One of my favorite TV shows has been turned into one of my least favorite movies and director M Night Shyamalan is to blame. I decided to make a laundry list of all that was wrong with that movie to help me vent a little and to adequately express my distaste with this whole sordid affair.
1.) The casting
That casting was some of the worst I have ever seen. The actors were not particularly good, for one thing. They delivered their lines about as flatly as they possibly could have. It looked like they were just doing as they were told instead of actually acting. I guess that's sometimes how it goes when you have a cast of mostly child actors, but that wasn't even the worst of it. The worst was the racial picks of each person. They tried to de-asian the whole series. The fire nation was made up of Indians and there was not one asian with a leading role, or maybe even a speaking role. It made for a real disconnect since they kept all the names the same. I didn't know Ziao was an Indian name... There were some Asians around as extras, but if someone was going to have lines, even a very few lines, they were white or Indian (depending on if they were a good guy or a bad guy). Sokka and Kitara's grandmother looked like the only white person in the south pole. In a sea of fire bending Indians, Iroh was the only white person. They made some really questionable racial choices that was not only untrue to the spirit of the cartoon, but also offensive and unpleasant to watch.
2.) Appa is not cute
I mean, seriously- Appa is not cute?!?! That has the be the cutest most cuddly creature in the whole mythical world. How did they manage the get something that looked like Appa without all the cuteness? I didn't even think it was possible, but in this movie, Appa looks dirty and even his face looks icky somehow. Even Momo looks gross. Appa at least provides transportation as a plot device. Momo's only purpose for being in that show is to add cuteness and adorability and humor. Why did they even bother including that character if it was only to make it look like a creepy flying rat?
3.) Pronunciation
I can understand if a movie adapted from a book pronounces things differently than you thought. When it's written you really don't know how things are supposed to be pronounced and you make your best guess, but when you're adapting things from some audio-visual source, the key part of that is the audio. You know how everything sounds. You can hear it. You hear it far more often than you see it written in fact. So, one would think the pronunciation wouldn't really be up for debate. Well tell that to Ih-row, Ong, and several others. Frankly, Ong is a more correctly Asian way of pronouncing the Avatar's name than the way they pronounced it in the series, but it's not like he was going to authentic asian-ness. The way it was, it just sounded pretentious and sloppy.
4.) Fight scenes
One of the things the cartoon did right, far better than your average cartoon, is the fight scenes. Original animation is a lot more costly than recycled animation. That's why so many cartoons have the same old power-up sequences (I'm looking at you DBZ) or transformation montages (Sailor Moon, you know what you are) and why the characters don't change clothing that often. It really tones down the excitement in a lot of cartoon having the same old fight animation. I mean, fights are supposed to get you more excited, not feel more familiar and boring. One of the things I loved about the Avatar cartoon is that they didn't do that. The fight sequences were all very original. Air bending wasn't all just gusts of wind; there were also spheres of air, whirlwinds, walking on walls, great agility, and a lot more. Water bending had ice, water octopus tentacles, frozen disks, spikes, etc. All of the bending was creative. It wasn't just the same stuff over and over. There were ideas I would never have thought of and all of them were creative, interacted with the surrounding terrain, and were generally very fun to watch. Sigh. Which brings us to the movie. Water bending was mostly just throwing water around or lifting the sea. It seemed like some overzealous yet inept choreographer tried to make his own original fight scene at one point. There's a moment where Aang is fighting a bunch of fire benders on their training ground. He's in the middle of a circular platform surrounded by hanging wooden planks and he uses his airbending to spin the planks and keep out the fire benders. First off, what is this training apparatus for? How exactly do the fire benders train with a circle of hanging planks? It seemed like that prop's only purpose was the try for an interesting fight scene and conveniently give an airbender a way to bat approaching fire benders away. The second major flaw in this plan is the *wooden* planks. Wooden. Fire benders. Wooden. Let's put two and two together. Then after apparently realizing the wooden plank thing is stupid, Aang goes to hop away agilely on the tops of these wooden poles over a pit. He manages to jump on each one with nimble grace (being an airbender and all), and the fire benders all stumble near the edge and can't follow him. Was this the part of their training grounds that they never used? Like houses that have a front room that no one ever sits in? Like the less popular Denny's in a town? Sure we went to all the rouble of digging this pit and putting in those planks, but it was more for the ambiance. They don't actually _use_ it. One has to wonder about the fire nation army that cannot successfully navigate their own training grounds.
5.) The voice-overs
I've heard people say that voice overs are a lazy plot device that never express things the actors can't express on their own, but I've never minded them. I think voice overs can be humorous and can help set up a scene. They have their place. Their place was not in this movie. Kitara kept narrating various things that could have been explained so easily and more interestingly with about one line of regular dialogue. Kitara's deadpan delivery felt like just stating the facts and getting on with the plot. It took all of the fun out of watching the movie and made it even more plodding than it already was. "We were making progress through the fire kingdom, but Sokka felt like we were being followed." Then camera pans behind them to show Sokka staring at a giant bonfire in the distance. He felt like you might be being followed, did he? What made him think that? Or how about, "At the North Pole, Sokka met the princess, who he really got along with." Why couldn't we have just seen them meet and watch him stammer for a few seconds? It would have gotten the point across without just telling us. It's terrible storytelling to tell you all the things you should just notice. I think I groaned at every voice over. They were all awful.
6.) The graphics
The reviews for this movie said that the graphics were good, but now I think they must have just been stretching to find something good to say about it. In a sea of bad, at least the special effects were ok. Honestly, that's about the most positive I could possibly be about it myself. In truth, they were sloppy and uninteresting. At one point when everyone was climbing Appa, I could see them stepping on the rungs of the ladder they were actually climbing. Appa and Momo were animated because they are major characters, but good luck finding one other animal in the whole series. That was one of the fun extra details of the cartoon. There were all these interesting hybrid animals, like tiger seals, moose lions, etc. For the cartoon, they put in the time to design characters that had no plot relevance whatsoever, just because they made the world a cuter, more interesting place. Very few shows are creative with the flora and fauna because it's usually not worth the time and effort, but it was refreshing to see in the cartoon and I enjoyed it. That was something that I thought even an incompetent director couldn't really mess up. Turns out he could. I guess he wanted to spend more of his special effects budget on... ugly Appa?
7.) The ambiance
When you watch the cartoon (and most children's programming really) the whole thing is awash in bright colors. Kids like bright colors, but it turns out M Night Shyamalan does not. This movie was so dark and drab. What type of mood was he trying to create? Everything felt grim and dirty and unhappy. Which brings us to the next point:
8.) The total absence of comic relief
Does everything have to be dark and serious all the time? Yes, apparently it does. Especially in season one of the cartoon, I was laughing all the time. Yes, their situation is serious, but the main characters are all kids. They still laugh and play and joke around. Sokka's ridiculous and Momo always gets a laugh. In the movie, Sokka was not funny. He's just about protecting his sister. Aang is not the playful kid of the series. He's a big pouty sad sack who doesn't want to be the Avatar because the monks said he could never have a family. Boo hoo. The drudgery just got tedious after a while. It was one of the least fun movies I have ever seen, but I guess that's what M Night Shyamalan does- suck the fun out of everything.
Honestly there were more things wrong with this movie as well, but I'm done writing about it. As much as I love the series, when/if the next movie comes out and it still has a 9% on rotten tomatoes, I'm just going to rewatch the series and content myself with that instead of spending money on a horrible movie that keeps my eyes pried to my watch instead of the screen.
Tuesday, July 6, 2010
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
Boredom
There are a lot of really commonly held myths out there. There are some things people just believe that aren't really true at all, but everyone sort of just believes it or buys into it. A simple example would be that pit bulls are violent. They aren't really at all. Another would be mind-body dualism, popular since the days of Descartes. Another things that's not really true. There are tons more of these, but there's one myth in particular that I've been thinking of a lot lately. Everyone thinks that work is bad, the sort of thing you only do because you have to. When I say I have the whole summer off, everyone is like, "oh I'm jealous." Really? I mean, really? What would you do if you had nothing you had to do? Depending on the person, you might get by just fine for the first week or so, but after a while, you start to run out of things to do. When you have nothing to do, that's when you really start to realize that there are 24 hours in the day, 24 long hours. Sure you can sleep away 8, maybe even 9 of them on a regular basis. You can cook for another two the three. You can take advantage of the greatest time waster, TV for perhaps 5, though you start to feel a bit sickly by the end of that. That takes us to 17 hours. There's still 7 hours to go. You can probably exercise for an hour of that. Down to 6. I've been surviving the last week or so filling that time with video games. That can cover about 4 more. Those were my most generous estimates and there are still two hours left in the day. I try to be a little productive, maybe fold some clothes or something, but there really aren't that many chores to do around the house. Sometimes I fill some time by taking a trip to the store. I recently read some comic books. Then I ran out of decent comic books to read. I try to get out of the house too, but I have nowhere to go most of the time. Everyone I'd like to hang out with is usually working and then when people are free, that's when Steven comes home and that's when I want to be cooking and spending time with him.
I don't mean to whine or go on bemoaning my free time or anything, but I do want to illustrate that there really isn't that much to do if all you've got is free time. And frankly, most of time fillers I listed above get really old after a while. I don't watch 5 hours of tv a day. I don't sleep 9 hours either. There's just a lot of time in the day when there's nothing you have to do. I'll probably figure out some way eventually to occupy myself with projects or something, but it's hard to get the energy to do anything when you don't have to do anything. Being woken up by an alarm and forced to go do something really gives you the energy to actually do it. When it's ok to sleep in and if you're not in the mood to do something it's no big deal, then things start to go bad. Since there's nothing I have to do, there's not a lot of meaning in anything I do. No one's counting on me to do anything. No one will mind if I go a day or two or three just lazing around. It's just not a very fun state to be in.
And this purgatory is what retirement must be like. And yet I know lots of people looking forward to their retirement and planning to retire as soon as possible. My dad has been wanting to retire for a while. Steven's dad is the same. He's going to retire as soon as he can. I hope he finds better ways to fill his time than I have because I think at that age, once you retire, you can't really go back. If there wasn't work on the horizon, I would be even more miserable. People go downhill after they retire. I've seen a lot of spry looking 70 year olds and the common link seems to be that they kept active and continued working. It doesn't have to be an 80 hour work week. Even part time would be enough. But having things that you have to do is kind of a gift. That's something that it took me a summer to get to learn. Next summer I'm going to be much more aggressive about finding myself something I need to do. I'll feel a lot better if I don't have so much free time like now.
I don't mean to whine or go on bemoaning my free time or anything, but I do want to illustrate that there really isn't that much to do if all you've got is free time. And frankly, most of time fillers I listed above get really old after a while. I don't watch 5 hours of tv a day. I don't sleep 9 hours either. There's just a lot of time in the day when there's nothing you have to do. I'll probably figure out some way eventually to occupy myself with projects or something, but it's hard to get the energy to do anything when you don't have to do anything. Being woken up by an alarm and forced to go do something really gives you the energy to actually do it. When it's ok to sleep in and if you're not in the mood to do something it's no big deal, then things start to go bad. Since there's nothing I have to do, there's not a lot of meaning in anything I do. No one's counting on me to do anything. No one will mind if I go a day or two or three just lazing around. It's just not a very fun state to be in.
And this purgatory is what retirement must be like. And yet I know lots of people looking forward to their retirement and planning to retire as soon as possible. My dad has been wanting to retire for a while. Steven's dad is the same. He's going to retire as soon as he can. I hope he finds better ways to fill his time than I have because I think at that age, once you retire, you can't really go back. If there wasn't work on the horizon, I would be even more miserable. People go downhill after they retire. I've seen a lot of spry looking 70 year olds and the common link seems to be that they kept active and continued working. It doesn't have to be an 80 hour work week. Even part time would be enough. But having things that you have to do is kind of a gift. That's something that it took me a summer to get to learn. Next summer I'm going to be much more aggressive about finding myself something I need to do. I'll feel a lot better if I don't have so much free time like now.
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
A post that's not about teaching
The title kind of ruins it by bringing it up though. Oh well.
I was getting kind of bummed that most of the shows I've been watching on hulu have run down to an end just in time for summer when I have lots of free time, but then I saw the season premier of True Beauty. God bless trashy television!
I was getting kind of bummed that most of the shows I've been watching on hulu have run down to an end just in time for summer when I have lots of free time, but then I saw the season premier of True Beauty. God bless trashy television!
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Student population
When you get started teaching, it's really easy to get totally overwhelmed and it's hard to see things sometimes. You know so little about what's ordinary that some things just slip right by. I don't really remember details from high school through the lens of a teacher. I knew jack shit about teaching then. All I remember is being a student, and a fairly studious one at that. Sometimes I look at my students now and I try to compare myself as a student to them. I have one student who finishes every assignment religiously and tries to get it right every time (not just write down crap). And I think, "was I like that?" I'm actually finding it hard to remember accurately. I think I remember getting all of my assignments done, though sometimes I didn't manage to read every assignment for history. That class was an extended lesson in skimming and I wasn't all that good at skimming and retaining, though I suppose most people aren't. I did get all of my math assignments done I remember, but that was mostly because I understood it and when you understand the problems, they go pretty fast. So maybe I was more like my student who finishes his assignments before I'm even done lecturing and always gets a perfect score on the tests. Except I don't remember getting perfect scores all that often. I was kind of sloppy on tests and would make careless errors. I have another student who is always helping the other students out, and I did that pretty often too. Nothing turns a good student into a stellar student like being willing to help others. Haroon is this super nice student who is constantly helping others, even when they're really far behind (he's kind of like the perfect student). I wouldn't call him the top student in the class, but most of the other students see him that way because he always knows how to help them out. I was a little like that because I was always tutoring other students. Haroon never finishes his work early, even though he's probably bright enough that he could, because he is always helping others around him. So that means he spends the entire hour of math class very actively engaged in and focused on math. He never gets much of a chance to zone out. He probably also spends time during lunch helping people out, and he takes the time to do his homework as well. So he gets a lot more math time than the average person. I'm relatively confident that helping my peers when I was a student made me spend a lot more time thinking about math, and spending more time makes you better at anything.
I don't thik I was too clear about where this train of thought was taking me at the beginning of this post. I began by talking about not knowing what was ordinary or not and then I kind of just shifted into comparisons between my high school self and my students. The order there is actually kind of backwards. I started this train of thought with my idle comparisons. The train of thought continued when I tried to compare other students who weren't all that much like me with my peers from high school. Were there students who zoned out in class? Were there student who didn't turn in any assignments? I realized thinking back that I was really very tunnel-visioned in high school. I think the big secret of high school is that everyone is tunnel-visioned. Everyone is so busy taking care of themselves and getting their own shit together that no one really pays attention to anyone else. I realize now that I was so focused on paying attention during lecture that I could not say one way or another if anyone else was. I have some vague memories of raising my hand and not being called on (despite being the only one raising my hand) because the teacher wanted other students to get a chance, which tells me in retrospect that no one else was really participating. As an adult and a teacher, that tells me that a lot of people weren't following along at all. As a kid I didn't really pay attention to whether or not other people knew the answer. Usually when I wasn't allowed to answer, someone would step up to the plate, so I think I just figured that other people knew and just didn't feel like participating. That was me sometimes too. Sometimes I would zone out and sometimes I just didn't feel like raising my hand. I never really considered that other people might not be following along at all. Considering that I retaught so many of my peers, especially in high school, I have to assume that most of them weren't really following along during lecture. My students at Mt Eden don't either, and it's interesting to realize that the students at a fancy private school aren't all that different.
But of course there are differences. Despite the fact that a lot of people weren't following along, I don't remember people talking during lecture. I couldn't say for sure if the other students took notes, but I think they did. Even if they didn't, I can say with relative certainty that they weren't talking. No one had phones out during class, though that was years ago when phones weren't quite so snazzy. Perhaps it has changed, but somehow I doubt it. I could believe that St Francis students also text on the sly like mine do, I would be shocked if they were constantly listening to music like mine. They think listening is having one headphone in. I mean seriously.
So anyway, when I was trying to make comparisons, this is where I started to think about what was ordinary and what wasn't. For a lot of first semester (and this semester too), I figured I wasn't really able to control the classroom because I was a new teacher and didn't know what the hell I was doing. All the things I thought would work definitely didn't. The amount of homework I assigned was wrong. The level of difficulty of the problems was wrong. The amount of lecture was wrong. My classroom management was WRONG wrong. And I just figured it was me and that I didn't know anything about anything. But now I'm thinking about it and I wonder... how much of my demeanor would have worked at St Francis? At St Francis, if a teacher told everyone to be quiet, everyone usually was. At least I think so. I'm kind of surprised by how hard it is to remember clearly, but I guess I am a very different person than I was in high school. It's almost like remembering someone else's life. But anyway, how difficult could I have made the problems at St Francis? How difficult could I have made the problems at Berkeley High? I remember putting in some really tricky problems in my tests when I was student teaching. And none of them were multiple choice. My students average a stone cold F on non multiple choice tests. As it is now, they actually do average a low C (in algebra 2- certainly not in algebra 1), as long as a take out the zeros. Now that's something that definitely didn't happen at St Francis. No zeros. If you didn't get the grade, you were asked to leave. Well, leave or donate 100k or something. There are a lot of really disruptive students who just wouldn't be there at St Francis- the students who can't even stay in their seats. Or keep from breaking your rulers in half. I hate that little shit Alfredo. Seriously- my class set of rulers is like 1/3 gone. All he'd have to do is cut class once and he'd be suspended, as opposed to now when it just goes down as a cut and maybe ends up giving his parents a truancy letter if he does it enough. He doesn't even have the decency to cut for the whole period. He stays for most of the period- long enough to raise hell, sexually harass the girls, throw paper balls, distract the kids that have trouble working, graffiti the desks, act disrespectful to me in front of the class, and generally make everything around him turn to shit. And then he leaves. You know, I could really just rip off his testicles. Wouldn't bat an eye.
Anyway, there are a lot of things at Mt Eden that just aren't ordinary. If you tell the kids to be quiet. That should be enough. They should be quiet. That is enough at other schools, and not just private schools. And Alfredo's behavior should never be tolerated. I write referrals, but nothing changes. Sometimes I pretend to write a referral so that he cuts earlier because he usually just walks out as soon as he thinks he's getting sent to the office. Well he's in for a surprise. I gave him detention- detention he'll never attend. So when he doesn't show up for a week, then that means they'll probably give him in house detention for two days (fingers crossed), which he'll probably also ditch and just get for real suspended, which may get him out of my hair for longer. Well... we'll see.
Anyway, the whole point of this blog is that I kind of realized it wasn't just me. I remember there was a first year teacher at St Francis that I had once. He had taught at community college before, but it was his first time teaching high school. And he didn't seem to struggle the way I did. It wasn't chaos in his classroom. So despite my total lack of experience of what's normal, I can kind of deduce from what little I know that even a bad teacher shouldn't have the discipline problems that I had. A large part of it is a difficult student population. It's kind of nice to know it's not just me.
I don't thik I was too clear about where this train of thought was taking me at the beginning of this post. I began by talking about not knowing what was ordinary or not and then I kind of just shifted into comparisons between my high school self and my students. The order there is actually kind of backwards. I started this train of thought with my idle comparisons. The train of thought continued when I tried to compare other students who weren't all that much like me with my peers from high school. Were there students who zoned out in class? Were there student who didn't turn in any assignments? I realized thinking back that I was really very tunnel-visioned in high school. I think the big secret of high school is that everyone is tunnel-visioned. Everyone is so busy taking care of themselves and getting their own shit together that no one really pays attention to anyone else. I realize now that I was so focused on paying attention during lecture that I could not say one way or another if anyone else was. I have some vague memories of raising my hand and not being called on (despite being the only one raising my hand) because the teacher wanted other students to get a chance, which tells me in retrospect that no one else was really participating. As an adult and a teacher, that tells me that a lot of people weren't following along at all. As a kid I didn't really pay attention to whether or not other people knew the answer. Usually when I wasn't allowed to answer, someone would step up to the plate, so I think I just figured that other people knew and just didn't feel like participating. That was me sometimes too. Sometimes I would zone out and sometimes I just didn't feel like raising my hand. I never really considered that other people might not be following along at all. Considering that I retaught so many of my peers, especially in high school, I have to assume that most of them weren't really following along during lecture. My students at Mt Eden don't either, and it's interesting to realize that the students at a fancy private school aren't all that different.
But of course there are differences. Despite the fact that a lot of people weren't following along, I don't remember people talking during lecture. I couldn't say for sure if the other students took notes, but I think they did. Even if they didn't, I can say with relative certainty that they weren't talking. No one had phones out during class, though that was years ago when phones weren't quite so snazzy. Perhaps it has changed, but somehow I doubt it. I could believe that St Francis students also text on the sly like mine do, I would be shocked if they were constantly listening to music like mine. They think listening is having one headphone in. I mean seriously.
So anyway, when I was trying to make comparisons, this is where I started to think about what was ordinary and what wasn't. For a lot of first semester (and this semester too), I figured I wasn't really able to control the classroom because I was a new teacher and didn't know what the hell I was doing. All the things I thought would work definitely didn't. The amount of homework I assigned was wrong. The level of difficulty of the problems was wrong. The amount of lecture was wrong. My classroom management was WRONG wrong. And I just figured it was me and that I didn't know anything about anything. But now I'm thinking about it and I wonder... how much of my demeanor would have worked at St Francis? At St Francis, if a teacher told everyone to be quiet, everyone usually was. At least I think so. I'm kind of surprised by how hard it is to remember clearly, but I guess I am a very different person than I was in high school. It's almost like remembering someone else's life. But anyway, how difficult could I have made the problems at St Francis? How difficult could I have made the problems at Berkeley High? I remember putting in some really tricky problems in my tests when I was student teaching. And none of them were multiple choice. My students average a stone cold F on non multiple choice tests. As it is now, they actually do average a low C (in algebra 2- certainly not in algebra 1), as long as a take out the zeros. Now that's something that definitely didn't happen at St Francis. No zeros. If you didn't get the grade, you were asked to leave. Well, leave or donate 100k or something. There are a lot of really disruptive students who just wouldn't be there at St Francis- the students who can't even stay in their seats. Or keep from breaking your rulers in half. I hate that little shit Alfredo. Seriously- my class set of rulers is like 1/3 gone. All he'd have to do is cut class once and he'd be suspended, as opposed to now when it just goes down as a cut and maybe ends up giving his parents a truancy letter if he does it enough. He doesn't even have the decency to cut for the whole period. He stays for most of the period- long enough to raise hell, sexually harass the girls, throw paper balls, distract the kids that have trouble working, graffiti the desks, act disrespectful to me in front of the class, and generally make everything around him turn to shit. And then he leaves. You know, I could really just rip off his testicles. Wouldn't bat an eye.
Anyway, there are a lot of things at Mt Eden that just aren't ordinary. If you tell the kids to be quiet. That should be enough. They should be quiet. That is enough at other schools, and not just private schools. And Alfredo's behavior should never be tolerated. I write referrals, but nothing changes. Sometimes I pretend to write a referral so that he cuts earlier because he usually just walks out as soon as he thinks he's getting sent to the office. Well he's in for a surprise. I gave him detention- detention he'll never attend. So when he doesn't show up for a week, then that means they'll probably give him in house detention for two days (fingers crossed), which he'll probably also ditch and just get for real suspended, which may get him out of my hair for longer. Well... we'll see.
Anyway, the whole point of this blog is that I kind of realized it wasn't just me. I remember there was a first year teacher at St Francis that I had once. He had taught at community college before, but it was his first time teaching high school. And he didn't seem to struggle the way I did. It wasn't chaos in his classroom. So despite my total lack of experience of what's normal, I can kind of deduce from what little I know that even a bad teacher shouldn't have the discipline problems that I had. A large part of it is a difficult student population. It's kind of nice to know it's not just me.
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Coworkers
I have a coworker Gil who is pretty friendly with me. He's always trying to help me out and give me advice and I help him out with scanning scantrons and entering data sometimes too. I can tell he enjoys my company (or maybe just having someone to give advice to who is likely to agree with him), but I often find myself kind of unsettled after talking to him. His methods are pretty different than mine. It's pretty disheartening because he's so much more effective than me too. I walk into his classroom and it's dead silent and most of the students are working. The ones that aren't working are at least not bothering the other students. And we have several of the same kids as well. One of mine, Ahkaila, was sitting quietly in her seat the whole time, when in my class, the phone is always out and she wanders out of the classroom at will. During my class she frequently yells out, often at really inappropriate times saying really inappropriate things. Sitting quietly was not even enough for Gil- he told her to do some work and she said no and he immediately threw her out of the class. If I threw out everyone who wasn't doing work, I'd have about three people left. And when I give Ahkaila a referral, she just bolts out of the room, often with a parting profanity or two. When Gil gave her a referral, she just quietly sat there and left quietly when the campus supervisor came to pick her up. It wasn't until after Gil started to call security that I even realized that Ahkaila had done something worthy of a referral. Sigh. Talking to Gil about it afterwards, he was describing how he gets them all in line, and I don't know that it's something I could do. Every teacher has their own style, so advice only goes so far, but it's kind of disheartening to hear advice I really don't want to take having such good results. He more or less treats them like dirt. He said "You've got to tell them to sit the fuck down." I said you couldn't cuss out the students. He said you can't say those words, but you can do it in your tone. There's something pretty callous about Gil really. We had a test a few weeks ago that had a scantron portion and a written portion. Today I helped him input the scantron portion. He made a comment about how he didn't know what their grades were until he scanned it in and I said that he still had to grade the written portions. He just sort of laughed at me and said he wasn't going to and it's not like he was ever going to return them anyway. That's not the way it's supposed to be. It really shouldn't be. Sigh.
I don't think I'd be so upset about the way Gil teaches if I wasn't so dissatisfied with how my class is run. It's a bit of a zoo. I mean, it's not like he's perfect. Far from it. Many of his students fail. But then again, so do many of mine. And perhaps in a few years I'll have a better results, but every part of me says you shouldn't get results the way Gil teaches and he pretty much unequivocally does. I guess I'll get better at it eventually, but I don't really want to be better at it the way that he is. I don't know. I guess I'm just down because I want a classroom like that, but I also don't. I'm very conflicted.
I don't think I'd be so upset about the way Gil teaches if I wasn't so dissatisfied with how my class is run. It's a bit of a zoo. I mean, it's not like he's perfect. Far from it. Many of his students fail. But then again, so do many of mine. And perhaps in a few years I'll have a better results, but every part of me says you shouldn't get results the way Gil teaches and he pretty much unequivocally does. I guess I'll get better at it eventually, but I don't really want to be better at it the way that he is. I don't know. I guess I'm just down because I want a classroom like that, but I also don't. I'm very conflicted.
Daylight Savings
I have not taken well to daylight savings this year. Usually I'm bitter for about a day and then I get over it, but I've been harboring a bitter resentment since Monday. I think it has to do with waking up in the dark each morning. I enjoyed waking up in the light quite a bit before. Now I wake up each morning and think "wah." Not the most inspiring way to start the day. I get bitter in the afternoon too. I feel like the sun is trying to trick me into staying at work longer. Overall I suppose I would say I have Daylight Savings Malaise, or DSM. It blows.
Saturday, February 6, 2010
Is it worth it?
About a month ago during winter break, Hilary and I were talking about teaching. She's been interested in going in to teaching for a while and now that graduation is close for her, she's started applying more seriously. She told me about her interview for Teach for America. One of the questions they asked her was what she would do if she was in a job where she felt overwhelmed, her class was out of control, her co-workers refused to work with her or help her, and the administration gave her no support at all. She said that in those circumstances she'd probably quit. I think their question was phrased a little differently, but whatever the exact wording was, it raised a lot of red flags for her. Who asks that in an interview? The only people who would are people who expect that to happen, or at least think it might be a possibility. She'd also heard me talking about how hard teaching was, so she asked if it was worth it, if I'd do it again. I told her no. Every veteran teacher I've talked to has always gone on about how important teaching is and how much of a difference you make, but I've never heard one try to dissuade me from teaching. Honestly, I wish a few of them had tried. It's not for everyone. It really isn't. Telling you how much you're needed really obscures away whether or not the job is right for you. It doesn't matter how much you are needed for a job if you're not happy with it. if someone needs advice about teaching, it really doesn't help to say how necessary it is. Yes, we know it's necessary, but what does the job entail? Is it a job I could be happy with? Is it worth devoting years of my life to a difficult profession? I think part of the fear is that if people knew what they were getting in to, there would be far fewer teachers. But why exactly is that a fear? They have always managed to find someone to fill positions. I guess the worry is that they'll find someone awful to fill a teaching position and that will be bad for the kids. In the end, anyone who tells you how important the job is is really trying to look out for the kids. It's an admirable goal, but it's important for the prospective teacher to realize that the advice is not given with their best interests at heart. I think the idea of veteran teachers is that they went through it and it wasn't so bad, or at least the bad part was over with in a year or two and as long as they can get a novice teacher through the first few years with guilt trips about how important the job is, they'll see that it's not so bad also. It's really selfish in a way. I've spoken with Hilary a few times about teaching and I could tell she didn't really know what the job entailed. No one really does until they have to do it themselves. I sure as hell didn't know and it took me even past my student teaching just to begin to start figuring it out. Hilary could become good at teaching eventually if she persevered at it. Frankly, anyone could if they just kept at it for long enough. But I also know with Hilary's temperament just how hard the first few years would be. It's hard for everyone, but I can tell it would definitely be hard for her. She was just starting to figure it out as well. Was it in her best interest to work at getting a credential and then have to go through even more difficulties teaching? Was it in my best interest? For me, I've already spent several years getting my credential and working on teaching, so the line is murkier, but if I knew three year ago what I know today, I'm not so sure I'd be on the same path.
That was my answer a month ago. Since then, things have been a little smoother. I have started to see what being a veteran teacher must be like. When I am no longer high stakes evaluated every year, when I am no longer pink slipped year after year, when I have my routines down, when I've seen all of the students' tricks, when I've gotten good enough to figure out which battles are worth fighting, when I've found which concepts are tricky for students, when I've accrued enough things worth putting on my walls, when I figure out how to grade quickly, as well as all the other things I haven't figured out that I need yet, the job actually has some pretty nice perks. I get a lot of vacation time. I can't be fired. There is always a market for my job. I can wear whatever I want to work. I have a lot of freedom and agency over how I conduct my day-to-day affairs. The job will always be intellectually satisfying and will never get boring. Some of these features are more valuable than others (such as the never being fired one - and all you have to do is put up with the guarantee of being fired for a few years straight), but they are all benefits in some way that wouldn't necessarily be a part of another job. The security that comes with being a veteran teacher is really worth something. I see Steven stress every day about his company getting a bad earnings report one quarter and firing him. I think he stresses a little unnecessarily, but I think most people worry about their jobs at one point or another. A job where you don't have to do that is pretty sweet. Of course, it's not worth it if you're miserable every day of the job, but I've gotten to the point where I'm not miserable every day. Eventually I think I'll be miserable even less. I am at the point where I have the general idea of what I'm supposed to be doing down. Now all I have to do is refine it.
But that brings us back to the point from earlier: is it worth it? Maybe one day I'll forget just how miserable the firsth alf of this year was, but right now it's pretty fresh in my mind. There are a lot of hard realities I've had to face teaching. My classroom management skills were awful. They are still awful, but I'm starting to get the hang of it a little. I've gotten better enough to realize that next year I will still be bad at it. Perhaps the year after that I will begin to be better, but it's still going to take a while for me to set everything up the way I want it. One of the other hard realities I've had to face is that my parents really didn't know a lot about discipline. I told my mom about how one of my students stole some tape from me and I was going to call his parents about it. She said "it's just tape. Let it go." I write a fair amount, but I'm honestly not sure how to put into words how much that flippant little phrase hurt me. It's hard to see someone you respect and have almost put on a pedestal make a mistake, and a serious one, and not even realize they were wrong. I felt like that in the beginning of the year and had to find out the hard way just how wrong that was. It was a very painful lesson, one that left me feeling like crap every day I walked out of that classroom, knowing how powerless I was and how I didn't know what I was doing. But it was a lesson I did learn in the end. I never realized until then that I was treating my students the way I had been raised. My parents left me to figure out what I should and shouldn't do. They didn't really force me to do anything. In some ways, this left me an independent person who had the freedom to choose the right path. In a lot of ways it was a good thing. I always felt like my judgement was good, as I was counted on to make pretty much all of my own decisions about my conduct. But kids are kids. They can't be counted on to make every decision correctly. There are some things that I decided weren't important somewhere along the line that really were in the end. My parents pretty much never made me clean my room. That wasn't important to me and it wasn't a battle they felt like fighting. I know my mom didn't like how messy my room was, but she left me to make my own decisions. She focused on how good I was in school instead. But organization is a skill, a skill you have to learn. Cleanliness is too, and kids can't always be counted on to realize how important it is. As I grow older, I'm starting to realize how bad clutter and mess can get when you have adult sized possessions and (this has been a great horror) papers, many of which are important and need to be saved somewhere.
I don't mean to put the burden or blame on my parents for how I turned out. For the most part, I really like how I turned out, but now that I'm finally out of school and out from under my parents' wing, I'm starting to notice how many important life skills I just don't have. Teaching brought that home to me a little faster than I think it otherwise would have come, but I think I would have figured out eventually that some of the things people have always said are important that I casually brushed off, might actually be important. I'm probably a more thoughtful individual since I've had a chance to realize this for myself instead of just doing as I was told and making my bed or cleaning my room or any of the other things kids are usually ordered to do by their parents, but it's a tough task to learn all these simple things that most people take for granted that you know. I don't really know how to sweep, mop, or vacuum. I'm not sure what a duster is supposed to accomplish (doesn't it just move dust around? How is that cleaner?). The vast array of cleaning utensils boggles my mind. When I first used a Lysol wipe, I thought it was magic. And I could come up with similar lists for cooking as well. I didn't know how to cut veggies, which things cooked the fastest, what temperatures different meats needed to be baked at, how a microplanar is different from a cheese grater (actually I still don't know that one. I have high hopes for figuring it out one day), how to clean a dirty pan, etc. So to tie this ramble back in to my point from earlier, I left for college not knowing all that much outside of what was absolutely necessary for school. I graduated college not a whole lot better in terms of practical skills. I had learned many of the rudimentary skills of cooking, but I was very lucky to have a convenient situation (the coops) and a good friend (Susan) to help me out. But even though I was lacking in all of these basic things, I never thought it was my parents' responsibility or that my mom had done anything less than being a perfect parent. In all honesty, she was an excellent parent in so many ways, but it wasn't until she made that comment about ignoring that student stealing from my desk that I realized she wasn't perfect, that there were things she missed. Then I saw all that struggling and suffering I'd gone through in the past few months because I wasn't prepared for what was awaiting me, and I had an idea of why I wasn't as prepared as I could have been. I almost broke down right there when I heard my mom make a comment consistent with beliefs I used to hold about discipline. It's so hard to shed beliefs you have about the world. You don't question where they came from. As long as they've always worked in your experience they must be fine, and it usually takes a lot of evidence otherwise to prove to yourself that they don't work. I had by that point had months of experience disproving that. And of course, at first you don't know exactly what it is that you're doing wrong, which belief you hold that is clearly not working. It takes a long while to figure it out and another long while to figure out what it is you should be doing differently. So after going through all that and coming to painful conclusions, I saw my mom espousing those same beliefs. She never realized that they were wrong. I saw where my beliefs had come from and I saw that my mom had steered me wrong. I knew from before that there were some things she was misguiding about, but I had never seen her be completely wrong. Since then, I've seen a lot of the ways in which she is fallible. She tries to convince you that she's right instead of just telling you. She doesn't ever tell you you have to do something, so she cajoles and reasons and when she really wants something, she manipulates. My brother's car is getting old and my mom wants him to get a new one, but he wants to keep it until the things is completely unsalvageable. It is getting to be a bit of a wreck, but it does still drive. The door doesn't open, most of the radio and dashboard buttons have fallen off, and it has more than 100,000 miles on it, but it does drive. My mom doesn't want to order Tony around, but she still wants him to do what she wants. She keeps offering arguments for why he should choose to get a new car himself, many of which are completely wrong. She tried the "girls won't like you with a beat up car" front. People do judge you based on what you drive sometimes. A first impression is important. This was her first argument and I think it's the real reason she wants him to stop driving that car. When Tony brushed that off, she moved on to the safety argument. Does she really think the airbags won't go off because the car is old? Or that the seatbelts won't work? That's not exactly the first things to fail. But that's what she was telling Tony when he was driving us around. It's untrue and she doesn't really believe it (though I'm sure she thinks she does), and that's what she said to Tony the whole time we were in the car when last we visited. During dinner, Tony got into a small argument with me. It was nothing big. We fight a lot when we're together actually because he has a very different view of the world and we occasionally butt heads over it. Two days later he called apologizing and was hoping I wasn't upset. I could tell my mom had been harping at him over those two days. He sounded so miserable. I wasn't even mad. That's just how our interactions go sometimes. He needs to get out of that house. I don't know how to tell him he does either. Next time I see him I'll try to bring it up.
When I think about it, a lot of the realizations I've made have been good things. It is important for me to see my mom's flaws as well as her strengths. It is important for me to grow a backbone and get over telling people what to do. I have grown a lot as a person by teaching. I don't know that it was the best way to learn. It certainly wasn't the easiest way, but it might have been the fastest. So again, we come back to "is it worth it?" And whatever answer I come up with to that question, will that still be my answer in a year? Two years? Ten? I don't know if I can answer this question now. One thing I really regret is that I never tried anything else. I never tried going into the job market with no idea what job I wanted or what I'd be required to do if I was hired. I never sent out mass resumes. Frankly, I took the simple path. I honed in on one of the few jobs I was even remotely familiar with and did the appropriate actions to follow through with it. There are millions of jobs out there, many of which I think I would be fine at, but I don't even know they exist. They're the jobs that happen behind the scenes that no one ever hears about, like Susan's. There's no major in college that prepares you for them. I wish I had gone into the "real" job market - the one where you're not set on a particular path in a particular direction by schooling before you're even on the hunt for a job. I wish I could compare teaching to some other job. Steven says all jobs are hard, but you never really understand until you experience it for yourself. I want to experience what another job is like, but it's not really reasonable for me to do that now. It doesn't make a lot of sense. Maybe I can try for a part time job in summer. Until then, I don't know if I can answer whether or not this job is worth it. A lot of the perks, I can't really appreciate without comparison. Maybe the autonomy my job allows isn't important to me but how will I know unless I get a job without much autonomy? Maybe the downsides of teaching outweigh the perks. If that's the case, then it really isn't worth it. Maybe I can't appreciate the perks now because I don't know how awful it would be without them. I do know this: if I had to do it over again, I'd do it different. I really didn't know what I was getting into with teaching. I needed to experience the world more and grow up a little more before even considering it. I wish I had braved the uncertainty and gone hunting for a job right after college. Perhaps one day I will give it a try. Perhaps I'll come back to the teaching profession afterwards. I just feel like right now, I don't have a lot of information and I made choices in my life that left me ill-prepared and ill-informed. Is it worth it? At this point, maybe. Then again, maybe not. I will keep working through the year. I'll give next year a try too. I think a third year would be pretty informative as well, but I'm not ready to think that far ahead. For now I need to put these thoughts on the back burner and deal with the present one day at a time. This is a question I'll revisit periodically, but for right now, I just can't answer it.
That was my answer a month ago. Since then, things have been a little smoother. I have started to see what being a veteran teacher must be like. When I am no longer high stakes evaluated every year, when I am no longer pink slipped year after year, when I have my routines down, when I've seen all of the students' tricks, when I've gotten good enough to figure out which battles are worth fighting, when I've found which concepts are tricky for students, when I've accrued enough things worth putting on my walls, when I figure out how to grade quickly, as well as all the other things I haven't figured out that I need yet, the job actually has some pretty nice perks. I get a lot of vacation time. I can't be fired. There is always a market for my job. I can wear whatever I want to work. I have a lot of freedom and agency over how I conduct my day-to-day affairs. The job will always be intellectually satisfying and will never get boring. Some of these features are more valuable than others (such as the never being fired one - and all you have to do is put up with the guarantee of being fired for a few years straight), but they are all benefits in some way that wouldn't necessarily be a part of another job. The security that comes with being a veteran teacher is really worth something. I see Steven stress every day about his company getting a bad earnings report one quarter and firing him. I think he stresses a little unnecessarily, but I think most people worry about their jobs at one point or another. A job where you don't have to do that is pretty sweet. Of course, it's not worth it if you're miserable every day of the job, but I've gotten to the point where I'm not miserable every day. Eventually I think I'll be miserable even less. I am at the point where I have the general idea of what I'm supposed to be doing down. Now all I have to do is refine it.
But that brings us back to the point from earlier: is it worth it? Maybe one day I'll forget just how miserable the firsth alf of this year was, but right now it's pretty fresh in my mind. There are a lot of hard realities I've had to face teaching. My classroom management skills were awful. They are still awful, but I'm starting to get the hang of it a little. I've gotten better enough to realize that next year I will still be bad at it. Perhaps the year after that I will begin to be better, but it's still going to take a while for me to set everything up the way I want it. One of the other hard realities I've had to face is that my parents really didn't know a lot about discipline. I told my mom about how one of my students stole some tape from me and I was going to call his parents about it. She said "it's just tape. Let it go." I write a fair amount, but I'm honestly not sure how to put into words how much that flippant little phrase hurt me. It's hard to see someone you respect and have almost put on a pedestal make a mistake, and a serious one, and not even realize they were wrong. I felt like that in the beginning of the year and had to find out the hard way just how wrong that was. It was a very painful lesson, one that left me feeling like crap every day I walked out of that classroom, knowing how powerless I was and how I didn't know what I was doing. But it was a lesson I did learn in the end. I never realized until then that I was treating my students the way I had been raised. My parents left me to figure out what I should and shouldn't do. They didn't really force me to do anything. In some ways, this left me an independent person who had the freedom to choose the right path. In a lot of ways it was a good thing. I always felt like my judgement was good, as I was counted on to make pretty much all of my own decisions about my conduct. But kids are kids. They can't be counted on to make every decision correctly. There are some things that I decided weren't important somewhere along the line that really were in the end. My parents pretty much never made me clean my room. That wasn't important to me and it wasn't a battle they felt like fighting. I know my mom didn't like how messy my room was, but she left me to make my own decisions. She focused on how good I was in school instead. But organization is a skill, a skill you have to learn. Cleanliness is too, and kids can't always be counted on to realize how important it is. As I grow older, I'm starting to realize how bad clutter and mess can get when you have adult sized possessions and (this has been a great horror) papers, many of which are important and need to be saved somewhere.
I don't mean to put the burden or blame on my parents for how I turned out. For the most part, I really like how I turned out, but now that I'm finally out of school and out from under my parents' wing, I'm starting to notice how many important life skills I just don't have. Teaching brought that home to me a little faster than I think it otherwise would have come, but I think I would have figured out eventually that some of the things people have always said are important that I casually brushed off, might actually be important. I'm probably a more thoughtful individual since I've had a chance to realize this for myself instead of just doing as I was told and making my bed or cleaning my room or any of the other things kids are usually ordered to do by their parents, but it's a tough task to learn all these simple things that most people take for granted that you know. I don't really know how to sweep, mop, or vacuum. I'm not sure what a duster is supposed to accomplish (doesn't it just move dust around? How is that cleaner?). The vast array of cleaning utensils boggles my mind. When I first used a Lysol wipe, I thought it was magic. And I could come up with similar lists for cooking as well. I didn't know how to cut veggies, which things cooked the fastest, what temperatures different meats needed to be baked at, how a microplanar is different from a cheese grater (actually I still don't know that one. I have high hopes for figuring it out one day), how to clean a dirty pan, etc. So to tie this ramble back in to my point from earlier, I left for college not knowing all that much outside of what was absolutely necessary for school. I graduated college not a whole lot better in terms of practical skills. I had learned many of the rudimentary skills of cooking, but I was very lucky to have a convenient situation (the coops) and a good friend (Susan) to help me out. But even though I was lacking in all of these basic things, I never thought it was my parents' responsibility or that my mom had done anything less than being a perfect parent. In all honesty, she was an excellent parent in so many ways, but it wasn't until she made that comment about ignoring that student stealing from my desk that I realized she wasn't perfect, that there were things she missed. Then I saw all that struggling and suffering I'd gone through in the past few months because I wasn't prepared for what was awaiting me, and I had an idea of why I wasn't as prepared as I could have been. I almost broke down right there when I heard my mom make a comment consistent with beliefs I used to hold about discipline. It's so hard to shed beliefs you have about the world. You don't question where they came from. As long as they've always worked in your experience they must be fine, and it usually takes a lot of evidence otherwise to prove to yourself that they don't work. I had by that point had months of experience disproving that. And of course, at first you don't know exactly what it is that you're doing wrong, which belief you hold that is clearly not working. It takes a long while to figure it out and another long while to figure out what it is you should be doing differently. So after going through all that and coming to painful conclusions, I saw my mom espousing those same beliefs. She never realized that they were wrong. I saw where my beliefs had come from and I saw that my mom had steered me wrong. I knew from before that there were some things she was misguiding about, but I had never seen her be completely wrong. Since then, I've seen a lot of the ways in which she is fallible. She tries to convince you that she's right instead of just telling you. She doesn't ever tell you you have to do something, so she cajoles and reasons and when she really wants something, she manipulates. My brother's car is getting old and my mom wants him to get a new one, but he wants to keep it until the things is completely unsalvageable. It is getting to be a bit of a wreck, but it does still drive. The door doesn't open, most of the radio and dashboard buttons have fallen off, and it has more than 100,000 miles on it, but it does drive. My mom doesn't want to order Tony around, but she still wants him to do what she wants. She keeps offering arguments for why he should choose to get a new car himself, many of which are completely wrong. She tried the "girls won't like you with a beat up car" front. People do judge you based on what you drive sometimes. A first impression is important. This was her first argument and I think it's the real reason she wants him to stop driving that car. When Tony brushed that off, she moved on to the safety argument. Does she really think the airbags won't go off because the car is old? Or that the seatbelts won't work? That's not exactly the first things to fail. But that's what she was telling Tony when he was driving us around. It's untrue and she doesn't really believe it (though I'm sure she thinks she does), and that's what she said to Tony the whole time we were in the car when last we visited. During dinner, Tony got into a small argument with me. It was nothing big. We fight a lot when we're together actually because he has a very different view of the world and we occasionally butt heads over it. Two days later he called apologizing and was hoping I wasn't upset. I could tell my mom had been harping at him over those two days. He sounded so miserable. I wasn't even mad. That's just how our interactions go sometimes. He needs to get out of that house. I don't know how to tell him he does either. Next time I see him I'll try to bring it up.
When I think about it, a lot of the realizations I've made have been good things. It is important for me to see my mom's flaws as well as her strengths. It is important for me to grow a backbone and get over telling people what to do. I have grown a lot as a person by teaching. I don't know that it was the best way to learn. It certainly wasn't the easiest way, but it might have been the fastest. So again, we come back to "is it worth it?" And whatever answer I come up with to that question, will that still be my answer in a year? Two years? Ten? I don't know if I can answer this question now. One thing I really regret is that I never tried anything else. I never tried going into the job market with no idea what job I wanted or what I'd be required to do if I was hired. I never sent out mass resumes. Frankly, I took the simple path. I honed in on one of the few jobs I was even remotely familiar with and did the appropriate actions to follow through with it. There are millions of jobs out there, many of which I think I would be fine at, but I don't even know they exist. They're the jobs that happen behind the scenes that no one ever hears about, like Susan's. There's no major in college that prepares you for them. I wish I had gone into the "real" job market - the one where you're not set on a particular path in a particular direction by schooling before you're even on the hunt for a job. I wish I could compare teaching to some other job. Steven says all jobs are hard, but you never really understand until you experience it for yourself. I want to experience what another job is like, but it's not really reasonable for me to do that now. It doesn't make a lot of sense. Maybe I can try for a part time job in summer. Until then, I don't know if I can answer whether or not this job is worth it. A lot of the perks, I can't really appreciate without comparison. Maybe the autonomy my job allows isn't important to me but how will I know unless I get a job without much autonomy? Maybe the downsides of teaching outweigh the perks. If that's the case, then it really isn't worth it. Maybe I can't appreciate the perks now because I don't know how awful it would be without them. I do know this: if I had to do it over again, I'd do it different. I really didn't know what I was getting into with teaching. I needed to experience the world more and grow up a little more before even considering it. I wish I had braved the uncertainty and gone hunting for a job right after college. Perhaps one day I will give it a try. Perhaps I'll come back to the teaching profession afterwards. I just feel like right now, I don't have a lot of information and I made choices in my life that left me ill-prepared and ill-informed. Is it worth it? At this point, maybe. Then again, maybe not. I will keep working through the year. I'll give next year a try too. I think a third year would be pretty informative as well, but I'm not ready to think that far ahead. For now I need to put these thoughts on the back burner and deal with the present one day at a time. This is a question I'll revisit periodically, but for right now, I just can't answer it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)