I was talking to Dylan the other day and he said I'm the sort of person that people won't be able to imagine I was once young when I'm older. This is a kind of ironic statement because I've been thinking a lot recently about how young I feel. I am the youngest person in my program. I say things the other people don't say (eg, "That blows" or excessive use of the word "totally"). And there's nothing wrong with the stuff I say. It's not even that immature or young sounding. But the thing is, I really watch myself and my language when I'm with them, mostly because I don't think they'd take my standard jokes the way the co-opers or other people who know me well would. And I still don't feel like my language quite fits in. My advisor compared the way I speak to Juno from the movie. Someone else agreed. She was supposed to be a high school student, and she does kind of talk like it. I guess I've got a young sound.
And it's not just with my cohort. Lately I've been struck a lot with the sense that I'm really very young. I've never been ashamed of playing video games, but recently I have gotten the sense that it's a really young activity. I know that's not really true; there are a lot of older people who still play video games. In fact, the average age has been steadily increasing.
On a tangent, that stuff about the average age of gamers increasing makes a lot of sense. When they first came out, video games were pretty challenging and required a totally new set of skills. Pressing buttons with careful timing was not a skill our grandparents had to learn. Now little kids are always learning new things. They kind of suck at everything they do because they're learning how to do all of it. They're learning how to walk, how to pour milk without spilling, how to behave at the dinner table, etc. All the commonplace things that are easy to us now, they still struggle with. So they're a lot more used to struggle. They're a lot more willing to engage in struggle because it's all around them. Everything they do is hard, so it doesn't matter that much if they get some new hard thing to do. This could be why kids are better at learning new things than adults; they're generally not afraid to try and they often won't stop after the first few failed attempts, if for no other reason that that they're accustomed to failing at everything.
So video games aren't really that hard to learn. The earliest ones could be incredibly challenging, but video game designers have wised up since then. They need to make games just hard enough to be satisfying when when you beat them. And there are also fewer consequences for losing. Back in the day, losing meant starting over from square one. Now losing means starting a 15 minute level over again, or reloading a recent save. Failure is still disappointing. It always is for anybody, no matter how few consequences there are. But now failure is less likely to discourage people and cause them to quit.
So even though video games are more attractive and more widespread among kids now than they were when they first came out, the age is still increasing. Video games were originally classified as a little kid's thing and that classification has been a little self fulfilling I think. Some people feel like once they reach a certain age, maybe it's time for them to stop. The people who don't play do tend to look down on video games and cling fast to that "it's a kid's game" mentality, and the condescension, I've found, gets worse with age. But video games are not really a kid's thing. It just makes sense that people would only be interested in starting as a child because adults are so unaccustomed to failure (most people get to be pretty good at avoiding it). So all the new recruits are young, but there are some older veterans who are still at it (such as me!). These veterans are still at it because video games really are fun for all ages. You just have to accept a certain degree of failure initially, but most people can't get past that.
Though to get back to my main point, even though the average age of gamers is increasing, there are still a lot of older people who do not play. Older gamers are still a minority. I imagine that the demographic will steadily change over time, especially as video game ads start trying to target different demographics (look at how popular the Wii is), but for right now, video games still carry a stigma of being a younger person's activity. Maybe that's part of the reason I feel so young. I flaunt some of my attributes that people consider young. I mean, I did a report for class on video games. None of my other colleagues are doing that. In fact, some of them are doing reports on how video games are harmful. When someone mentions that video games kill your brain, I often disagree. I'm actually fairly confident that I'm right on this one, but that doesn't mean that I don't get affiliated with something that is classified as a kid's toy.
But that's not really the only reason I feel young. Some of my mannerisms strike me as a little young too. I said something to Jake today about something that could have gone better in class and I said it in front of a few of middle school students who didn't know me or who I was. I was a little sheepish and a little like "I guess I messed up," which in retrospect is also not a very adult thing to do, but afterwards one of the kids asked me if I was a student. That happened once when I was observing in high school, but I really wasn't expecting that to happen in middle school. I even dress up for school in part to prevent that! Sheesh!
But that's still not the only reason I feel young. I'm also arrogant like a little kid. I've got a little kid's confidence and misunderstanding of the situation. I've heard that ignorance begets confidence, and I definitely believe it. I first started teaching pretty sure that I'd be able to explain things great so the kids would understand it. It's a lot more complicated than that. I've been kind of down about my teaching lately. It's on the low end of mediocre. I'm not being a pessimist or anything. It's true. On the bright side, I used to be piss poor. Now I'm almost mediocre. Actually, I think that shows pretty sharp improvement over a short period of time, but I'm still not pleased with being mediocre. I will get it eventually. This isn't something you just start out being good at (much like video games in that respect). I'm still chafing a little at being average. I've never really been average, so I don't like the feeling. I feel confident that I'll improve a lot, and I'm not going to stop when the going gets tough either. If there's one thing I've learned from grad school it's that you have to keep struggling with something and not quitting in order to learn. I'll eventually get to be good enough that I can handle what goes on in my classroom and that's going to be really satisfying when it happens. But until then I have to deal with mediocrity.
Perhaps that's another reason I've been feeling so young lately. Nothing makes you feel mature like competency and nothing makes you feel young like incompetency. I am in a situation right now that's very similar to when I was young. I'm struggling to do well and only managing to do ok. In college, I struggled to do well and I did. In high school I struggled to do well and I did so in some classes and did ok in others. At the end of high school, I was convinced that I wasn't really into history or science since I wasn't so hot at those subjects. It's weird to think that now. I'm still not that well versed in history. I've forgotten a lot of the dates and the details, but I also recognize that it's just a matter of understanding the situation thoroughly, not as a collection of details, but as a cohesive scenario. I think I could do it now. And as for science, pshaw. I use that stuff all the time. I would kick high school science's ass with ease if I had it do over again. Sometimes I think back to high school and wish I could go through it again, just so that I could pwn it so hard. The SATs wouldn't have shit on me (now there's a young phrase). I could totally wow the teachers and get kickass recommendations. I think a lot of them found me immature and unruly. Since high school, I've totally mastered the fake, proper, overly respectful attitude I use around conservatives. Even though it's total bullshit, conservatives want to believe that shit, so they eat it right up. And this is another example of me feeling young. Sometimes when I'm observing Jake in his 4th period class (so that I have material for my 2nd period class), he'll ask a question and I'll have to stop myself from raising my hand to respond. I feel like a student. I feel like a little kid. I feel really young.
When I was younger, I was always being told to grow up or act my age. It frustrated me a lot because I was always convinced that I was acting my age. I just happened to be at an age when people are giddy and silly and talk out of turn. Right now, there's no one telling me to grow up, but I nonetheless feel a lot of pressure to do so. Perhaps it's just become internalized by now, or perhaps I just don't like the feeling of incompetence and not knowing what's going on that goes hand in hand with being young, but I think I need to just grin and bear it. I do not think it would serve me well to "grow up" at this time. I really don't want to forget what it's like to be a kid. As it is, I don't really know what it's like to be a real struggling student with low confidence in their intelligence. It's true that I thought there were some subjects that I was better at than others, but even in my difficult subjects, it's not like I did that bad and I never really thought it was beyond me. Some students are really bad at math and I can't quite relate to them as well. So I've already got some issues relating to some students; I shouldn't make it worse by trying to grow up faster than I should. I've known people who couldn't stand being told to grow up and then proceeded to do so, beyond their maturity level. It didn't exactly make them well rounded individuals *cough*Matoots*cough*. If you work so hard to change yourself like that, you become really negative toward people who don't, especially since they usually look happier than you. I can hold off on growing up. I don't exactly have a rapport with my students, but that might come later when I actually know how to manage a class. By growing up now, I might lose that potential even if I do eventually get the classroom management down.
So I guess I'll be feeling young for a while longer. It's a little unpleasant really. Being young has a lot of unpleasant feelings of not really understanding the world around you. Being young makes up for it though by having very few responsibilities and requirements. Now I feel young, but I still have all kind of responsibilities and things to do. Balls. But I just have to grin and bear it a while longer. That maturity will come at some point. I just have to be patient about it.
Friday, May 23, 2008
Thursday, May 15, 2008
Remorse
I feel a little bad about Jen and Patricia. When I first heard about it, I was so angry and really wanted there to be some sort of reaction. But now I feel like the reaction was too strong and I feel bad about it. I don't think that the punishment we finally agreed upon was too strong. I think it's pretty fair actually. They have to pay money for all the alcohol they stole and then each has to do 4 hours of workshift on top of that. And the workshift has to be unpleasant, gross workshifts that no one else would do. That seems actually kinda fair to me, but when I was thinking of gross shifts for them to do, I started feeling bad about it. I mean, cleaning out compost bins is so gross. Scrubbing toilets: also gross. I mean, all these things they have to do really really blow. So I feel bad about how we, as managers, handled it with the house. Yes, what they did was fucked up, but deciding on fining without talking to them first, calling an emergency house meeting to deal with the appeals, and then changing our minds after that because we reached an agreement feels so stupid and sketchy. We made a spectacle of the whole thing. I kind of wanted the house to know how sketchy these two had been, but the whole public announcement thing feels like a bit much now. This rumor would have gotten out one way or another.
-------
Ok. I didn't have time to finish this when I started and now it's over a week later. I have other things I want to blog about and this unfinished blog post is stopping me. So I'm going to finish it up super promptly. I changed my mind. Yeah, they were really sketchy, but they did feel bad about it and the punishment didn't fit the crime. Hearing them speak in person changed my mind and made me feel a little ashamed of myself. The end.
-------
Ok. I didn't have time to finish this when I started and now it's over a week later. I have other things I want to blog about and this unfinished blog post is stopping me. So I'm going to finish it up super promptly. I changed my mind. Yeah, they were really sketchy, but they did feel bad about it and the punishment didn't fit the crime. Hearing them speak in person changed my mind and made me feel a little ashamed of myself. The end.
Monday, May 12, 2008
Thieving Bitches
As you might guess from the title, this blog entry is going to be about thieving bitches. Two people from my house stole an assload of alcohol from our house during special dinner. I'm talking about three handles of hard liquor, 5 bottles of wine, and 10 bottles of champagne. Then they had a party with some friends where they drank all of our alcohol. All of the numbers are estimates. I don't know for sure how much they stole. This was the amount initially quoted to me by the person who ratted them out. The managers discussed this issue at length tonight to decide what we should do about it. Let me just say, I was a touch irate. We ended up deciding to fine them each $85. Jesse informed them of this decision, but they protested the fine. Below is the email Jesse sent to the other managers:
Hey, all,
So Roxy and I had a conversation with Jen and Patricia. While they have admitted to stealing some alcohol the night of special dinner, they say they did not steal as much as we say--the Jim Beam Black and maybe 5-10 bottles of wine/champagne. Also, that they did not do it with malicious intent, nor were they gloating at their party about it. I suggested that at least half of the fines that we quoted to them were "uncooperative fines" in that they were independent of the alcohol that was taken and more dependent on the fact that they took it and that we as a management team then had to deal, discuss, and stress because of it. They will hopefully be coming to me or Roxy tomorrow with a number that they would like it reduced to--I gave them no suggestions. I just wanted to create a forum now to discuss how we feel about reducing those fines in light of this new information, so that we hopefully can come to a conclusion before the meeting and allow them to contest tomorrow if necessary.
Here's my two cents, since I probably won't have much time tomorrow to discuss:
When I first talked to Jen, she said all they took were a couple bottles of wine. Patricia threw in the Jim Beam. The number kept growing that they'd confess to as I talked to them. I do understand that we are still way overquoting what they probably took, but again, we spent 30 minutes or so discussing this with each other, and Roxy and I spent more talking to them afterward, and now we're spending even more time discussing, which should all be factored in to this uncooperative fine. The fact that they did this is reprehensible and should also be a part of what they pay for. The point is that we need to make this seem like it is not being dealt with lightly.
That being said, "uncooperative fines" are always arbitrary and we may be quoting a steep one here, especially since we're removing the option to make it up with workshift. I could see $60-75 each as a viable option. Or possibly that they each must pay $30-$40 to cover the alcohol (that goes back into the social budget) and then each get 3 hours of uncooperative workshift hour fines to cover the uncooperative act.
Any thoughts?
Jesse
And here is my response to Jesse's email:
So you said this forum would be to talk about their fines in light of this new information, but I want to go over really quickly what the new information is:
1: Jen and Patricia have confessed to stealing alcohol
2: They claim they didn't steal with malicious intent
3: They claim they didn't gloat about stealing our alcohol
As for point 1, regardless of the quantity, stealing our house's alcohol during a social event is an incredibly selfish and disrespectful act. Because they have confessed, we know that our accusations are correct, if not in degree, then at least in substance.
As for point 2, I don't know what it means to steal without malicious intent. I don't know why they thought they needed to sneak away the alcohol if they weren't doing a shady thing. I sincerely doubt that they didn't realize what they were doing. They knew this was a horrible thing to do and they did it anyway, over and over again throughout the night. Even though they knew it was wrong, they didn't return the alcohol the next day. They didn't even enjoy it quietly by themselves. Instead they threw a party with it. If that isn't gloating, I don't know what is. Did they actively laugh about how proud they were to steal from us? I believe so, but ultimately that doesn't matter. We aren't fining them because they bragged. We are fining them because they stole from the members of this house for their own personal gain. We are fining them because that was incredibly disrespectful of the house, their fellow housemates, and their managers (especially social). The "new" information we've gotten from them doesn't actually change much except to confirm my beliefs. They definitely stole. They knew enough about their actions to hide them. They had too much alcohol for personal consumption, and they had to throw a party in celebration of what they did in order to get rid of all of it.
I think some extra thought on this subject adds one more point of new information: Jen and Patricia are liars. Their claims about not being malicious and not gloating don't make any sense. Their constantly increasing estimates of what they stole doesn't add to their credibility either.
So what do I think about reducing their fines now that I have this new information? I don't have to think about it very much at all.
Rosemary
Well that pretty much covers the situation. Feel the anger radiating off of my email? It burns so goooooood...
Hey, all,
So Roxy and I had a conversation with Jen and Patricia. While they have admitted to stealing some alcohol the night of special dinner, they say they did not steal as much as we say--the Jim Beam Black and maybe 5-10 bottles of wine/champagne. Also, that they did not do it with malicious intent, nor were they gloating at their party about it. I suggested that at least half of the fines that we quoted to them were "uncooperative fines" in that they were independent of the alcohol that was taken and more dependent on the fact that they took it and that we as a management team then had to deal, discuss, and stress because of it. They will hopefully be coming to me or Roxy tomorrow with a number that they would like it reduced to--I gave them no suggestions. I just wanted to create a forum now to discuss how we feel about reducing those fines in light of this new information, so that we hopefully can come to a conclusion before the meeting and allow them to contest tomorrow if necessary.
Here's my two cents, since I probably won't have much time tomorrow to discuss:
When I first talked to Jen, she said all they took were a couple bottles of wine. Patricia threw in the Jim Beam. The number kept growing that they'd confess to as I talked to them. I do understand that we are still way overquoting what they probably took, but again, we spent 30 minutes or so discussing this with each other, and Roxy and I spent more talking to them afterward, and now we're spending even more time discussing, which should all be factored in to this uncooperative fine. The fact that they did this is reprehensible and should also be a part of what they pay for. The point is that we need to make this seem like it is not being dealt with lightly.
That being said, "uncooperative fines" are always arbitrary and we may be quoting a steep one here, especially since we're removing the option to make it up with workshift. I could see $60-75 each as a viable option. Or possibly that they each must pay $30-$40 to cover the alcohol (that goes back into the social budget) and then each get 3 hours of uncooperative workshift hour fines to cover the uncooperative act.
Any thoughts?
Jesse
And here is my response to Jesse's email:
So you said this forum would be to talk about their fines in light of this new information, but I want to go over really quickly what the new information is:
1: Jen and Patricia have confessed to stealing alcohol
2: They claim they didn't steal with malicious intent
3: They claim they didn't gloat about stealing our alcohol
As for point 1, regardless of the quantity, stealing our house's alcohol during a social event is an incredibly selfish and disrespectful act. Because they have confessed, we know that our accusations are correct, if not in degree, then at least in substance.
As for point 2, I don't know what it means to steal without malicious intent. I don't know why they thought they needed to sneak away the alcohol if they weren't doing a shady thing. I sincerely doubt that they didn't realize what they were doing. They knew this was a horrible thing to do and they did it anyway, over and over again throughout the night. Even though they knew it was wrong, they didn't return the alcohol the next day. They didn't even enjoy it quietly by themselves. Instead they threw a party with it. If that isn't gloating, I don't know what is. Did they actively laugh about how proud they were to steal from us? I believe so, but ultimately that doesn't matter. We aren't fining them because they bragged. We are fining them because they stole from the members of this house for their own personal gain. We are fining them because that was incredibly disrespectful of the house, their fellow housemates, and their managers (especially social). The "new" information we've gotten from them doesn't actually change much except to confirm my beliefs. They definitely stole. They knew enough about their actions to hide them. They had too much alcohol for personal consumption, and they had to throw a party in celebration of what they did in order to get rid of all of it.
I think some extra thought on this subject adds one more point of new information: Jen and Patricia are liars. Their claims about not being malicious and not gloating don't make any sense. Their constantly increasing estimates of what they stole doesn't add to their credibility either.
So what do I think about reducing their fines now that I have this new information? I don't have to think about it very much at all.
Rosemary
Well that pretty much covers the situation. Feel the anger radiating off of my email? It burns so goooooood...
Tuesday, May 6, 2008
Homeless Turnover
Something that has occurred to me recently is that all the homeless people that I see now vs when I first came to Berkeley are different. I'll admit I didn't pay really close attention before, but the more attention grabbing (read creepiest) ones are all gone. It's not like there's one or two who have remained constant. They're all gone. It makes me wonder about what happened to them. Did they get arrested for three petty offenses under 3 strikes and are now spending the rest of their lives in jail? Did they finally seek some help and are struggling to get back on their feet? Did they move to another city? Did they die? I don't know, but it does make me wonder a little about what it's like to be homeless. Nothing must be constant. People are always coming and going and sometimes never coming back until one day you don't come back either. I guess having a home keeps you and your life constant. I guess I never realized how unstable it was to be homeless. I mean, homeless people have always been a constant in Berkeley. They're always there. But they're all different people. I wonder how long someone could last. It seems 4 years is more than anyone could make. It seems like an awful short time to be able to stay in one place.
I'm working on shorter blog entries and honestly I don't have a lot more to say, so I think I'll end it here. May your musings be more pleasant than mine.
I'm working on shorter blog entries and honestly I don't have a lot more to say, so I think I'll end it here. May your musings be more pleasant than mine.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
My 100th post
Hi, faithful readers! It's been a while since my last post. Sorry about that. Mostly that's because I knew this would be my 100th post and got a little intimidated by that. I thought I had to have something really compelling. Well I have several topics in mind that are moderately compelling. This blog could really be a mighty ramble if I let it. There are a bunch of things I could talk about. I'll list off a few of them here to get my bearings (and also so I don't forget the topics later if I choose to write about them).
-So pissed at my research methods class (and teacher)
--This could be a follow up to the post about how much she hurt my feelings after the colloquium.
-The joys and hardships of teaching
--I'd mostly talk about the hardships because those are standing out most saliently to me right now.
-An interesting philosophical rant about how the world is continuous, yet we can only understand things in discrete intervals.
--All of life is an attempt to break into intervals something that is actually continuous.
--Don't worry I'll explain this better later. This one I'm going to get to for sure.
-Feeling strained/sick and possible explanations.
--I think it's a mental thing.
-Housing for next year.
-Fuck board and fuck trying to get something done at the central level.
-Being stressed by all the different things I have to do.
--I have a lot of different things to do for each aspect of my life (co-op, teaching, school where I'm the student, finding a place to live, etc.). This is way worse than just having a lot to do in one aspect of my life and getting to chill in other respects.
Sheesh that's a lot. I could write a blog entry about any of these. I guess I'll start with stress since I'm definitely feeling that right now.
So I have about a million things to do, things that have to get done too. And I know they won't get done without me. It's just hard trying to keep track of and remember everything. I have to start looking in to getting an HDTV. It was my motion and I do want one. I'm just not thrilled about hunting around and doing the work right now. However, the sooner I do it, the better. I should probably do it this weekend to keep people's minds on it or something. I don't want this to stagnate. Also, since I'm moving out before too long, I might as well get it and enjoy it. But I really don't want that one extra thing on my plate right now.
I have to go to board in 20 minutes or so (I'll be pausing partway through this post) so that I can argue my point with all my might only to get shot down. I honestly don't think I have a proposal that would pass. But I have to try. Ugh. It pisses me off because I really think it's important and necessary and I'm trying to convince people whose job it is to disbelieve me and find a way that it is not necessary. The odds are stacked against me and it's not going to happen. And I still have to go through all the effort when I know it's futile. I want summer managers to get more comp. I'm going to propose this to the people who want to balance the budget and cut everything they can. I know it's pretty hopeless, but I have to try. I have to show that I've done the research on a central level before I can bring it to the house. And besides, this is something that should be addressed on a central level. It just makes me so mad. I might have had a chance when Jesse G was still on FiCom (Finance Committee) since he was thinking about being house manager this summer and it would be a lot better for him if he had full comp. But that lazy fuck transferred off of FiCom because it was too much work. He's such a shitty board rep. He's constantly talking about how his manager reports don't matter and no one should listen to him. He talks big about all the great stuff he's going to do, and it never happens. He got us to move our manager meetings earlier so he could screen cult movies at 10 after snack. Of course that never happened. He tried once and no one showed up because it's a fucking stupid idea. So now I have to leave Fremont a half hour earlier for absolutely no good reason.
Sigh. I don't mind Jesse really at all. I don't think laziness is really a personality flaw unless people are counting on you and you flake or something. And that's not really the case with him. I'm just angry about a lot of things and it makes it easier to blow up. It's especially easy to blow up at the guy who stole a half hour from me every week for no good reason. And I'll have reason to be angry again after the FiCom meeting in another 10 minutes when my motion gets shot down after they make me wait a half hour for no good reason. My expectations are so low. It's best that way I suppose. That way I won't feel so bad when FiCom makes the wrong decision. And then I can try to get something done at the house instead of at central level. I'll have a battle there too, but that's a fight that I think I might be able to win. It's so frustrating to walk into what I know is a losing battle. Kid of like in "To Kill a Mockingbird" where Atticus fights for the black guy even when he knows the jury will decide against them. I don't know where that high school moment came from, but I think the analogy is apt. I rarely fight losing battles. I like to win and it feels so pointless to work so hard for nothing. My time and energy are worth more to me than that. But, just like with Atticus, I think there might be some point here too. Nothing so grandiose as his point, but a point nonetheless. I'm going to pack up my notes (I can't believe I actually have notes for this shit) and be on my way. I'll continue writing when I get back.
*********************************************
Well I didn't continue writing when I got back. I messed around for a while instead. It is now Friday and yet again I have very little time to write, not nearly enough to do all these subjects justice. But because this is my 100th post, I'm not going to post until it's all done. Yeah, this one's going to be a doozy.
So back to board and FiCom. So I was there for an hour. They didn't get to me immediately, but it was other Stebbins stuff on the agenda, so it was at least interesting to listen to. Jesse F brought a motion to reduce our parking which passed by a slim margin. So at least there's some justice.
And after listening to my proposal for a while (we had a good discussion, actually) it was voted down unanimously on account of not having enough information. If the houses were over budget, things might have looked better. But I didn't have that information. I do now. It's going to be voted on again at the next Board meeting in a week once I have a more concrete plan. I still need more information from the individual houses to form a plan.
Sigh. This is sucking up too much of my life. I have too many stresses right now to be pouring effort into something I will never see the results of. I have argued eloquently and valiantly and perhaps it's time I quit. But I don't really think I can now. It's like the last leg of a marathon. If I can get things together in this week, then the comp will actually increase for this summer. I won't be a manager this summer, so it doesn't really affect me, but I still think it's necessary. Yeah... *reminisces* Last night at FiCom, someone said this might be necessary for Stebbins, but they weren't sure this was something coop-wide that should be brought to FiCom and board. I think I responded to that really well. I spoke about how I thought bringing this motion to board was probably futile and a waste of time and no matter what the outcome, I was going to bring this to my house afterwards, but I still thought it was necessary and I thought it did apply to more houses than just mine. I said it all in a really quiet voice too, the kind that makes people listen closer. Afterwards a couple people thanked me for bringing the motion and snapped appreciatively (only in the coops). They were all really nice actually and it keeps me from being too bitter about the situation. It also makes me really want to keep pushing since a lot of people explicitly expressed that they thought there should be a change. I wasn't able to get something through since I had no motion (a rather overwhelming obstacle), but I was at least compelling. Hopefully I can be compelling when the actual voting happens.
******************************************************
Ok. I had to stop at the point above to go to Fremont for the weekend and I didn't do any writing while I was there. So now it's Monday. And I've lost my train of thought. Luckily, I can go back and reread where I was. One moment...
Ok. To follow up with changing comp, not much has happened since Friday. This is a little concerning since I still want to meet with Dave before Thursday, but hey, whatcha gonna do?
I think now that I'm a little less incensed about board, this is a good time to segue into another one of my topics. Perhaps the best one would be how much I hate my research methods class. I really really hate it. Norma pushes us to come up with a research question when I don't even know yet what I'm interested in researching. The rational side of me says that I'm not exactly going to have a better idea later if I don't push myself to think about it now. But on the other hand, if I get pushed to come up with something I'm not passionate about too soon, then that just means all my work will be for nothing since I'll end up scrapping it all. A lot of the 2nd years told me they scrapped the question they started with and had to start all over. A couple people even started their master's project this semester. They had to use other people's data instead of collecting their own though. Which I wouldn't mind honestly. But anyway, I saw the point in choosing a specific research question and getting some practice with it. Maybe it was short sighted of me, but I chose something I am interested in, but unfortunately is a little hard to collect data for. Actually, it's not that hard to collect data for it. It's only hard to collect observational data. It works fine with interviews and surveys. So of course, she gives us an assignment where we have to collect observational data relating to our thesis. What a waste. It's busy work and I know it. My research does not lend itself to this form of data collection at all. I'm just being told to waste my time to practice a method of data collection I may never use. It's really frustrating. Yeah it's great to get some practice, but it's also a waste of time if I have no motivation or reason to do it. And then when the time comes for us to do surveys (something I might actually be able to use for my research), she has us work in groups to come up with out survey. Why was that necessary? Now I'm pretty much guaranteed not to get the question I want. So there's no way this is going to be helpful to me. So once again, I have no reason whatsoever to be motivated. For the interview assignment, I guess I'm a little more motivated for that. But I still don't really care. I know it's just a little practice for me to realize how shitty transcribing a 10 minute interview can be. You know, I was willing to take people's word for it. Everyone says it sucks. I believe them. Really I do. So do I have to do this bullshit? Sure do. Sigh. I hate this class. And now I have like a month's worth of work to do because I just haven't been able to get the motivation to do anything for the class for about a month. Yeah, I dug myself into a hole, but I don't regret it that much. It just means I'll rush the assignments when I finally do get around to them (thus devoting a more appropriate fraction of my time to this debacle of a class).
----------
Ok. So things got a little out of hand with this post. It is now April 24th and I see that I started this some time ago. Sorry. Right now I'm going to finish it. I'm going to just leave the rest of this hanging (perhaps updates on the above will come later), but for now I'm going to move into my last piece of this blog post- the idea about discrete vs continuous. It's an interesting idea I've had in mind for a while.
Now for some background: something discrete is something you can count. For instance, the number of cars you have. Let's say you're ridiculously rich and have an enormous number of cars. Even if it's a huge number, it can still be counted in discrete units. Perhaps for a more realistic example, you can look at grains of rice. There may be so many of them that you would never bother to count them, but they're all still individual, countable units.
Something continuous, on the other hand, is something you cannot separate and count. For instance, water cannot really be separated and counted (or any liquid for that matter). It all blends together. It may form droplets, but those droplets aren't really separate. You can't isolate a droplet unless you remove it from the rest of your liquid. And as soon as it touches that liquid again, that particular droplet is lost.
Now those among my readers who know what a liter is may protest that liquids can be measured in discrete amounts. We can measure their volume. This is an interesting point I'd like to revisit, so let's keep it in mind.
Now that I've laid out the distinction between discrete and continuous, I'm going to make the claim that continuous things are much more complex than discrete ones. The idea of something continuous where you cannot make divisions into groupings or categories is very difficult for people. With a bucket of water, you cannot distinguish one part of the water from another; it's all one big mass.
But perhaps you could say the same about the rice since every grain is the same. So let's look at a situation similar to the rice (i.e. discrete) where not every "grain" is the same. I might as well choose an example close to my own heart, video games. There are a discrete number of video games in the world. I wouldn't even think of counting them, but I know that it would be possible to count them and tell you the number of existing video games. Now these video games can be easily divided in categories. There are cartridge games vs disc games. There are playstation games vs Wii games. There are games titled Super Mario Galaxy and games titled Super Smash Brothers Brawl. They can be very clearly counted and very clearly categorized. There is no video game that is in both categories. If it is Mario Galaxy, it is not Brawl. If it is a cartridge game, it is not on a dvd disc. Things can get a little messier when you try to classify them into genres, but I would say that classification is based upon the content of the game (which I claim is not discrete from the content of other games) and not on the physical game itself.
So now we have a discrete group of objects and can see that it is easy to divide up and classify in different ways depending on how you want to split up all the video games. So now let's look at a continuous group of objects that differ and see if we can divide that up at all. Probably one of the simplest continuous groups is color. A finding which has been tested by people studying perception of color all around the world is that there is a core idea of most basic colors. For instance, there is a core red. There is a particular color that people would say is more red than other shades of red. A dark burgundy color might fall into the red category, but it is not the core, prototypical red. So let's consider our categories to be red, orange, yellow, green, blue, purple, brown, black, and white. This is actually more basic color divisions than most people around the world make. But we could make more divisions still. Let's say we came across a shade of gray that was perfectly in between black and white. Which category would we put it in? If we couldn't decide (and since the categorization would be arbitrary if we did), we could create another category, gray. There. Problem solved. But what if we found something perfectly in between green and blue, perhaps some sort of teal color? Well we could create another category, teal. Unfortunately, for any division I could make into categories, I could also find something in between those two categories. It might get so fine grained that I would stop caring, but I could still find it. There are no obvious divisions in between colors. You might look at a red color and say it was nothing like a greenish blue, but even though there are differences, it is difficult to draw boundary lines in between them. Sometimes in frustration, we create other categories like teal or gray, but those are unfortunately arbitrary as well. In fact, there are so many difficult to classify colors, that our language has developed a construction to deal with that. If something is in between red and orange, but looks a little more orange than red, we say it is reddish orange. If it fell on the red side of our arbitrary boundary, we would say it was orangish red. If it fell in between so closely that we were unable to tell which category it was, we would create a new name like teal.
So now we have looked at a continuous category with many different objects and found that it is difficult to divide up. So why do we divide it then? That should be obvious to most people. We need to be able to talk about and refer to different colors, so we created other words for them. If I want to paint my house a pale blue, I have to be able to tell someone. If I want someone to cut the red wire and not the green one, it is exceedingly important that I tell them which color to cut. So these categorizations and divisions are arbitrary, but it doesn't make them any less necessary for functioning in life. This is why continuous things are much more complex than discrete things. No matter what we are dealing with, if it has significant variation, we will need to be able to talk about that variation. When the thing we are talking about is discrete, it is easy to divide it up and discuss without ambiguity on any instances of that sort of object. When we are dealing with something continuous, we can still divide it up such that our divisions will work for quite a few cases, but there will always be items that fall in between our boundaries and are hard to classify simply because they are continuous.
Perhaps this is a good time to bring back the example of water divided into cups and liters so that it can be measured based on volume. It is very useful to be able to measure water, or any liquid. How else could we package drinks fairly? How else could we cook in the right proportions? But those divisions are slightly arbitrary as well. If you filled a measuring cup to the 2/3 mark with milk, you would say it was 2/3 full, but it probably wouldn't be exactly 2/3 full. You could get an eyedropper and add one more drop of milk and still claim pretty accurately that it was 2/3 full. You could probably add 50 more drops without breaking a sweat. In fact, the cup could be 3/4 full and you probably wouldn't care. You might just say it was close enough and go on with your cooking. 2/3 is a category as well and since it is dividing something continuous, it is hard to be perfectly precise. Perhaps you could have an exceptionally well calibrated machine to measure the precise volume, but even that would only be accurate up to a certain number of decimal places. However it is probably accurate enough for our needs, and since our needs were the only reason we made the arbitrary divisions in the first place, it's not really a big deal that it's not "perfectly" accurate.
I hate to inform my loyal readers, but all of this discussion so far has only been the buildup to my main point. I've given an example of continuous and an example of discrete without going into which might be more common. I believe continuous categories are far, far, more common than discrete ones. Since we divide both into sub classifications, there may be some things which we might think are discrete, but are actually continuous. In fact, I think most people just take for granted that many continuous things are discrete without realizing they're actually continuous, or perhaps glossing over some of the hard to categorize cases that are usually the first sign that something is continuous. This lack of realization is a real problem. It leads people to reason incorrectly about certain categories, as if the divisions were set in stone and not really a continuum. The most glaring example to me would be people. Yes, there are a discrete number of people right now, but if you consider all the variation there has been over the years dating back into prehistoric times and all the variation that will come from future generations (in theory, an infinite amount), the group of people starts to look a lot more continuous. Everyone has noticed that there are some pretty significant differences between people, so we had to make divisions and classifications to find a way to speak differently about them. Sometimes we divide people based on nationality. Sometimes we divide them based upon gender. Sometimes we divide them based upon race. Many people would say "Either you're French or you're American or you're Japanese and that's that." It is a decent classification. It applies to most cases. But there are some cases that clearly don't fit, such as a person with dual citizenship. With this classification, you also lose all of the variation within a category (as with any categorization really). The same can be said of race. There are many people of mixed race. You can classify a person one way or another, but the division will always be arbitrary. There was a rather famous court case in Louisiana some time ago (perhaps in the 60s or 70s?) where a woman who thought she was white was categorized by the state as being black for having 1/32 of her heritage be black. Which category was she? Most would say that she was white since she herself had not even know about her black ancestry. All of her friends were white. She was outraged at the classification. But the state of Louisiana had decided where the line was to divide the races, and if I remember correctly, they held firm. Clearly, divisions were very important to them. They were important enough for the state to keep records of everyone's heritage dating back to every person's great-great-great grandparents. Some would say the state's division was incorrect since this woman should not have been classified as black, but no matter where the division line had been, it would have been arbitrary. The division line was placed at 1/32 based upon the state's (probably racist) needs. There was a time in US history when Irish people were not white. They were new immigrants, not yet established in the country, and their ways were different from the people already here. So the division line was set with them being on the other side of white. As time went on, more people came to America who were even more different, the differences between white and Irish people started to look less severe. People no longer needed to clearly distinguish Irish from white, so Irish started becoming more and more a part of white. Very many people would claim that racial divisions are merely describing the world, but they do not. The world is not discrete; it is continuous. Any divisions we make are false divisions based upon our needs.
The false divisions are not limited just to people. We classify everything in this manner. Biological divisions between species can be very arbitrary. You may say, either you're a mammal or a bird or a fish or whatever, but there are many cases where those distinctions are not clear. Duck billed platypuses and echidnas are egg laying mammals. Penguins are birds that swim. Dolphins are mammals with no fur (at least none that I know of). Venus fly traps are carnivorous plants. There are debates among people who classify animals about whether it should be based upon their ancestry (what a species descended/evolved from) or whether it should be based upon what can mate and breed with what. And if it's based upon breeding (which I believe is the more standardly accepted classification), what about the case when species A can breed with species B and species B can breed with species C, but species A cannot breed with species C? All of these difficult to classify cases exist. Biologists get together and decide on how these things should be classified, but these classifications do not really exist. Yes, there are differences and yes, it is useful for us to be able to make the distinctions, but the differences are not really there. It is one continuous spectrum. We place boundaries based upon what we need as humans to interact with and speak about something that has variation. Even something presumably obvious like gender has variation. Most people write off that variation as freak incidents, perhaps because they don't want to think that such a neat, discrete category could actually be continuous, but it is. There are transgender people, hermaphrodites, and some would even classify gays as breaking the categories and say that that's an instance of men acting like women and women acting like men (I think comments such as "They're not real men" might be an instance of this). But the classification line, even in a case that seems clear cut like gender, is arbitrary. It is placed based upon people's needs. There have been many cultures where gender, and especially sexuality, have meant different things. Lines have been placed elsewhere, or in some cases, not at all. Who places these lines and how is a more complex question, perhaps to be saved for another blog post, but the truth is, I don't know. The important idea for this post is that the world is not discrete. It is broken up arbitrarily into categories and people do not always realize just how arbitrary those categories are. I think it's important for people to at least be aware of the nature of the world and how our attempts to classify and understand it are not really complete nor accurate. From these misconceptions about reality, a lot of misunderstanding and strife spring up. A little more awareness might help stem them, even if only a little bit.
----------
So that's it. My 100th blog entry. I was going to make it just that continuous/discrete argument, but then I thought it might not be long enough. Looking at it now, I can see that it would have been, but I don't exactly want to go back and erase what I did before, or place it into another entry. The date wouldn't be right. And besides, people have waited so long for another blog entry, they might as well get a big one. I will be far more reasonable in the future and not have such a lengthy entry. Thank you for reading all the way! I hope you liked it!
-So pissed at my research methods class (and teacher)
--This could be a follow up to the post about how much she hurt my feelings after the colloquium.
-The joys and hardships of teaching
--I'd mostly talk about the hardships because those are standing out most saliently to me right now.
-An interesting philosophical rant about how the world is continuous, yet we can only understand things in discrete intervals.
--All of life is an attempt to break into intervals something that is actually continuous.
--Don't worry I'll explain this better later. This one I'm going to get to for sure.
-Feeling strained/sick and possible explanations.
--I think it's a mental thing.
-Housing for next year.
-Fuck board and fuck trying to get something done at the central level.
-Being stressed by all the different things I have to do.
--I have a lot of different things to do for each aspect of my life (co-op, teaching, school where I'm the student, finding a place to live, etc.). This is way worse than just having a lot to do in one aspect of my life and getting to chill in other respects.
Sheesh that's a lot. I could write a blog entry about any of these. I guess I'll start with stress since I'm definitely feeling that right now.
So I have about a million things to do, things that have to get done too. And I know they won't get done without me. It's just hard trying to keep track of and remember everything. I have to start looking in to getting an HDTV. It was my motion and I do want one. I'm just not thrilled about hunting around and doing the work right now. However, the sooner I do it, the better. I should probably do it this weekend to keep people's minds on it or something. I don't want this to stagnate. Also, since I'm moving out before too long, I might as well get it and enjoy it. But I really don't want that one extra thing on my plate right now.
I have to go to board in 20 minutes or so (I'll be pausing partway through this post) so that I can argue my point with all my might only to get shot down. I honestly don't think I have a proposal that would pass. But I have to try. Ugh. It pisses me off because I really think it's important and necessary and I'm trying to convince people whose job it is to disbelieve me and find a way that it is not necessary. The odds are stacked against me and it's not going to happen. And I still have to go through all the effort when I know it's futile. I want summer managers to get more comp. I'm going to propose this to the people who want to balance the budget and cut everything they can. I know it's pretty hopeless, but I have to try. I have to show that I've done the research on a central level before I can bring it to the house. And besides, this is something that should be addressed on a central level. It just makes me so mad. I might have had a chance when Jesse G was still on FiCom (Finance Committee) since he was thinking about being house manager this summer and it would be a lot better for him if he had full comp. But that lazy fuck transferred off of FiCom because it was too much work. He's such a shitty board rep. He's constantly talking about how his manager reports don't matter and no one should listen to him. He talks big about all the great stuff he's going to do, and it never happens. He got us to move our manager meetings earlier so he could screen cult movies at 10 after snack. Of course that never happened. He tried once and no one showed up because it's a fucking stupid idea. So now I have to leave Fremont a half hour earlier for absolutely no good reason.
Sigh. I don't mind Jesse really at all. I don't think laziness is really a personality flaw unless people are counting on you and you flake or something. And that's not really the case with him. I'm just angry about a lot of things and it makes it easier to blow up. It's especially easy to blow up at the guy who stole a half hour from me every week for no good reason. And I'll have reason to be angry again after the FiCom meeting in another 10 minutes when my motion gets shot down after they make me wait a half hour for no good reason. My expectations are so low. It's best that way I suppose. That way I won't feel so bad when FiCom makes the wrong decision. And then I can try to get something done at the house instead of at central level. I'll have a battle there too, but that's a fight that I think I might be able to win. It's so frustrating to walk into what I know is a losing battle. Kid of like in "To Kill a Mockingbird" where Atticus fights for the black guy even when he knows the jury will decide against them. I don't know where that high school moment came from, but I think the analogy is apt. I rarely fight losing battles. I like to win and it feels so pointless to work so hard for nothing. My time and energy are worth more to me than that. But, just like with Atticus, I think there might be some point here too. Nothing so grandiose as his point, but a point nonetheless. I'm going to pack up my notes (I can't believe I actually have notes for this shit) and be on my way. I'll continue writing when I get back.
*********************************************
Well I didn't continue writing when I got back. I messed around for a while instead. It is now Friday and yet again I have very little time to write, not nearly enough to do all these subjects justice. But because this is my 100th post, I'm not going to post until it's all done. Yeah, this one's going to be a doozy.
So back to board and FiCom. So I was there for an hour. They didn't get to me immediately, but it was other Stebbins stuff on the agenda, so it was at least interesting to listen to. Jesse F brought a motion to reduce our parking which passed by a slim margin. So at least there's some justice.
And after listening to my proposal for a while (we had a good discussion, actually) it was voted down unanimously on account of not having enough information. If the houses were over budget, things might have looked better. But I didn't have that information. I do now. It's going to be voted on again at the next Board meeting in a week once I have a more concrete plan. I still need more information from the individual houses to form a plan.
Sigh. This is sucking up too much of my life. I have too many stresses right now to be pouring effort into something I will never see the results of. I have argued eloquently and valiantly and perhaps it's time I quit. But I don't really think I can now. It's like the last leg of a marathon. If I can get things together in this week, then the comp will actually increase for this summer. I won't be a manager this summer, so it doesn't really affect me, but I still think it's necessary. Yeah... *reminisces* Last night at FiCom, someone said this might be necessary for Stebbins, but they weren't sure this was something coop-wide that should be brought to FiCom and board. I think I responded to that really well. I spoke about how I thought bringing this motion to board was probably futile and a waste of time and no matter what the outcome, I was going to bring this to my house afterwards, but I still thought it was necessary and I thought it did apply to more houses than just mine. I said it all in a really quiet voice too, the kind that makes people listen closer. Afterwards a couple people thanked me for bringing the motion and snapped appreciatively (only in the coops). They were all really nice actually and it keeps me from being too bitter about the situation. It also makes me really want to keep pushing since a lot of people explicitly expressed that they thought there should be a change. I wasn't able to get something through since I had no motion (a rather overwhelming obstacle), but I was at least compelling. Hopefully I can be compelling when the actual voting happens.
******************************************************
Ok. I had to stop at the point above to go to Fremont for the weekend and I didn't do any writing while I was there. So now it's Monday. And I've lost my train of thought. Luckily, I can go back and reread where I was. One moment...
Ok. To follow up with changing comp, not much has happened since Friday. This is a little concerning since I still want to meet with Dave before Thursday, but hey, whatcha gonna do?
I think now that I'm a little less incensed about board, this is a good time to segue into another one of my topics. Perhaps the best one would be how much I hate my research methods class. I really really hate it. Norma pushes us to come up with a research question when I don't even know yet what I'm interested in researching. The rational side of me says that I'm not exactly going to have a better idea later if I don't push myself to think about it now. But on the other hand, if I get pushed to come up with something I'm not passionate about too soon, then that just means all my work will be for nothing since I'll end up scrapping it all. A lot of the 2nd years told me they scrapped the question they started with and had to start all over. A couple people even started their master's project this semester. They had to use other people's data instead of collecting their own though. Which I wouldn't mind honestly. But anyway, I saw the point in choosing a specific research question and getting some practice with it. Maybe it was short sighted of me, but I chose something I am interested in, but unfortunately is a little hard to collect data for. Actually, it's not that hard to collect data for it. It's only hard to collect observational data. It works fine with interviews and surveys. So of course, she gives us an assignment where we have to collect observational data relating to our thesis. What a waste. It's busy work and I know it. My research does not lend itself to this form of data collection at all. I'm just being told to waste my time to practice a method of data collection I may never use. It's really frustrating. Yeah it's great to get some practice, but it's also a waste of time if I have no motivation or reason to do it. And then when the time comes for us to do surveys (something I might actually be able to use for my research), she has us work in groups to come up with out survey. Why was that necessary? Now I'm pretty much guaranteed not to get the question I want. So there's no way this is going to be helpful to me. So once again, I have no reason whatsoever to be motivated. For the interview assignment, I guess I'm a little more motivated for that. But I still don't really care. I know it's just a little practice for me to realize how shitty transcribing a 10 minute interview can be. You know, I was willing to take people's word for it. Everyone says it sucks. I believe them. Really I do. So do I have to do this bullshit? Sure do. Sigh. I hate this class. And now I have like a month's worth of work to do because I just haven't been able to get the motivation to do anything for the class for about a month. Yeah, I dug myself into a hole, but I don't regret it that much. It just means I'll rush the assignments when I finally do get around to them (thus devoting a more appropriate fraction of my time to this debacle of a class).
----------
Ok. So things got a little out of hand with this post. It is now April 24th and I see that I started this some time ago. Sorry. Right now I'm going to finish it. I'm going to just leave the rest of this hanging (perhaps updates on the above will come later), but for now I'm going to move into my last piece of this blog post- the idea about discrete vs continuous. It's an interesting idea I've had in mind for a while.
Now for some background: something discrete is something you can count. For instance, the number of cars you have. Let's say you're ridiculously rich and have an enormous number of cars. Even if it's a huge number, it can still be counted in discrete units. Perhaps for a more realistic example, you can look at grains of rice. There may be so many of them that you would never bother to count them, but they're all still individual, countable units.
Something continuous, on the other hand, is something you cannot separate and count. For instance, water cannot really be separated and counted (or any liquid for that matter). It all blends together. It may form droplets, but those droplets aren't really separate. You can't isolate a droplet unless you remove it from the rest of your liquid. And as soon as it touches that liquid again, that particular droplet is lost.
Now those among my readers who know what a liter is may protest that liquids can be measured in discrete amounts. We can measure their volume. This is an interesting point I'd like to revisit, so let's keep it in mind.
Now that I've laid out the distinction between discrete and continuous, I'm going to make the claim that continuous things are much more complex than discrete ones. The idea of something continuous where you cannot make divisions into groupings or categories is very difficult for people. With a bucket of water, you cannot distinguish one part of the water from another; it's all one big mass.
But perhaps you could say the same about the rice since every grain is the same. So let's look at a situation similar to the rice (i.e. discrete) where not every "grain" is the same. I might as well choose an example close to my own heart, video games. There are a discrete number of video games in the world. I wouldn't even think of counting them, but I know that it would be possible to count them and tell you the number of existing video games. Now these video games can be easily divided in categories. There are cartridge games vs disc games. There are playstation games vs Wii games. There are games titled Super Mario Galaxy and games titled Super Smash Brothers Brawl. They can be very clearly counted and very clearly categorized. There is no video game that is in both categories. If it is Mario Galaxy, it is not Brawl. If it is a cartridge game, it is not on a dvd disc. Things can get a little messier when you try to classify them into genres, but I would say that classification is based upon the content of the game (which I claim is not discrete from the content of other games) and not on the physical game itself.
So now we have a discrete group of objects and can see that it is easy to divide up and classify in different ways depending on how you want to split up all the video games. So now let's look at a continuous group of objects that differ and see if we can divide that up at all. Probably one of the simplest continuous groups is color. A finding which has been tested by people studying perception of color all around the world is that there is a core idea of most basic colors. For instance, there is a core red. There is a particular color that people would say is more red than other shades of red. A dark burgundy color might fall into the red category, but it is not the core, prototypical red. So let's consider our categories to be red, orange, yellow, green, blue, purple, brown, black, and white. This is actually more basic color divisions than most people around the world make. But we could make more divisions still. Let's say we came across a shade of gray that was perfectly in between black and white. Which category would we put it in? If we couldn't decide (and since the categorization would be arbitrary if we did), we could create another category, gray. There. Problem solved. But what if we found something perfectly in between green and blue, perhaps some sort of teal color? Well we could create another category, teal. Unfortunately, for any division I could make into categories, I could also find something in between those two categories. It might get so fine grained that I would stop caring, but I could still find it. There are no obvious divisions in between colors. You might look at a red color and say it was nothing like a greenish blue, but even though there are differences, it is difficult to draw boundary lines in between them. Sometimes in frustration, we create other categories like teal or gray, but those are unfortunately arbitrary as well. In fact, there are so many difficult to classify colors, that our language has developed a construction to deal with that. If something is in between red and orange, but looks a little more orange than red, we say it is reddish orange. If it fell on the red side of our arbitrary boundary, we would say it was orangish red. If it fell in between so closely that we were unable to tell which category it was, we would create a new name like teal.
So now we have looked at a continuous category with many different objects and found that it is difficult to divide up. So why do we divide it then? That should be obvious to most people. We need to be able to talk about and refer to different colors, so we created other words for them. If I want to paint my house a pale blue, I have to be able to tell someone. If I want someone to cut the red wire and not the green one, it is exceedingly important that I tell them which color to cut. So these categorizations and divisions are arbitrary, but it doesn't make them any less necessary for functioning in life. This is why continuous things are much more complex than discrete things. No matter what we are dealing with, if it has significant variation, we will need to be able to talk about that variation. When the thing we are talking about is discrete, it is easy to divide it up and discuss without ambiguity on any instances of that sort of object. When we are dealing with something continuous, we can still divide it up such that our divisions will work for quite a few cases, but there will always be items that fall in between our boundaries and are hard to classify simply because they are continuous.
Perhaps this is a good time to bring back the example of water divided into cups and liters so that it can be measured based on volume. It is very useful to be able to measure water, or any liquid. How else could we package drinks fairly? How else could we cook in the right proportions? But those divisions are slightly arbitrary as well. If you filled a measuring cup to the 2/3 mark with milk, you would say it was 2/3 full, but it probably wouldn't be exactly 2/3 full. You could get an eyedropper and add one more drop of milk and still claim pretty accurately that it was 2/3 full. You could probably add 50 more drops without breaking a sweat. In fact, the cup could be 3/4 full and you probably wouldn't care. You might just say it was close enough and go on with your cooking. 2/3 is a category as well and since it is dividing something continuous, it is hard to be perfectly precise. Perhaps you could have an exceptionally well calibrated machine to measure the precise volume, but even that would only be accurate up to a certain number of decimal places. However it is probably accurate enough for our needs, and since our needs were the only reason we made the arbitrary divisions in the first place, it's not really a big deal that it's not "perfectly" accurate.
I hate to inform my loyal readers, but all of this discussion so far has only been the buildup to my main point. I've given an example of continuous and an example of discrete without going into which might be more common. I believe continuous categories are far, far, more common than discrete ones. Since we divide both into sub classifications, there may be some things which we might think are discrete, but are actually continuous. In fact, I think most people just take for granted that many continuous things are discrete without realizing they're actually continuous, or perhaps glossing over some of the hard to categorize cases that are usually the first sign that something is continuous. This lack of realization is a real problem. It leads people to reason incorrectly about certain categories, as if the divisions were set in stone and not really a continuum. The most glaring example to me would be people. Yes, there are a discrete number of people right now, but if you consider all the variation there has been over the years dating back into prehistoric times and all the variation that will come from future generations (in theory, an infinite amount), the group of people starts to look a lot more continuous. Everyone has noticed that there are some pretty significant differences between people, so we had to make divisions and classifications to find a way to speak differently about them. Sometimes we divide people based on nationality. Sometimes we divide them based upon gender. Sometimes we divide them based upon race. Many people would say "Either you're French or you're American or you're Japanese and that's that." It is a decent classification. It applies to most cases. But there are some cases that clearly don't fit, such as a person with dual citizenship. With this classification, you also lose all of the variation within a category (as with any categorization really). The same can be said of race. There are many people of mixed race. You can classify a person one way or another, but the division will always be arbitrary. There was a rather famous court case in Louisiana some time ago (perhaps in the 60s or 70s?) where a woman who thought she was white was categorized by the state as being black for having 1/32 of her heritage be black. Which category was she? Most would say that she was white since she herself had not even know about her black ancestry. All of her friends were white. She was outraged at the classification. But the state of Louisiana had decided where the line was to divide the races, and if I remember correctly, they held firm. Clearly, divisions were very important to them. They were important enough for the state to keep records of everyone's heritage dating back to every person's great-great-great grandparents. Some would say the state's division was incorrect since this woman should not have been classified as black, but no matter where the division line had been, it would have been arbitrary. The division line was placed at 1/32 based upon the state's (probably racist) needs. There was a time in US history when Irish people were not white. They were new immigrants, not yet established in the country, and their ways were different from the people already here. So the division line was set with them being on the other side of white. As time went on, more people came to America who were even more different, the differences between white and Irish people started to look less severe. People no longer needed to clearly distinguish Irish from white, so Irish started becoming more and more a part of white. Very many people would claim that racial divisions are merely describing the world, but they do not. The world is not discrete; it is continuous. Any divisions we make are false divisions based upon our needs.
The false divisions are not limited just to people. We classify everything in this manner. Biological divisions between species can be very arbitrary. You may say, either you're a mammal or a bird or a fish or whatever, but there are many cases where those distinctions are not clear. Duck billed platypuses and echidnas are egg laying mammals. Penguins are birds that swim. Dolphins are mammals with no fur (at least none that I know of). Venus fly traps are carnivorous plants. There are debates among people who classify animals about whether it should be based upon their ancestry (what a species descended/evolved from) or whether it should be based upon what can mate and breed with what. And if it's based upon breeding (which I believe is the more standardly accepted classification), what about the case when species A can breed with species B and species B can breed with species C, but species A cannot breed with species C? All of these difficult to classify cases exist. Biologists get together and decide on how these things should be classified, but these classifications do not really exist. Yes, there are differences and yes, it is useful for us to be able to make the distinctions, but the differences are not really there. It is one continuous spectrum. We place boundaries based upon what we need as humans to interact with and speak about something that has variation. Even something presumably obvious like gender has variation. Most people write off that variation as freak incidents, perhaps because they don't want to think that such a neat, discrete category could actually be continuous, but it is. There are transgender people, hermaphrodites, and some would even classify gays as breaking the categories and say that that's an instance of men acting like women and women acting like men (I think comments such as "They're not real men" might be an instance of this). But the classification line, even in a case that seems clear cut like gender, is arbitrary. It is placed based upon people's needs. There have been many cultures where gender, and especially sexuality, have meant different things. Lines have been placed elsewhere, or in some cases, not at all. Who places these lines and how is a more complex question, perhaps to be saved for another blog post, but the truth is, I don't know. The important idea for this post is that the world is not discrete. It is broken up arbitrarily into categories and people do not always realize just how arbitrary those categories are. I think it's important for people to at least be aware of the nature of the world and how our attempts to classify and understand it are not really complete nor accurate. From these misconceptions about reality, a lot of misunderstanding and strife spring up. A little more awareness might help stem them, even if only a little bit.
----------
So that's it. My 100th blog entry. I was going to make it just that continuous/discrete argument, but then I thought it might not be long enough. Looking at it now, I can see that it would have been, but I don't exactly want to go back and erase what I did before, or place it into another entry. The date wouldn't be right. And besides, people have waited so long for another blog entry, they might as well get a big one. I will be far more reasonable in the future and not have such a lengthy entry. Thank you for reading all the way! I hope you liked it!
Thursday, February 28, 2008
I hate Richard Louv
May his conservative, manipulative ass roast in hell. I just ranted about him for 8 pages in my journal for class, so I don't feel particularly inclined to rant about him any more, but I needed one final shout of rage. Hmmm... or maybe I could just put my log up on my blog. It's in table format. I wonder if blogger can handle that. Well I'll give it a try.
Ok, I can't get a table, but it's mostly readable. It's only two columns: the first one is the author's important ideas which is usually a quote followed by a page number in parentheses and the second column is me ranting my ass off.
Here is me ranting my ass off about Last Child in the Woods, a book about how children need more time playing out in nature. To give you a little background, I'm not opposed to the idea. I spent a lot of my childhood roaming around outdoors freely and I think I turned out ok. But then I also enjoy video games and don't think they're damaging our children. So this is my log that I'm turning in to my teacher tomorrow word for word except there were a few more paragraphs in my original table (they didn't copy and damned if I'm going through this whole thing pressing enter every time I think it's needed).
Enjoy.
First impression (1) I suppose the first question I have to ask (and hope will be addressed) is what about people who don’t have the money to be near nature?
Anecdote about son (1) A personal anecdote seems to be the inspiration for this book. I wonder if this is a common experience shared by many people. I, myself, explored a lot as a kid, but I also really enjoyed video games and other indoor activities. Perhaps only the author’s son feels this way about outdoor activities. I would like more evidence.
Summer camp stories (2) The change in summer activities could be interpreted as a move from outdoor to indoor activities, but it could also be interpreted as a move from play to work (camp is much more an expression of play than weight loss camp). Both I think are valid interpretations that lead to a similar conclusion.
Nature (4) I know it’s a pretty commonly accepted term, but I think the use of nature is itself ambiguous. Technically, everything on Earth is natural. Humans evolved the way they did naturally, so all human creations must be natural. I have to wonder at what point man became unnatural.
“On its face, New York City may not appear natural, but it does contain all manner of hidden, self-organizing wild places” (8) I’m pleased to see this point here. It addresses the concern I had earlier about not being able to afford being near nature.
“when I use the word ‘nature’ in a general way, I mean natural wilderness: biodiversity, abundance – related loose parts in a backyard or a rugged mountain ridge” (8-9) Almost as soon as he addresses my concerns, he un-addresses them. Not everyone can live near a rugged mountain ridge or have their own backyard. Though I do appreciate a specific definition of nature.
“The woods were my Ritalin” (10) I have some issues with this. I can be patient and wait for the book to later substantiate its claim about lack of nature causing ADD, but the truth of the matter is, I don’t really believe in ADD. There may be some cases of it, but in general, I think it’s just kids acting their age. Their age just happens to have a lot of energy. If lack of nature really causes ADD, then there should be a lot of people with ADD, but I don’t think there really are.
“ ‘I like to play indoors better, ‘cause that’s where all the electrical outlets are’” (10) I have to wonder where child preference comes into play in this book. Can you or should you force a child to play outdoors if that’s not what they want to do?
“But for many others, playing in nature seemed so… Unproductive. Off-limits. Alien. Cute. Dangerous. Televised” (10) I can just hear the disdain in his voice, after spending several paragraphs on the majesty of nature to refer to it with this string of irreverent adjectives. He certainly chooses his words well to arouse that same sense of disdain in the reader.
“Though several [parents] lived on the same block, this was the first time that some of these parents had met each other” (11) This book is lined with sentences like this, and I think it’s worthwhile to stop and analyze one of them in depth. The whole structure of the sentence seems to imply that people should know their neighbors as that is the assumed, natural way of things. Then it points to the fact that even though these parents are in a situation where they should know their neighbors, some of them have never met. It offers this sentence like some strange, lamentable fact, but this “fact” contains many tacit assumptions and premises that are inaccurate. It’s as though the author hopes to convince us of his point by bombarding us with manufactured truisms about the changing face of the new society. Let’s question his assumptions. Should we know our neighbors? I don’t see any reason why we should. Perhaps to build a better community, though the whole idea sounds a little forced to me. You can’t really choose your neighbors. Now is this a new state of affairs? My parents don’t know their neighbors. My grandparents didn’t know theirs. Perhaps I’m anomalous, but I doubt I’m that out of the ordinary. Over and over again in this book, the reader is offered tidbits of the good way things used to be contrasted with the sad and pitiable way that things are now. The framing of the facts is impeccable, but I notice it (this is partly because of all the cognitive linguistics classes I’ve taken where we take texts like this and analyze word by word all the metaphors and assumptions inherent in each sentence) and it makes me very resistant to what the author is saying. I feel like he’s trying to manipulate me. Why can’t he just lay down the facts without manipulative language? Is he too worried that people will reject his opinion if he lets the facts speak for themselves? I suppose this is the point where I just stopped trusting what the author was trying to say. I have a biased text, and even if nature may be helpful to people, I just don’t want to hear it at this point. If his tone changes, I might change my mind, but from here on out, I feel like I’m going to be trudging through something that tries to change my mind illegitimately. I’m honestly a little sick that I have to keep reading and giving this author more chances to infect me with his bias.
“Beard epitomizes a time when a young person’s experience of nature was inseparable from the romantic view of the American frontier” (15) After the quote on page 11 when I sat down and really thought about what was going on, I was really trying to gloss over the text and give it less of a chance to piss me off, but this sentence stood out so much I could help but go off on a tirade. Before I thought the book was classist. Now I thin it’s racist too. How can you call the American frontier romantic? The only people who can say that are white. The race of the author is painfully apparent. He paints this ideal, suburban 50s society where everyone gets to know their new neighbor by bringing them a jello mold as soon as they move in to the neighborhood where, of course, everyone is white. It is extremely obvious to me that this book is targeted directly at white people. I just can’t imagine these words coming out of the mouth of anyone else. He sits here and talks about his love of nature, but that love of nature comes at a price. He says on page 14 that we have a mixed message about valuing nature and then tearing it down and gives a precious little picture of a would-be poet girl whose inspiration was destroyed when her favorite forest was torn down. Awwww. Just makes you weep. What he doesn’t mention is what was put in place of that forest. I’m going to take a wild guess and say it was housing. There’s always new housing going up. It’s immensely profitable. Everyone wants to live the American dream and have a house in the suburbs, especially since the suburbs bring us closer to nature, which is obviously so good for our children, according to this book. Then they can play in our quaint backyard next to the rocky ridge! Oh the ridge was torn down? What a shame. Let’s make a jello mold! There isn’t enough space, money, or equity to give everyone the dream this author is selling. This book is destroying nature by its very existence! He may criticize suburbs for not being natury enough, but that’s not the take home message here. The take home message is “have a nice little backyard and force your children to play in it.” And here he romanticizes the American frontier (and later goes on to say all the good that came of it and how it improved our psyche and made us hearty and better than every other country in the world) which was one long history of injustice and removal of people (primarily Indians) from nature. There was the great dividing and partitioning of the land, folklore about how many trees Paul Bunyan can cut down, importing Chinese laborers to do the work you don’t want to do (building a railroad) that allows even more people to come to the west and mess with the land even more. He talks about a mixed message and doesn’t even realize what he’s doing!
“ ‘the existence of an area of free land…’ explained the development of the American nation, history and character” (17) He takes this big bucket of American patriotism and justifies our arrogance by the existence of a frontier and our relation to (conquering of) nature. So that’s why we’re so much better than all those other countries that never had that experience.
“an increased intellectual understanding of our relationship with other animals” (19) and “more young people may be vegetarians or consume foods from the health food store, but fewer are likely to raise their own food – especially if the food is an animal” (21) He uses the qualifier “intellectual” so that it’s clear we don’t really understand nature and animals. He looks down on vegetarians as not really knowing what they’re doing. It’s like he’s saying “sure it sounds like they’re doing the right thing, but since they have no idea what an animal is, it’s for all the wrong reasons.” Grrrr… I hate this author. There are constant, subtle jibes at so many things that don’t deserve it.
“even the definition of life itself is up for grabs” (21) He keeps talking about how the world is changing and all the awful new things he sees in it, but most of this stuff isn’t even new. Roe v Wade was big milestone in the debate on life, and that’s not terribly new (it’s from his venerable generation that knew the value of nature, after all). I’m sure there are many other examples as well.
“For baby boomers, such news is fascinating, strange, disturbing” (23) Every word and scenario is described in such a way as to make it seem disturbing (what exactly does he have against genetic, anyway? I’m guessing he dislikes making progress toward curing genetic diseases). He is clearly disturbed by the news and expects us to be too. And again we see him emphasizing the irreconcilable difference between our generations: there’s the righteous older generation who knows that this newfangled stuff is wrong and there’s the new generation, robbed of its morals by lack of a communion with nature. At this point, I almost just put the book down and stopped reading. I did have to stop for a while, but I really didn’t want to pick it back up. Every few sentences something was making me angry. I didn’t see the point in continuing. It didn’t serve any purpose. I really wanted it to get better and start offering some substance to its claims (I had yet to see any convincing evidence), but I had given up hope of it actually doing so. Just giving me some news blurbs with his particular, negative spin on it was not exactly convincing. And I still had another 15 pages of this conservative trash to read. I trudged on and tried to skim, but every time I glossed over something without picking it apart and getting irate, I worried that his words would sink in, so I found myself stopping almost as much as I had. This is hardly even a science text. This is rhetorical garbage (though I will admit it is insidiously well done). Sigh.
“the march of the nanorobots or the advance of the chimera” (26) Nanorobots (or nanomachines to be more accurate) don’t march. So why use the word “march”? The only things that march are armies or some other type of threatening military force. The nanorobots (machines don’t march, but unfeeling, unthinking robots do, so perhaps there’s a reason to his misnaming and mislabeling) and the chimera (genetics is not used to create mythical Greek monsters like the chimera, but why not phrase it that way and offer one example that might fit the phrasing so you can use a word with the appropriately monstrous connotations) are advancing, but who are they advancing on? Us of course. The whole writing style is designed to create a sense of fear through a few well placed, well chosen words. Disgusting.
“verboten” “constricted” “growing obsession with order” (28) “Verboten” has the special connotation that not only is something forbidden (the English translation), but it is unnecessarily so, or perhaps that the restriction is excessive and unreasonable. And “constriction” sounds like children are suffocating painfully under the regime. “Growing obsession with order” speaks for itself. He chooses his words so carefully. It’s sick.
Community associations are “private government” (28) There’s an unfair, rigid, group of draconian disciplinarians who are running their own anti-democratic private government and worst of all, they’re presiding over your own front yard! The manipulation has just gotten rampant at this point. It was bad before, but now it can barely contain itself.
“the criminalization of natural play is more suggestive than read” (29) So if you try to look for laws that actually support what he’s saying, you’re not going to find them, but trust him – they’re “suggestive.”
Touching story about a grandfather who can no longer fly his kite with his grandson after generations of kit flying (29) The kite flying scares away an endangered bird (probably endangered because it’s been scared away by kite flyers for generations). It has consequences. And just because kite flying has happened for so long and seems so harmless, he’s trying to suggest that that’s justification for continuing. We can’t right the wrongs of the past, but if we notice that something is damaging the environment, we have a duty to stop it. Unfortunately, our friend of nature here does not feel the same way.
“decapitated hills” “artificial landscaping” “yards the size of gravesites” (30) Are you kidding me? How can this guy even write with a straight face? This goes beyond being “poetic;” this is simply manipulative.
“how could something so timeless change in such a short time?” (32) I hardly know where to begin with this one. Timeless? Timeless how? Justify what you mean instead of throwing around sappy, loaded words to pull on our heartstrings. Timeless as in, since America’s founding? Timeless as in, from Europe in medieval times (since your ancestors were clearly European)? Timeless as in ancient Greeks? Timeless as in the dawn of man? I don’t know how universal this communion with nature is supposed to be, but I can’t believe it’s as eternal and universal as he’s pretending it is. And on another note, look how perfectly this phrase appeals to conservatives. It suggests how our way of life is being fenced out and systematically destroyed within the blink of an eye and how we have to fight to stop it. The only person I’ll fight is this scummy author.
“indoor, sedentary lifestyle linked to mental health problems” (32) This quote is from a study done by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Finally some actual evidence instead of a stream of manipulative rhetoric. Well it had to happen eventually. I have to give credit where credit is due. I’m curious to know what these mental health problems are though.
“For almost two decades, the well known Japanese photographer Keiki Haganoya photographed children’s play in the cities of Japan. In recent years, “children have disappeared so rapidly from his viewfinder that he has had to bring that chapter of his work to an end,” Moore [a professor of landscape architecture at North Carolina State] reports” (33) And we all know what problems with ADHD Japanese kids have. I noticed how crazy they were in that TIMMS study. I guess he’s finally convinced me that lack of nature and ADHD are related. As long as he has evidence of some sort, there’s no need to follow up with a critical eye, right? I’m sorry, I’m rarely this sarcastic, but it’s hard to contain myself with this guy.
There’s no money in natural play (I forget the page number) Is that really true? A video game console with a few games costs $500. A house costs anywhere from tens to hundreds of thousands depending on what part of the country you’re in. The type of living he’s describing does not come cheap. Yes, he speaks poorly of suburban housing (some of the most expensive natural environment), but only because of its restrictions on natural play. This book makes a tacit assumption about free time and money that shows how restrictive and limited it is in its audience.
Ok, I can't get a table, but it's mostly readable. It's only two columns: the first one is the author's important ideas which is usually a quote followed by a page number in parentheses and the second column is me ranting my ass off.
Here is me ranting my ass off about Last Child in the Woods, a book about how children need more time playing out in nature. To give you a little background, I'm not opposed to the idea. I spent a lot of my childhood roaming around outdoors freely and I think I turned out ok. But then I also enjoy video games and don't think they're damaging our children. So this is my log that I'm turning in to my teacher tomorrow word for word except there were a few more paragraphs in my original table (they didn't copy and damned if I'm going through this whole thing pressing enter every time I think it's needed).
Enjoy.
First impression (1) I suppose the first question I have to ask (and hope will be addressed) is what about people who don’t have the money to be near nature?
Anecdote about son (1) A personal anecdote seems to be the inspiration for this book. I wonder if this is a common experience shared by many people. I, myself, explored a lot as a kid, but I also really enjoyed video games and other indoor activities. Perhaps only the author’s son feels this way about outdoor activities. I would like more evidence.
Summer camp stories (2) The change in summer activities could be interpreted as a move from outdoor to indoor activities, but it could also be interpreted as a move from play to work (camp is much more an expression of play than weight loss camp). Both I think are valid interpretations that lead to a similar conclusion.
Nature (4) I know it’s a pretty commonly accepted term, but I think the use of nature is itself ambiguous. Technically, everything on Earth is natural. Humans evolved the way they did naturally, so all human creations must be natural. I have to wonder at what point man became unnatural.
“On its face, New York City may not appear natural, but it does contain all manner of hidden, self-organizing wild places” (8) I’m pleased to see this point here. It addresses the concern I had earlier about not being able to afford being near nature.
“when I use the word ‘nature’ in a general way, I mean natural wilderness: biodiversity, abundance – related loose parts in a backyard or a rugged mountain ridge” (8-9) Almost as soon as he addresses my concerns, he un-addresses them. Not everyone can live near a rugged mountain ridge or have their own backyard. Though I do appreciate a specific definition of nature.
“The woods were my Ritalin” (10) I have some issues with this. I can be patient and wait for the book to later substantiate its claim about lack of nature causing ADD, but the truth of the matter is, I don’t really believe in ADD. There may be some cases of it, but in general, I think it’s just kids acting their age. Their age just happens to have a lot of energy. If lack of nature really causes ADD, then there should be a lot of people with ADD, but I don’t think there really are.
“ ‘I like to play indoors better, ‘cause that’s where all the electrical outlets are’” (10) I have to wonder where child preference comes into play in this book. Can you or should you force a child to play outdoors if that’s not what they want to do?
“But for many others, playing in nature seemed so… Unproductive. Off-limits. Alien. Cute. Dangerous. Televised” (10) I can just hear the disdain in his voice, after spending several paragraphs on the majesty of nature to refer to it with this string of irreverent adjectives. He certainly chooses his words well to arouse that same sense of disdain in the reader.
“Though several [parents] lived on the same block, this was the first time that some of these parents had met each other” (11) This book is lined with sentences like this, and I think it’s worthwhile to stop and analyze one of them in depth. The whole structure of the sentence seems to imply that people should know their neighbors as that is the assumed, natural way of things. Then it points to the fact that even though these parents are in a situation where they should know their neighbors, some of them have never met. It offers this sentence like some strange, lamentable fact, but this “fact” contains many tacit assumptions and premises that are inaccurate. It’s as though the author hopes to convince us of his point by bombarding us with manufactured truisms about the changing face of the new society. Let’s question his assumptions. Should we know our neighbors? I don’t see any reason why we should. Perhaps to build a better community, though the whole idea sounds a little forced to me. You can’t really choose your neighbors. Now is this a new state of affairs? My parents don’t know their neighbors. My grandparents didn’t know theirs. Perhaps I’m anomalous, but I doubt I’m that out of the ordinary. Over and over again in this book, the reader is offered tidbits of the good way things used to be contrasted with the sad and pitiable way that things are now. The framing of the facts is impeccable, but I notice it (this is partly because of all the cognitive linguistics classes I’ve taken where we take texts like this and analyze word by word all the metaphors and assumptions inherent in each sentence) and it makes me very resistant to what the author is saying. I feel like he’s trying to manipulate me. Why can’t he just lay down the facts without manipulative language? Is he too worried that people will reject his opinion if he lets the facts speak for themselves? I suppose this is the point where I just stopped trusting what the author was trying to say. I have a biased text, and even if nature may be helpful to people, I just don’t want to hear it at this point. If his tone changes, I might change my mind, but from here on out, I feel like I’m going to be trudging through something that tries to change my mind illegitimately. I’m honestly a little sick that I have to keep reading and giving this author more chances to infect me with his bias.
“Beard epitomizes a time when a young person’s experience of nature was inseparable from the romantic view of the American frontier” (15) After the quote on page 11 when I sat down and really thought about what was going on, I was really trying to gloss over the text and give it less of a chance to piss me off, but this sentence stood out so much I could help but go off on a tirade. Before I thought the book was classist. Now I thin it’s racist too. How can you call the American frontier romantic? The only people who can say that are white. The race of the author is painfully apparent. He paints this ideal, suburban 50s society where everyone gets to know their new neighbor by bringing them a jello mold as soon as they move in to the neighborhood where, of course, everyone is white. It is extremely obvious to me that this book is targeted directly at white people. I just can’t imagine these words coming out of the mouth of anyone else. He sits here and talks about his love of nature, but that love of nature comes at a price. He says on page 14 that we have a mixed message about valuing nature and then tearing it down and gives a precious little picture of a would-be poet girl whose inspiration was destroyed when her favorite forest was torn down. Awwww. Just makes you weep. What he doesn’t mention is what was put in place of that forest. I’m going to take a wild guess and say it was housing. There’s always new housing going up. It’s immensely profitable. Everyone wants to live the American dream and have a house in the suburbs, especially since the suburbs bring us closer to nature, which is obviously so good for our children, according to this book. Then they can play in our quaint backyard next to the rocky ridge! Oh the ridge was torn down? What a shame. Let’s make a jello mold! There isn’t enough space, money, or equity to give everyone the dream this author is selling. This book is destroying nature by its very existence! He may criticize suburbs for not being natury enough, but that’s not the take home message here. The take home message is “have a nice little backyard and force your children to play in it.” And here he romanticizes the American frontier (and later goes on to say all the good that came of it and how it improved our psyche and made us hearty and better than every other country in the world) which was one long history of injustice and removal of people (primarily Indians) from nature. There was the great dividing and partitioning of the land, folklore about how many trees Paul Bunyan can cut down, importing Chinese laborers to do the work you don’t want to do (building a railroad) that allows even more people to come to the west and mess with the land even more. He talks about a mixed message and doesn’t even realize what he’s doing!
“ ‘the existence of an area of free land…’ explained the development of the American nation, history and character” (17) He takes this big bucket of American patriotism and justifies our arrogance by the existence of a frontier and our relation to (conquering of) nature. So that’s why we’re so much better than all those other countries that never had that experience.
“an increased intellectual understanding of our relationship with other animals” (19) and “more young people may be vegetarians or consume foods from the health food store, but fewer are likely to raise their own food – especially if the food is an animal” (21) He uses the qualifier “intellectual” so that it’s clear we don’t really understand nature and animals. He looks down on vegetarians as not really knowing what they’re doing. It’s like he’s saying “sure it sounds like they’re doing the right thing, but since they have no idea what an animal is, it’s for all the wrong reasons.” Grrrr… I hate this author. There are constant, subtle jibes at so many things that don’t deserve it.
“even the definition of life itself is up for grabs” (21) He keeps talking about how the world is changing and all the awful new things he sees in it, but most of this stuff isn’t even new. Roe v Wade was big milestone in the debate on life, and that’s not terribly new (it’s from his venerable generation that knew the value of nature, after all). I’m sure there are many other examples as well.
“For baby boomers, such news is fascinating, strange, disturbing” (23) Every word and scenario is described in such a way as to make it seem disturbing (what exactly does he have against genetic, anyway? I’m guessing he dislikes making progress toward curing genetic diseases). He is clearly disturbed by the news and expects us to be too. And again we see him emphasizing the irreconcilable difference between our generations: there’s the righteous older generation who knows that this newfangled stuff is wrong and there’s the new generation, robbed of its morals by lack of a communion with nature. At this point, I almost just put the book down and stopped reading. I did have to stop for a while, but I really didn’t want to pick it back up. Every few sentences something was making me angry. I didn’t see the point in continuing. It didn’t serve any purpose. I really wanted it to get better and start offering some substance to its claims (I had yet to see any convincing evidence), but I had given up hope of it actually doing so. Just giving me some news blurbs with his particular, negative spin on it was not exactly convincing. And I still had another 15 pages of this conservative trash to read. I trudged on and tried to skim, but every time I glossed over something without picking it apart and getting irate, I worried that his words would sink in, so I found myself stopping almost as much as I had. This is hardly even a science text. This is rhetorical garbage (though I will admit it is insidiously well done). Sigh.
“the march of the nanorobots or the advance of the chimera” (26) Nanorobots (or nanomachines to be more accurate) don’t march. So why use the word “march”? The only things that march are armies or some other type of threatening military force. The nanorobots (machines don’t march, but unfeeling, unthinking robots do, so perhaps there’s a reason to his misnaming and mislabeling) and the chimera (genetics is not used to create mythical Greek monsters like the chimera, but why not phrase it that way and offer one example that might fit the phrasing so you can use a word with the appropriately monstrous connotations) are advancing, but who are they advancing on? Us of course. The whole writing style is designed to create a sense of fear through a few well placed, well chosen words. Disgusting.
“verboten” “constricted” “growing obsession with order” (28) “Verboten” has the special connotation that not only is something forbidden (the English translation), but it is unnecessarily so, or perhaps that the restriction is excessive and unreasonable. And “constriction” sounds like children are suffocating painfully under the regime. “Growing obsession with order” speaks for itself. He chooses his words so carefully. It’s sick.
Community associations are “private government” (28) There’s an unfair, rigid, group of draconian disciplinarians who are running their own anti-democratic private government and worst of all, they’re presiding over your own front yard! The manipulation has just gotten rampant at this point. It was bad before, but now it can barely contain itself.
“the criminalization of natural play is more suggestive than read” (29) So if you try to look for laws that actually support what he’s saying, you’re not going to find them, but trust him – they’re “suggestive.”
Touching story about a grandfather who can no longer fly his kite with his grandson after generations of kit flying (29) The kite flying scares away an endangered bird (probably endangered because it’s been scared away by kite flyers for generations). It has consequences. And just because kite flying has happened for so long and seems so harmless, he’s trying to suggest that that’s justification for continuing. We can’t right the wrongs of the past, but if we notice that something is damaging the environment, we have a duty to stop it. Unfortunately, our friend of nature here does not feel the same way.
“decapitated hills” “artificial landscaping” “yards the size of gravesites” (30) Are you kidding me? How can this guy even write with a straight face? This goes beyond being “poetic;” this is simply manipulative.
“how could something so timeless change in such a short time?” (32) I hardly know where to begin with this one. Timeless? Timeless how? Justify what you mean instead of throwing around sappy, loaded words to pull on our heartstrings. Timeless as in, since America’s founding? Timeless as in, from Europe in medieval times (since your ancestors were clearly European)? Timeless as in ancient Greeks? Timeless as in the dawn of man? I don’t know how universal this communion with nature is supposed to be, but I can’t believe it’s as eternal and universal as he’s pretending it is. And on another note, look how perfectly this phrase appeals to conservatives. It suggests how our way of life is being fenced out and systematically destroyed within the blink of an eye and how we have to fight to stop it. The only person I’ll fight is this scummy author.
“indoor, sedentary lifestyle linked to mental health problems” (32) This quote is from a study done by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Finally some actual evidence instead of a stream of manipulative rhetoric. Well it had to happen eventually. I have to give credit where credit is due. I’m curious to know what these mental health problems are though.
“For almost two decades, the well known Japanese photographer Keiki Haganoya photographed children’s play in the cities of Japan. In recent years, “children have disappeared so rapidly from his viewfinder that he has had to bring that chapter of his work to an end,” Moore [a professor of landscape architecture at North Carolina State] reports” (33) And we all know what problems with ADHD Japanese kids have. I noticed how crazy they were in that TIMMS study. I guess he’s finally convinced me that lack of nature and ADHD are related. As long as he has evidence of some sort, there’s no need to follow up with a critical eye, right? I’m sorry, I’m rarely this sarcastic, but it’s hard to contain myself with this guy.
There’s no money in natural play (I forget the page number) Is that really true? A video game console with a few games costs $500. A house costs anywhere from tens to hundreds of thousands depending on what part of the country you’re in. The type of living he’s describing does not come cheap. Yes, he speaks poorly of suburban housing (some of the most expensive natural environment), but only because of its restrictions on natural play. This book makes a tacit assumption about free time and money that shows how restrictive and limited it is in its audience.
Friday, February 8, 2008
Fragile
Kids are so delicate. It's really sad sometimes. Today in class one of the students, Laron, was misbehaving a little. Actually I couldn't even see what he was doing from the back of the room, and honestly I can see almost everything. I think he was either joking quietly with the person next to him or simply not paying attention. Whatever it was wasn't a big deal from my point of view. It must have been upsetting to Jake (my master teacher) though. He had to flip his card all the way to orange (it starts out green, then yellow is a warning, then orange is a call home. It almost never gets to red, but 4 reds equals a suspension). Then after getting an orange card, Jake had to send him to the back of the room near the end of the period. They had a quiz at around the same time and I didn't see Jake give him a quiz. I asked if that was intentional, and Jake said Laron wasn't really in the mood to work because he was so angry, but he gave me the quiz and a copy for myself and let me try to get him to work. I sat next to him at the back of the room and tried. He wouldn't talk to me, but I'm pretty sure he was listening to me talk to him. And Jake may have thought he wasn't working because he was angry, but that wasn't really the reason. He was angry, but he was mostly angry because of how hurt he was. He wouldn't talk to me because he was crying and really didn't want me to know. He turned away and pulled is hood around his head as tightly as it would go, but I could hear him sniffling (as quietly as he could) and see him occasionally wiping his eyes. I told him he should really think about starting his quiz because he didn't want to get a zero, but that felt like a really harsh thing to say to someone crying. I felt like trying to comfort him wouldn't be too helpful since he really didn't want me to know how sad he was. After a minute or two, he picked up his quiz and looked at it. I saw this as a pretty good sign, but he also picked up a pair of scissors that I saw had been left on the tables in the back of the room. I should have picked them up earlier in the day when I first noticed them. I noticed them in his hand and cringed a little when I saw him go for his test, but I he just ran the scissors along the back of it, coming close to cutting it, but not actually cutting it. I'm pretty sure that wasn't for my benefit. He knew he'd get in trouble for cutting up the test, but he felt so angry and hurt that he wanted to lash out at something. He was just running the scissors along the middle behind it so that he could pretend he was actually cutting it, getting a little of the relief of actually cutting it but without getting into any trouble. I thought about trying to stop him or trying to get the scissors away from him, but I understood exactly how he was feeling. He was humiliated and frustrated and needed to take it out on something. I was worried that he was actually going to cut it up, which wouldn't have offended me, but could have been considered a serious act of rebellion that might have even gotten him a red card. Then he started to cut of the tops of the corners of the paper. That was a relief since it helped to relieve some pressure as well, but I knew if left to his own devices he'd eventually get bolder and bolder and cut up the rest of it, or at least cut enough that what he was doing became noticeable. I really didn't want Jake to find out about that. It's fine to let out your frustrations on some inanimate object, but it wasn't exactly the safest space to do so. Jake is a good teacher, but I think he's got a lot of frustrations and burdens and they've gotten in the way of his appreciation of the students. He's more into getting them to behave than he is enjoying their company. Of course, I guess it's his job to get them to behave so he can teach the class. But anyway, back to Laron. After he'd cut each of the corners once in a small way, I spoke to him again for the first time in minutes. I told him that cutting up his test wasn't really going to help him. I told him that if it made him feel better he could keep doing it, but he'd still be in the same situation with the same problems and I didn't really think it would make him feel better. He wiped his eyes a few times and turned back to his desk, put down the scissors, and started working.
Kids are so good! Can you believe that? The teacher was really mean to him (from his point of view at least) and he really didn't want to cooperate, but he still tried to work through his tears. I told him how impressive that was to work when he felt so bad. He stopped and cried momentarily when I told him that. I think he was ashamed and being told he was hurting when he was trying his best to ignore his pain probably just reminded him of what he was trying to forget. I don't regret praising him though. He was amazing. He worked really hard. He got a problem wrong, but I didn't have the heart to correct him. He was in a fragile enough state of mind as it was. When the bell rang, I told him that he did a great job and did great work. He may have goofed off for the majority of the period, but he worked harder than someone working for the full hour and half for those five minutes at the end. He didn't speak to me the entire time except for once immediately after I sat down with him where he said, "I hate him." Poor Laron. I think speaking made him cry more. That's how it is with me too. I know communicating is better than keeping quiet when you're obviously upset, but for whatever reason, voicing your problems refreshes all the injustice of them and makes you start crying. Sometimes when I'm sad I'll just stop talking entirely because anything I say will make me cry and I really don't want to cry. After I left, I saw Jake trying to talk to him. He kept asking why Laron was so mad. I knew it was futile. Laron was mad at him (and perhaps for good reason) and wasn't about to let Jake see him cry. Jake didn't realize he'd hurt Laron. He still just thought Laron was angry and pouty. I could have told Jake that he'd hurt Laron, but Laron would have heard and that would have hurt his pride. I know Laron would have rather been viewed as angry and rebellious than as a weakling who got hurt by the teacher sending him to the back of the room. The last person he would want to know was Jake. It might have gotten him into more trouble in the end since he looked like he was being belligerent and aggressive instead of just hurt.
*pause for a moment while I send Jake and email telling him to go easy on Laron*
I hope that was a good idea. Laron doesn't have to know about that. I just don't want Jake to make a bad situation worse by calling his mom and telling her that her son is being disruptive. Perhaps he is, but that's the last thing Laron needs to hear.
It seems like Jake is hurting his kids' feelings a lot lately. Most of them aren't as susceptible as Laron, but I can tell when he's doing something he should be, when he's taking excessive measures that make the students want to behave even worse. Sometimes, just letting a kid be for a few moments does a lot more than forcing them to do what you want. For instance, I could have told Laron to take away the scissors or get another card flipped and forced him to put down the thing that he was releasing some frustration on, but by just letting him cut his paper a little and set down the scissors on his own, I think it was a lot more productive. I don't think he would have started working at the end otherwise. I'll admit I was really proud of myself for the way I handled that, but even more so I was proud of Laron. I don't know that I would have had the strength to try again after that, or at least not try the day of the incident. He's a really good kid. Honestly, they all are. I felt so bad when he was crying. This is the reason I want to become a teacher, or at least one of the reasons anyway. I want things to be better for kids. I had enough teachers who didn't understand me. I had enough teachers who glorified the Rosalie's of the class (she works hard and always is on task and does what she's told, but she's really not as intelligent as some of the people who are doing worse because they are so intelligent and question orders- she's a good kid, but she shouldn't be glorified). The misbehavers are really some of the more endearing students. I like them so much. I hope Laron is ok. He'll have a whole weekend to cool down a little. I hope things go better for him on Monday.
Kids are so good! Can you believe that? The teacher was really mean to him (from his point of view at least) and he really didn't want to cooperate, but he still tried to work through his tears. I told him how impressive that was to work when he felt so bad. He stopped and cried momentarily when I told him that. I think he was ashamed and being told he was hurting when he was trying his best to ignore his pain probably just reminded him of what he was trying to forget. I don't regret praising him though. He was amazing. He worked really hard. He got a problem wrong, but I didn't have the heart to correct him. He was in a fragile enough state of mind as it was. When the bell rang, I told him that he did a great job and did great work. He may have goofed off for the majority of the period, but he worked harder than someone working for the full hour and half for those five minutes at the end. He didn't speak to me the entire time except for once immediately after I sat down with him where he said, "I hate him." Poor Laron. I think speaking made him cry more. That's how it is with me too. I know communicating is better than keeping quiet when you're obviously upset, but for whatever reason, voicing your problems refreshes all the injustice of them and makes you start crying. Sometimes when I'm sad I'll just stop talking entirely because anything I say will make me cry and I really don't want to cry. After I left, I saw Jake trying to talk to him. He kept asking why Laron was so mad. I knew it was futile. Laron was mad at him (and perhaps for good reason) and wasn't about to let Jake see him cry. Jake didn't realize he'd hurt Laron. He still just thought Laron was angry and pouty. I could have told Jake that he'd hurt Laron, but Laron would have heard and that would have hurt his pride. I know Laron would have rather been viewed as angry and rebellious than as a weakling who got hurt by the teacher sending him to the back of the room. The last person he would want to know was Jake. It might have gotten him into more trouble in the end since he looked like he was being belligerent and aggressive instead of just hurt.
*pause for a moment while I send Jake and email telling him to go easy on Laron*
I hope that was a good idea. Laron doesn't have to know about that. I just don't want Jake to make a bad situation worse by calling his mom and telling her that her son is being disruptive. Perhaps he is, but that's the last thing Laron needs to hear.
It seems like Jake is hurting his kids' feelings a lot lately. Most of them aren't as susceptible as Laron, but I can tell when he's doing something he should be, when he's taking excessive measures that make the students want to behave even worse. Sometimes, just letting a kid be for a few moments does a lot more than forcing them to do what you want. For instance, I could have told Laron to take away the scissors or get another card flipped and forced him to put down the thing that he was releasing some frustration on, but by just letting him cut his paper a little and set down the scissors on his own, I think it was a lot more productive. I don't think he would have started working at the end otherwise. I'll admit I was really proud of myself for the way I handled that, but even more so I was proud of Laron. I don't know that I would have had the strength to try again after that, or at least not try the day of the incident. He's a really good kid. Honestly, they all are. I felt so bad when he was crying. This is the reason I want to become a teacher, or at least one of the reasons anyway. I want things to be better for kids. I had enough teachers who didn't understand me. I had enough teachers who glorified the Rosalie's of the class (she works hard and always is on task and does what she's told, but she's really not as intelligent as some of the people who are doing worse because they are so intelligent and question orders- she's a good kid, but she shouldn't be glorified). The misbehavers are really some of the more endearing students. I like them so much. I hope Laron is ok. He'll have a whole weekend to cool down a little. I hope things go better for him on Monday.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)