the subject matter. This thought is kind of out in left field, but what if she's trying to make us feel like a suppressed minority? We're studying the subtle effects of power and how they impact those without power. She has definitely been exercising her authority in a very coercive manner, ignoring many, many complaints about it. She's trying to quash any forms of passive resistance. She's been filming this movie "The Color of Fear" (the only times she's not talking are when this movie is playing, so I am very grateful), and one of the black people in it wasn't getting through to a white person until he started yelling and screaming. So maybe quiet, subtle complaints aren't working because she doesn't want them to work- what if she's waiting for someone to just yell at her in front of everyone about what a dick she's been...

And here is my dilemma. I have enough common sense to realize how stupid it would be to yell at her if that's not what she was going for. Also, I recognize how improbable it is that she has some sort of grandiose plan to make us feel oppressed and learn to mobilize against an oppressor. But can she really be so dense as to not realize that this is a problem? Can she really ignore so many complaints (I know of at least 4)? She also seems a little full of herself. It would be pretty arrogant to make a stab at being the oppressor in order to teach us all a life lesson.

Ok. I'm not going to accuse her of anything, but I am walking out on her class at 4 exactly next week. I suspect others will follow me, and if they don't they will the week after that. Everyone was so irate after class was over, it was all we could talk about. If I leave 5 minutes earlier than them, and then show up to the next class relaxed and mellow, with no repercussions (I mean, what can she do?), they'll go along the next time for sure.

Sigh. I wish I didn't have to fight so much. I suppose it's only natural that I draw parallels between what we're being taught and the behavior of the teacher teaching it, but in all likelihood, I'd be surprised if she sees the comparison. There are a lot of education professors who don't know the first thing about teaching. She keeps talking about her undergrads, an easily cowed lot, I'm sure. I know I was. But I'm afraid I'm too sassy and full of myself (though perhaps not to the extent that she's full of herself) to let this sort of awful pedagogy slide for long.