This comparison came to me not long ago and ever since I've been thinking about the parallels. There are more of them than I would have expected actually.
The similarity that originally struck me was the learning curve. When I first began playing Angband, it was such a slow and painful process. Ever minute or so, I had to ask someone how to do something. I might not have continued playing the game if I wasn't playing it in the same room as several other Angband enthusiasts that I could routinely ask for help. But everyone around me was playing it and they seemed to be having fun, so I stuck with it and grappled with all the different commands I had to learn (I want to drink... what do I do? Quaff???). Learning all the commands and getting to be fluid with them was actually a pretty slow process as I remember. In fact, it was so slow and subtle that I didn't even realize when I stopped pausing every few seconds to ask someone what I should do. And questions still came up from time to time as the game progressed (What's elvenkind?), but the mechanics of the game started to become much more automated for me. I didn't have to think about them so much (I need to drink? q. Move on.). I wasn't even aware how natural it had gotten until it hit me all of a sudden. It was about the same time that I realized I was having fun.
I had that same surprising realization recently with teaching. I can't think of any other time I've had this same exact feeling. It's sort of a surprised "Wait... I like this?" That's not too surprising actually. Very rarely do we persist in something that's not fun for an extended period of time. Things with a steep learning curve spend a lot of time being just not fun. They're initially hard, strenuous, frustrating, and depressing. I can't say I got too depressed over Angband (though losing a character you've worked on for days just because you stopped paying attention for a second is really annoying), but teaching has been a strain on me. There have been times when I've wallowed for hours after class because I had a really bad day. At least once this semester (if not more), I seriously considered quitting and trying something less painful. The job was so hard and, more often than not, not particularly rewarding. Often you get smacked on your ass by a student who wants to be difficult just because they can, or an angry parent will start to yell at you because everything is not perfect for their child. Or worse yet, you just confuse everyone and then you have to go through the painful process of grading a bunch of tests that make everyone's grades drop. Sometimes the test is the first indication I have that something is wrong, and by then it's too late. That's a really frustrating situation to be in.
There are a lot of frustrating situations. Teaching is just one long string of frustrating situations. I was doing it because it was something really important and I thought I could make a difference, but it was a constant struggle.
Then, almost imperceptibly, I struggled a little less. Of course, I still flopped quite heartily quite often. I flopped enough that I don't think I realized I was struggling less.
Then, after enough time spent flopping and struggling and messing up, a day goes smoothly. You feel good about a day well done.
Then you flop the next day and forget all about it.
Then another smooth day goes by. Then, slowly yet surely, the good days start to outnumber the flops. You start to make predictions about how certain things will go. You start asking students questions that don't confuse them as much. You get a sense for how long certain activities will take. You get the knack of designing a worksheet in 10 minutes. Then you start to get the knack of making that worksheet accomplish something good.
Then you suddenly realize it. You don't realize, "oh I'm good at this." That's not what I realized about Angband. It wouldn't have been true either. I couldn't legitimately get past level 40 or 50 as I recall. The real realization you come across is, "Oh! That was fun!" There is a sense of accomplishment about actually knowing how to maneuver yourself through an ASCII world or a classroom of teenagers, but that in itself isn't fun. It's satisfying certainly, and maybe that can give a feeling of fun, but I'm not sure it's quite the same. I actually enjoyed class today. I'm not going to say that's never happened before, but today was one of the first days when it really struck me, when I realized with a start that what had been a chore and a difficult yet necessary job in my mind for so long actually left me feeling happy. That doesn't happen often, in part because I'm a strict self critic when it comes to teaching and in part because I'm so used to being in the top 10% of things I do that being considerably worse than that is really frustrating.
But today I felt went really well. And it felt like I had something to do with it going well. I made good choices. I asked the right questions. I set up the right problems for them to work on. The kids weren't just having a good day, though that may have also been true. It went well and it was more than just luck. I did things right, and I got to see the benefits of that.
And the benefits are good. :D
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
Friday, August 15, 2008
Finally Blogging
I haven't blogged in a while and I've missed it. I've been itching to blog for week without really getting much of an opportunity to do so. It seems like my every spare moment has been taken up with math or the many distractions in my new house. Math 104 just ended yesterday and it was certainly hard. I did have to spend a lot of time studying for that class. It wouldn't have been so bad if I hadn't moved right before the second midterm. I didn't have a lot of time to study for that test and did pretty average on it (in that I scored the mean), so I felt like I had to study extra hard for the final I took yesterday. It was hard to focus too. The day before my final, there was happy nerdiness going on all day long. Two games of Puerto Rico were played, and video games were on the rest of the time. I was very hard to keep focused, especially with Aaron insisting that I play. He was little too insistent for my tastes, and I was a little annoyed since it was the day before my final, but I'll appreciate him as another player in games on some other day.
I feel like I've skipped some background here. If you're paying attention to the bits and pieces I've been mentioning, you know that I live in a new place and that nerdiness happens there, but those are just general senses of what going on. I'd like to get a little more in to the nitty gritty of it all.
So let's talk a little about moving. I finally live with Steven now and it's great. Before we moved in together, we were really chafing about having to part ways every Sunday. It just wasn't enough to see him only on the weekends. I remember there were a few weeknights where we just had to see each other and I went over to his place for the night. It was really inconvenient since I had to wake up early to go to class the next day, but sometimes we just couldn't stand being apart. And without exception Sunday nights were a bitter experience. I remember when I had to go to manager meetings on Sundays. I was so cranky and grouchy and bit everyone's heads off. I remember our president Roxy would try to get the meetings started with cute little games. Another time of the week and I might have appreciated it, but Sunday nights I never did. I feel like I was part of the reason that she didn't like being president. Not that she held it against me I don't think. And to be honest, I'm not even sure she disliked being president. I remember her saying once that she probably wouldn't run again and didn't think it was really for her. She's one of those people who is really pure. She likes to do sweet things and take care of children. She does well around children, but not necessarily around people who make dirty jokes and ask her to show off her cleavage. And she's also the sort of person who wouldn't get mad about stuff like that, but you could tell she didn't appreciate it. I often felt like she was repressing herself a little to act appropriately in the face of some of Stebbins' darker elements when she was actually pretty bothered. But who knows. I think she enjoyed herself most of the time, so it was actually probably pretty easy for her to ignore the stuff she didn't like. She did still try to do cute little games, which children probably would have appreciated a lot more than busy college students, even as I shot her down. I feel bad about it a little, but the idea was pretty misplaced. Sure it's great if you've got nothing else better to do and everything's great for you, but when things aren't great, you want to get down to business, not play a little game. I was a little mean, she was a little shortsighted; it all evens out. I don't regret it.
Nor do I regret my non-manager status. I never really enjoyed being a manager. I took satisfaction in doing my job well, and I liked seeing it done well, and I especially hated seeing it done poorly, but I was still glad that it wasn't my responsibility. I was glad that I was able to pull up stakes and leave two thirds of the way through the summer to live with Steven. Yes, I had my frustrating moments through the summer when I disagreed with Sabira's policies and had to fight them, but even then the fight was kind of fun. Overall, I would rather not have to fight about things, but it is satisfying to win. And fighting her policies didn't really take that long. Certainly it took longer than being workshift manager, which is compensated pitifully during summer. Even when I increased the summer comp, it was still pretty pitiful. So maybe I shouldn't be too surprised that Sabira was the only one who ran, and when there's no competition, there's often low quality close behind. But I can't complain too much. She was a lot better than Matt Jones or Jon Hung. Better than Even by a wide margin too. This actually makes me think that maybe I'm too picky about the job and how I think it should be run. The only other workshift manager in my memory was Aron Bothman. I didn't experience him much first hand. I came in late and he didn't assign me any permanent workshifts, so I went down a bunch of hours. I guess in that sense he wasn't so hot. But that sort of thing is a pain, especially under the old system of workshift. I don't fault him too much. Apparently he was pretty on top of things in his day (which was before my time). But he was an incumbent for too long and got kind of lazy. At least that's what I've heard. I was only around for the very tail end of his regime, so I can't really make any of these comments from personal experience.
As much as I do love to ramble, I'd like to put this digression back on track: our new place. We did some house hunting online, but when it came down to actually looking at places, we only looked at two. Did we get the best deal we could? Who knows. Given how much time we were willing to put in to it, I think we did fine. As it stands, I love our place, and it's hard to put a price tag on satisfaction. It's a really cute place in a really convenient location. It has a nice kitchen and a two car garage. It looks really really spacious (and actually does have a pretty large square footage - 1380), and there's lots of storage space. Though some of the things I love the most about are things I would love about any house. I love being able to keep our stuff in common space without fear of it getting stolen. I love having nice things and not worrying about them getting destroyed by drunk Stebbinites. I love living in a house where I know I get along with everybody. A couple people warned me that a couple living in a house with one other person would result in a lot of third wheeling and awkwardness, but it hasn't happened yet. I think Susan and Steven and I are all getting along great. I really like our dynamic. It's going to be a really fun year I think. :)
One of the things facilitating the fun is all of our common interests. We're all a bunch of nerds. We've got Star Trek dvds on the table, Magic cards in the corner, more video game consoles than I could carry, and a handful of nerdy board games (which we actually have enough players around to play on a regular basis!). I love being immersed in all the nerdiness. Living in Stebbins, and in Berkeley in general, nerdiness is more a point of pride than one of shame, but there are people who do look down on nerdy things. It's a real downer when you come across one of those. They're generally people who have believed what others have told them without investigating for themselves. For instance, most people who dislike video games haven't actually played much of them. I don't mind them having their own opinions, but it seems like more often than not, people who dislike video games will look down on those who do. I don't look down on people who like to boat, even though it holds no interest for me. I don't look down on people who fish. I don't look down on people who go to museums. None of these things are my favorite activities. I've never fished, or been on a boat recreationally, and I rarely visit museums (and can often find myself bored when I do go). But that doesn't mean I don't see any worth in it. If it makes someone happy, then go for it. It's not hurting anyone; it's just how you choose to spend your free time. So don't be so judgmental about how I spend mine.
But realistically, everyone agrees with the statement I just made. No one thinks they're judgmental, or if they do end up judging something, they just say that that something merits it. And I think a lot of people aren't really aware that they look down on video games. They really don't think about it that often. I had difficulty coming up with examples of things I don't think about often just a moment ago. It's hard to think about something that you don't consider much. It's just that when video games do present themselves, when people do come across someone with a controller in their hands, it's like a knee jerk reaction to react negatively. I remember whenever Sabira entered a room with people playing video games, she would always leave as soon as she could because she claimed that video games were antisocial. If the type of social they keep away is Sabira's company, I don't think I mind too much. As it is, I feel very social when playing video games most of the time. Even one player games are fun to watch.
I don't know why I'm defending video games or even complaining about the disrespect they receive. It's not like it's going to change matters. I won't change anyone's opinions, but I will admit it is something of a sore spot for me. It makes it easy to rant and ramble whenever I think about it.
But back to some of the main things I was talking about. I feel like I've gone over the new house a little. Sure, there's more to tell, but perhaps now it's time to move on to a different topic, another one that was covered briefly in my introduction paragraph. Math 104 was a very difficult class for me. Everyone always said it was going to be crazy hard, and I believed them, but sometimes you have to experience something yourself to really understand it. There was some pretty crazy stuff there near the end. But the thing is, I felt like I could have understood all of it given more time. Taking this class over the summer was really hard. It's not like I had any choice in the matter, but nonetheless, I wish I had been able to take it in the fall or spring. Part of me is just glad to have it done, but I feel like I would have learned it a lot better if I had been able to go at a slower pace. I just don't feel like I got much out of this course. I felt like I was cramming the whole time. Trying to squeeze all that complicated information into my head at once makes me feel like none of it is going to stick. Even now, one day later, I don't feel like I can remember all of the little details I knew a day ago. I feel like I took this class for a reason, not just to have taken it, but given how much I took from the class, I don't know that I achieved its purpose. I was supposed to gain some insight into calculus, and maybe I did. But I really don't feel like a lot more enlightened now than I was at the beginning of summer. After taking abstract algebra and linear algebra last summer, I really felt like I knew a lot about algebra and numbers in general leaving those classes. I really learned a lot. For this class, I crammed a lot. I showed good test taking skills. But do I have some intuitive grasp on calculus? Not really. I guess I do understand some concepts better this time around than I did the first time I learned them in high school (and I learned them pretty well in high school), and I guess that will be useful (it's always important for the teacher to know a little more than she has to teach), but I worked really hard and I just don't feel like I got the same payout. It's a little embittering, especially considering all the painful stuff I had to go through. To give an idea of how crazy tough our final was, about three fourths of the way through, the guy next to me started to cry. I felt really awful. I couldn't focus on him that much because I had a test of my own to take, but I remember rooting for him silently for a second or two. "Just keep it together for another half hour! You're almost there!" There's nothing like feeling miserable to ensure that you really bomb a test though. You get into this spiral of unproductivity. You just think a lot slower when you're fighting off tears, and you know that you're moving slower and that makes you even more frustrated and makes you want to cry more. I've never broken down like that during a test, but I've had my breakdowns before. I know how he felt and I felt really bad for him. Our teacher admitted at the end that it was an exceptionally hard final and he felt bad about a few of the questions, but I could tell he didn't feel too bad about it. He always said the whole time, "It all comes out in the wash," meaning everyone else had to go through it too, so comparatively, you don't look so bad. But why make everyone go through such hardship? I know you want to differentiate the students and you don't want to give two people who differ by only a few points two different grades. You also don't want to dock someone who worked hard for making a stupid mistake if they know the concepts. But is a crazy hard test really the way to do that? I don't know if I can feel positively about something that creates that much misery. Also, how do you the sheer impossibility of a test won't just discourage someone who knows the material? I've known people who seem like they know what's going on turn around and bomb a test. One of my better students last semester did much worse than her peers who weren't as smart and didn't work as hard. Some of that might just be test anxiety (it's hard to compare a middle school student to college students in an upper div math class), but I think it just shows another example that tests are not always the most accurate measure of skill. The guy next to me seemed like he had his shit together the whole class. He was probably crying because he thought he wouldn't be above the mean, not because he thought he would fail. But what if he had thought that other people would find the test equally hard instead of thinking about how he didn't get it? Thinking one of those two thoughts over the other isn't exactly indicative of mathematical skill. But the person who thought other people were struggling too would have done better on that test than someone who started to despair, even if they had the same mathematical skills. More than once during that test I looked at a question and thought "Ummm... well this isn't happening," but at the same time I also thought that it wasn't happening for a lot of other people either. And so I just kept flipping pages until I found a problem that was happening. I've yet to see how I did. I could believe anything from a little below the mean to an SD above. I really didn't know what was going on, and there's no way to judge how it went for other people. I guess I'll find out in the next couple days when the grades get posted. Whatever my grade is, even if it's an A, I'm a little dissatisfied. I don't think I, or anyone else in the calss, learned the material that well. We certainly didn't learn it well enough to have any sort of hope on that final. And I know you're not supposed to do well on upper division math finals, but it really is disheartening to be so thoroughly trounced and feel like you didn't really learn a lot. I'm not as down about the whole thing as I'm coming off, but I do feel like it wasn't the most valuable use of my time. It is a little disappointing to work hard and suffer for not much payout. I did work hard. I did suffer. And what have I got to show for it?
Sorry to end on a bit of a low note, but that all for this blog entry. I've got a few more topics in mind for blog entries though that should be a little cheerier. To give a little spoiler of things to come, they will be titled "Comic-con is super amazing fantastic!" and "Pruning". The first one sounds more exciting than the second, but I'm a little more personally interested in the second one. It's not quite what it sounds like. Ok. That's enough of a teaser for now. More to come in a little while (not so long a dry spell as last time, in other words)!
I feel like I've skipped some background here. If you're paying attention to the bits and pieces I've been mentioning, you know that I live in a new place and that nerdiness happens there, but those are just general senses of what going on. I'd like to get a little more in to the nitty gritty of it all.
So let's talk a little about moving. I finally live with Steven now and it's great. Before we moved in together, we were really chafing about having to part ways every Sunday. It just wasn't enough to see him only on the weekends. I remember there were a few weeknights where we just had to see each other and I went over to his place for the night. It was really inconvenient since I had to wake up early to go to class the next day, but sometimes we just couldn't stand being apart. And without exception Sunday nights were a bitter experience. I remember when I had to go to manager meetings on Sundays. I was so cranky and grouchy and bit everyone's heads off. I remember our president Roxy would try to get the meetings started with cute little games. Another time of the week and I might have appreciated it, but Sunday nights I never did. I feel like I was part of the reason that she didn't like being president. Not that she held it against me I don't think. And to be honest, I'm not even sure she disliked being president. I remember her saying once that she probably wouldn't run again and didn't think it was really for her. She's one of those people who is really pure. She likes to do sweet things and take care of children. She does well around children, but not necessarily around people who make dirty jokes and ask her to show off her cleavage. And she's also the sort of person who wouldn't get mad about stuff like that, but you could tell she didn't appreciate it. I often felt like she was repressing herself a little to act appropriately in the face of some of Stebbins' darker elements when she was actually pretty bothered. But who knows. I think she enjoyed herself most of the time, so it was actually probably pretty easy for her to ignore the stuff she didn't like. She did still try to do cute little games, which children probably would have appreciated a lot more than busy college students, even as I shot her down. I feel bad about it a little, but the idea was pretty misplaced. Sure it's great if you've got nothing else better to do and everything's great for you, but when things aren't great, you want to get down to business, not play a little game. I was a little mean, she was a little shortsighted; it all evens out. I don't regret it.
Nor do I regret my non-manager status. I never really enjoyed being a manager. I took satisfaction in doing my job well, and I liked seeing it done well, and I especially hated seeing it done poorly, but I was still glad that it wasn't my responsibility. I was glad that I was able to pull up stakes and leave two thirds of the way through the summer to live with Steven. Yes, I had my frustrating moments through the summer when I disagreed with Sabira's policies and had to fight them, but even then the fight was kind of fun. Overall, I would rather not have to fight about things, but it is satisfying to win. And fighting her policies didn't really take that long. Certainly it took longer than being workshift manager, which is compensated pitifully during summer. Even when I increased the summer comp, it was still pretty pitiful. So maybe I shouldn't be too surprised that Sabira was the only one who ran, and when there's no competition, there's often low quality close behind. But I can't complain too much. She was a lot better than Matt Jones or Jon Hung. Better than Even by a wide margin too. This actually makes me think that maybe I'm too picky about the job and how I think it should be run. The only other workshift manager in my memory was Aron Bothman. I didn't experience him much first hand. I came in late and he didn't assign me any permanent workshifts, so I went down a bunch of hours. I guess in that sense he wasn't so hot. But that sort of thing is a pain, especially under the old system of workshift. I don't fault him too much. Apparently he was pretty on top of things in his day (which was before my time). But he was an incumbent for too long and got kind of lazy. At least that's what I've heard. I was only around for the very tail end of his regime, so I can't really make any of these comments from personal experience.
As much as I do love to ramble, I'd like to put this digression back on track: our new place. We did some house hunting online, but when it came down to actually looking at places, we only looked at two. Did we get the best deal we could? Who knows. Given how much time we were willing to put in to it, I think we did fine. As it stands, I love our place, and it's hard to put a price tag on satisfaction. It's a really cute place in a really convenient location. It has a nice kitchen and a two car garage. It looks really really spacious (and actually does have a pretty large square footage - 1380), and there's lots of storage space. Though some of the things I love the most about are things I would love about any house. I love being able to keep our stuff in common space without fear of it getting stolen. I love having nice things and not worrying about them getting destroyed by drunk Stebbinites. I love living in a house where I know I get along with everybody. A couple people warned me that a couple living in a house with one other person would result in a lot of third wheeling and awkwardness, but it hasn't happened yet. I think Susan and Steven and I are all getting along great. I really like our dynamic. It's going to be a really fun year I think. :)
One of the things facilitating the fun is all of our common interests. We're all a bunch of nerds. We've got Star Trek dvds on the table, Magic cards in the corner, more video game consoles than I could carry, and a handful of nerdy board games (which we actually have enough players around to play on a regular basis!). I love being immersed in all the nerdiness. Living in Stebbins, and in Berkeley in general, nerdiness is more a point of pride than one of shame, but there are people who do look down on nerdy things. It's a real downer when you come across one of those. They're generally people who have believed what others have told them without investigating for themselves. For instance, most people who dislike video games haven't actually played much of them. I don't mind them having their own opinions, but it seems like more often than not, people who dislike video games will look down on those who do. I don't look down on people who like to boat, even though it holds no interest for me. I don't look down on people who fish. I don't look down on people who go to museums. None of these things are my favorite activities. I've never fished, or been on a boat recreationally, and I rarely visit museums (and can often find myself bored when I do go). But that doesn't mean I don't see any worth in it. If it makes someone happy, then go for it. It's not hurting anyone; it's just how you choose to spend your free time. So don't be so judgmental about how I spend mine.
But realistically, everyone agrees with the statement I just made. No one thinks they're judgmental, or if they do end up judging something, they just say that that something merits it. And I think a lot of people aren't really aware that they look down on video games. They really don't think about it that often. I had difficulty coming up with examples of things I don't think about often just a moment ago. It's hard to think about something that you don't consider much. It's just that when video games do present themselves, when people do come across someone with a controller in their hands, it's like a knee jerk reaction to react negatively. I remember whenever Sabira entered a room with people playing video games, she would always leave as soon as she could because she claimed that video games were antisocial. If the type of social they keep away is Sabira's company, I don't think I mind too much. As it is, I feel very social when playing video games most of the time. Even one player games are fun to watch.
I don't know why I'm defending video games or even complaining about the disrespect they receive. It's not like it's going to change matters. I won't change anyone's opinions, but I will admit it is something of a sore spot for me. It makes it easy to rant and ramble whenever I think about it.
But back to some of the main things I was talking about. I feel like I've gone over the new house a little. Sure, there's more to tell, but perhaps now it's time to move on to a different topic, another one that was covered briefly in my introduction paragraph. Math 104 was a very difficult class for me. Everyone always said it was going to be crazy hard, and I believed them, but sometimes you have to experience something yourself to really understand it. There was some pretty crazy stuff there near the end. But the thing is, I felt like I could have understood all of it given more time. Taking this class over the summer was really hard. It's not like I had any choice in the matter, but nonetheless, I wish I had been able to take it in the fall or spring. Part of me is just glad to have it done, but I feel like I would have learned it a lot better if I had been able to go at a slower pace. I just don't feel like I got much out of this course. I felt like I was cramming the whole time. Trying to squeeze all that complicated information into my head at once makes me feel like none of it is going to stick. Even now, one day later, I don't feel like I can remember all of the little details I knew a day ago. I feel like I took this class for a reason, not just to have taken it, but given how much I took from the class, I don't know that I achieved its purpose. I was supposed to gain some insight into calculus, and maybe I did. But I really don't feel like a lot more enlightened now than I was at the beginning of summer. After taking abstract algebra and linear algebra last summer, I really felt like I knew a lot about algebra and numbers in general leaving those classes. I really learned a lot. For this class, I crammed a lot. I showed good test taking skills. But do I have some intuitive grasp on calculus? Not really. I guess I do understand some concepts better this time around than I did the first time I learned them in high school (and I learned them pretty well in high school), and I guess that will be useful (it's always important for the teacher to know a little more than she has to teach), but I worked really hard and I just don't feel like I got the same payout. It's a little embittering, especially considering all the painful stuff I had to go through. To give an idea of how crazy tough our final was, about three fourths of the way through, the guy next to me started to cry. I felt really awful. I couldn't focus on him that much because I had a test of my own to take, but I remember rooting for him silently for a second or two. "Just keep it together for another half hour! You're almost there!" There's nothing like feeling miserable to ensure that you really bomb a test though. You get into this spiral of unproductivity. You just think a lot slower when you're fighting off tears, and you know that you're moving slower and that makes you even more frustrated and makes you want to cry more. I've never broken down like that during a test, but I've had my breakdowns before. I know how he felt and I felt really bad for him. Our teacher admitted at the end that it was an exceptionally hard final and he felt bad about a few of the questions, but I could tell he didn't feel too bad about it. He always said the whole time, "It all comes out in the wash," meaning everyone else had to go through it too, so comparatively, you don't look so bad. But why make everyone go through such hardship? I know you want to differentiate the students and you don't want to give two people who differ by only a few points two different grades. You also don't want to dock someone who worked hard for making a stupid mistake if they know the concepts. But is a crazy hard test really the way to do that? I don't know if I can feel positively about something that creates that much misery. Also, how do you the sheer impossibility of a test won't just discourage someone who knows the material? I've known people who seem like they know what's going on turn around and bomb a test. One of my better students last semester did much worse than her peers who weren't as smart and didn't work as hard. Some of that might just be test anxiety (it's hard to compare a middle school student to college students in an upper div math class), but I think it just shows another example that tests are not always the most accurate measure of skill. The guy next to me seemed like he had his shit together the whole class. He was probably crying because he thought he wouldn't be above the mean, not because he thought he would fail. But what if he had thought that other people would find the test equally hard instead of thinking about how he didn't get it? Thinking one of those two thoughts over the other isn't exactly indicative of mathematical skill. But the person who thought other people were struggling too would have done better on that test than someone who started to despair, even if they had the same mathematical skills. More than once during that test I looked at a question and thought "Ummm... well this isn't happening," but at the same time I also thought that it wasn't happening for a lot of other people either. And so I just kept flipping pages until I found a problem that was happening. I've yet to see how I did. I could believe anything from a little below the mean to an SD above. I really didn't know what was going on, and there's no way to judge how it went for other people. I guess I'll find out in the next couple days when the grades get posted. Whatever my grade is, even if it's an A, I'm a little dissatisfied. I don't think I, or anyone else in the calss, learned the material that well. We certainly didn't learn it well enough to have any sort of hope on that final. And I know you're not supposed to do well on upper division math finals, but it really is disheartening to be so thoroughly trounced and feel like you didn't really learn a lot. I'm not as down about the whole thing as I'm coming off, but I do feel like it wasn't the most valuable use of my time. It is a little disappointing to work hard and suffer for not much payout. I did work hard. I did suffer. And what have I got to show for it?
Sorry to end on a bit of a low note, but that all for this blog entry. I've got a few more topics in mind for blog entries though that should be a little cheerier. To give a little spoiler of things to come, they will be titled "Comic-con is super amazing fantastic!" and "Pruning". The first one sounds more exciting than the second, but I'm a little more personally interested in the second one. It's not quite what it sounds like. Ok. That's enough of a teaser for now. More to come in a little while (not so long a dry spell as last time, in other words)!
Thursday, July 17, 2008
Who to Teach?
When I first got interested in teaching, one of the reasons I wanted to do it is because a lot of people don't see how math is relevant to their lives, and I think that makes their lives a lot worse. People who can use math fluently can adapt to their surroundings better, can manipulate their environment, are less likely to get cheated by deals they don't understand, etc. I really think it not only makes your life better, but it makes your life better by a huge amount.
Now there's a lot of people who don't see how math is relevant, but they're still good at it. They probably won't ever credit math with their successes in life, but I honestly don't worry about them that much. They'll be able to figure things out when they need to. But there are a lot of people who really can't handle math related things. There are people who fundamentally don't understand credit cards and end up poor the rest of their life because of it. There are people who get suckered in to signing up for premium packages even though they utilize about a tenth of the resources. There are people who think they'll be in the top 10% of the nation, when they don't even have a chance, or understand what that means. In fact, most people think they're above average. People who aren't capable of sitting down and reasoning through their situations are at a severe disadvantage. If everything goes well in their life and difficult decisions never come up, then it's not such a big issue. It is feasible that you could get by without math in an ideal situation. However most people will be faced with difficult choices. Do I chose place X for $500 a month, or place Y for $700 a month? Each of those choices has many repercussions on the rest of your life. Do I get a car loan, or do I take the bus? A friend of my mom's bought an SUV a few years ago. She liked the idea of being able to spontaneously go into the mountains. Not my kind of thing really, since I'm so indoorsy, but I can see that being a nice thing to have. So we know the benefits. What are the costs? And how do you best compare them to weigh your options? Do you compare the money spent on renting a car vs paying off one you own? How about factoring in flexibility (you have to pay for the car you own- you don't have to rent a car if you can't afford it)? And how do you account for environmental concerns? And even if those aren't important to you, what about other lasting factors? How will your credit score be affected if you're pushing yourself to pay for a car? What if you, like my mom's friend, pay only the minimum balance on the car every month? My mom's friend didn't even realize she had bad credit until she applied for a loan to buy a house. That must have hurt to find out that paying the minimum balance every month was making it harder and harder to own a home. She thought she was paying what she owed and so should have great credit. She didn't realize that she was never touching the principle and that when applying to get a loan, it appeared that she already had a large debt.
Are all of these concerns math related? Not directly. Some of it is just misinformation leading to misfortune. But what caused that level of misinformation? When you sign a contract for a credit card, all the rules are spread out and described. Of course, if you can't understand percentages or compound interest, it might not mean much to you. If your grasp over mathematics is so poor that you can't understand contracts that you sign yourself into, then maybe you'll have trouble figuring out how to work within the system. Maybe you'll have a harder time calculating the costs and benefits of something you wish to purchase. Maybe you won't save up the money you need for retirement and will have to keep working until eventually your company fires your for being unfit to work and you've destroyed your health just trying to make ends meet. Most people do not have enough money for retirement. Would it have been any different if they had sat down and calculated their earnings at an earlier stage of life? Would they have still decided to buy the fancier car or the larger house or get the hundreds of DVDs for their collection? Why do people buy things that they cannot afford? Is it because they don't see the consequences? Or is it because they don't understand them? It is a difficult mathematical calculation to even decide what it is that you can and cannot afford. It takes further understanding to realize what the repercussions are for going over the limit, or even for not going positive enough. I want to help people use math so their lives are better. Even if people don't see these as mathematical calculations, if someone is good at math, they'll be able to figure things out on their own. It grants them a certain independence and makes me confident that they'll go on to do fine. It's the students who struggle with even simple computations who worry me. What decisions will they make when the stakes are higher? Where instead of getting grades, they get debt? I worry for them a lot. And that why I want to teach. I figure that's the best way to help these people and the best way to target ignorance.
However certain signs indicate to me that that might not be the path I take when teaching. Several people in my program have commented to me that I would really excel at teaching the higher level calculus classes, especially when I comment about having difficulties with my lower achieving class. I keep thinking to myself, "But those kids are fine! They'll get by just fine without me. They'll go to college and make some realizations and maybe they'll get burned at times, but they'll learn from it and figure out a way to come back." It's the other kids who I worry might not bounce back so easily. I want to help them so that they won't be at such a disadvantage. But I don't know sometimes. Was I really a help to my last class? I don't really think so. It's true that I don't know where they would have been without me, but I have to say I wasn't happy with where they ended up. Most of them quit trying, or were unhappy about trying when everyone else just copied from them. I didn't get across any of the idea that were really important to me, some of the ideas that took several paragraphs up above. But I've been thinking about it recently- those ideas aren't simple. It's true that the struggling students don't understand a lot of what I just wrote about, but I'm not so sure the advanced students do either. None of them have credit cards- why should they understand credit debt? But they might be in a better position to understand some of those things. I just assumed that they'd figure it out as they went though life, but who's to say that they would? I know a lot of bright people who got turned off to math and then never touched it again. Will I be able to do more good helping remedial kids (against nearly overwhelming odds, I might add), or helping the already gifted who have a better chance of actually showing some improvement because of me? Is this a case of helping the wealthy (in knowledge) get wealthier? Will I really enact any change this way? I would like to help the most needy, but of course, those are the hardest to help. I don't know what to do.
Truthfully, I'm just going to have to try different things and see what feels most rewarding to me. It's not like I have to choose one or the other. I think I can try both, even at the same time. It's just hard for me to consider changing my original reason for getting into teaching, to shift my target group from the students of early math to the students who have already mastered (or gotten past at least) the basics. It's a tough decision and even after writing for a while, I don't feel like I have any answers.
Now there's a lot of people who don't see how math is relevant, but they're still good at it. They probably won't ever credit math with their successes in life, but I honestly don't worry about them that much. They'll be able to figure things out when they need to. But there are a lot of people who really can't handle math related things. There are people who fundamentally don't understand credit cards and end up poor the rest of their life because of it. There are people who get suckered in to signing up for premium packages even though they utilize about a tenth of the resources. There are people who think they'll be in the top 10% of the nation, when they don't even have a chance, or understand what that means. In fact, most people think they're above average. People who aren't capable of sitting down and reasoning through their situations are at a severe disadvantage. If everything goes well in their life and difficult decisions never come up, then it's not such a big issue. It is feasible that you could get by without math in an ideal situation. However most people will be faced with difficult choices. Do I chose place X for $500 a month, or place Y for $700 a month? Each of those choices has many repercussions on the rest of your life. Do I get a car loan, or do I take the bus? A friend of my mom's bought an SUV a few years ago. She liked the idea of being able to spontaneously go into the mountains. Not my kind of thing really, since I'm so indoorsy, but I can see that being a nice thing to have. So we know the benefits. What are the costs? And how do you best compare them to weigh your options? Do you compare the money spent on renting a car vs paying off one you own? How about factoring in flexibility (you have to pay for the car you own- you don't have to rent a car if you can't afford it)? And how do you account for environmental concerns? And even if those aren't important to you, what about other lasting factors? How will your credit score be affected if you're pushing yourself to pay for a car? What if you, like my mom's friend, pay only the minimum balance on the car every month? My mom's friend didn't even realize she had bad credit until she applied for a loan to buy a house. That must have hurt to find out that paying the minimum balance every month was making it harder and harder to own a home. She thought she was paying what she owed and so should have great credit. She didn't realize that she was never touching the principle and that when applying to get a loan, it appeared that she already had a large debt.
Are all of these concerns math related? Not directly. Some of it is just misinformation leading to misfortune. But what caused that level of misinformation? When you sign a contract for a credit card, all the rules are spread out and described. Of course, if you can't understand percentages or compound interest, it might not mean much to you. If your grasp over mathematics is so poor that you can't understand contracts that you sign yourself into, then maybe you'll have trouble figuring out how to work within the system. Maybe you'll have a harder time calculating the costs and benefits of something you wish to purchase. Maybe you won't save up the money you need for retirement and will have to keep working until eventually your company fires your for being unfit to work and you've destroyed your health just trying to make ends meet. Most people do not have enough money for retirement. Would it have been any different if they had sat down and calculated their earnings at an earlier stage of life? Would they have still decided to buy the fancier car or the larger house or get the hundreds of DVDs for their collection? Why do people buy things that they cannot afford? Is it because they don't see the consequences? Or is it because they don't understand them? It is a difficult mathematical calculation to even decide what it is that you can and cannot afford. It takes further understanding to realize what the repercussions are for going over the limit, or even for not going positive enough. I want to help people use math so their lives are better. Even if people don't see these as mathematical calculations, if someone is good at math, they'll be able to figure things out on their own. It grants them a certain independence and makes me confident that they'll go on to do fine. It's the students who struggle with even simple computations who worry me. What decisions will they make when the stakes are higher? Where instead of getting grades, they get debt? I worry for them a lot. And that why I want to teach. I figure that's the best way to help these people and the best way to target ignorance.
However certain signs indicate to me that that might not be the path I take when teaching. Several people in my program have commented to me that I would really excel at teaching the higher level calculus classes, especially when I comment about having difficulties with my lower achieving class. I keep thinking to myself, "But those kids are fine! They'll get by just fine without me. They'll go to college and make some realizations and maybe they'll get burned at times, but they'll learn from it and figure out a way to come back." It's the other kids who I worry might not bounce back so easily. I want to help them so that they won't be at such a disadvantage. But I don't know sometimes. Was I really a help to my last class? I don't really think so. It's true that I don't know where they would have been without me, but I have to say I wasn't happy with where they ended up. Most of them quit trying, or were unhappy about trying when everyone else just copied from them. I didn't get across any of the idea that were really important to me, some of the ideas that took several paragraphs up above. But I've been thinking about it recently- those ideas aren't simple. It's true that the struggling students don't understand a lot of what I just wrote about, but I'm not so sure the advanced students do either. None of them have credit cards- why should they understand credit debt? But they might be in a better position to understand some of those things. I just assumed that they'd figure it out as they went though life, but who's to say that they would? I know a lot of bright people who got turned off to math and then never touched it again. Will I be able to do more good helping remedial kids (against nearly overwhelming odds, I might add), or helping the already gifted who have a better chance of actually showing some improvement because of me? Is this a case of helping the wealthy (in knowledge) get wealthier? Will I really enact any change this way? I would like to help the most needy, but of course, those are the hardest to help. I don't know what to do.
Truthfully, I'm just going to have to try different things and see what feels most rewarding to me. It's not like I have to choose one or the other. I think I can try both, even at the same time. It's just hard for me to consider changing my original reason for getting into teaching, to shift my target group from the students of early math to the students who have already mastered (or gotten past at least) the basics. It's a tough decision and even after writing for a while, I don't feel like I have any answers.
Monday, July 14, 2008
Indoor Skydiving
Doesn't sound like a good idea, does it? Well it is! It's also not quite what it sounds like. It approximates skydiving in that it's quite windy, but it doesn't really involve the sky at all. Or diving for that matter. Really it's all false advertisement except for the indoor part.
To put it simply, there's an enormous fan blowing air straight up into a small wind tunnel. The force of the wind is actually enough to suspend you in the air. It's supposed to feel pretty similar to skydiving. I wouldn't know since I've never skydived, but I can say that indoor skydiving is a blast! I went last weekend and it was really fun. It was very short and very pricey ($55 for 2 minutes!), but Steven and I had been wanting to try it for a while, and in a bad economy like this one, I fear things like indoor skydiving might have some difficulty surviving. Silly me though. The place was packed! And the receptionists were on the phone constantly taking reservations for future appointments. Crazy.
So we shelled out the bucks and got to fly around in the wind tunnel for a little while. There was an instructor with us and once we started getting the hang of the tunnel, he started spinning us around in the air. It was pretty cool. One word of caution though: the wind blows so hard that it was a little hard for me to breathe through my nose. What option did that leave? Breathing through my mouth, which of course meant keeping my mouth open. Which, as it turns out, meant getting my saliva blown onto my face where it pretty much instantly dried. Not a problem if you have nice breath. But let's just say my experience inspired me to eat some mints.
It was a lot of money for a short time, but I have to say I'm tempted to go back. The second time is cheaper and you're able to control your own movements more (instead of having the instructor position you). If you get good enough, you eventually move up to the really high speed winds and can do barrel rolls and other really crazy flips. I think the second visit is $40 and it gets even cheaper from there, but that's still a lot, especially considering how little time you're actually in there.
Perhaps one day I'll go back, but for now I'll just call it another interesting experience under my belt and move on. I do have one extra special memory from it though: after we were done, Steven told me that I looked so cute in the wind tunnel with my little wind blown smile (getting spit on my face and not really caring) that he fell in love with me all over again. He's a real romantic that one. I told him as much, and he just said that he says what he's feeling. And that's why he's such a romantic. He's the best.
To put it simply, there's an enormous fan blowing air straight up into a small wind tunnel. The force of the wind is actually enough to suspend you in the air. It's supposed to feel pretty similar to skydiving. I wouldn't know since I've never skydived, but I can say that indoor skydiving is a blast! I went last weekend and it was really fun. It was very short and very pricey ($55 for 2 minutes!), but Steven and I had been wanting to try it for a while, and in a bad economy like this one, I fear things like indoor skydiving might have some difficulty surviving. Silly me though. The place was packed! And the receptionists were on the phone constantly taking reservations for future appointments. Crazy.
So we shelled out the bucks and got to fly around in the wind tunnel for a little while. There was an instructor with us and once we started getting the hang of the tunnel, he started spinning us around in the air. It was pretty cool. One word of caution though: the wind blows so hard that it was a little hard for me to breathe through my nose. What option did that leave? Breathing through my mouth, which of course meant keeping my mouth open. Which, as it turns out, meant getting my saliva blown onto my face where it pretty much instantly dried. Not a problem if you have nice breath. But let's just say my experience inspired me to eat some mints.
It was a lot of money for a short time, but I have to say I'm tempted to go back. The second time is cheaper and you're able to control your own movements more (instead of having the instructor position you). If you get good enough, you eventually move up to the really high speed winds and can do barrel rolls and other really crazy flips. I think the second visit is $40 and it gets even cheaper from there, but that's still a lot, especially considering how little time you're actually in there.
Perhaps one day I'll go back, but for now I'll just call it another interesting experience under my belt and move on. I do have one extra special memory from it though: after we were done, Steven told me that I looked so cute in the wind tunnel with my little wind blown smile (getting spit on my face and not really caring) that he fell in love with me all over again. He's a real romantic that one. I told him as much, and he just said that he says what he's feeling. And that's why he's such a romantic. He's the best.
Monday, June 30, 2008
I hate driving
Seriously, how can people think it's fun? I know some people who think driving is relaxing and enjoyable. They like to go for a drive as if it were relaxing or something. I drive because I have to. It's something that's gotta be done. I have to get where I want to go and sometimes the only way to do that is via car. But I certainly don't think it's something fun to do and I would never do it unless I had to get somewhere.
Whenever I see someone who likes to drive, I think to myself, "Do you also like to sit still for long periods of time? And while you're sitting still you have to be paying constant attention? Oh and don't forget that you have about a million rules to be keeping in mind at once. And of course, if you fail to adhere to those rules and if you fail to pay attention and focus properly, you could die." I see driving as the most physical control that I have to have over my body at any point during the day. And if I don't have total control, there could be terrible consequences. If I even do something as minor as turning my steering wheel 15 degrees to the left while on the freeway, I'm likely to die. Even if I do nothing, I'm likely to die. All the road has to do is turn a little without me turning with it and I will crash into the median or, even worse, another car. How can you relax when there's always something to do? And not doing that something could be the last thing you don't do.
But that's not even the worst of it. You could be perfectly aware and alert, obeying the rules of the road, not fidgeting even when you really want to, and it still wouldn't be enough. One careless driver in the lane next to you is all it takes for you to die. Sure they'll be at fault, but that won't matter to you much when you're dead. So not only do you have to perfect, you have to trust every other person on the road to also be perfect, and honestly, I don't trust random people that much, especially not with my life.
I never particularly liked driving, but I didn't dislike it this much before my accident. I wonder how many people who enjoy driving have been in a huge car accident. My guess is very few. Most people don't realize the seriousness of driving. I certainly didn't. You don't really understand the forces at work until you feel them on your body. There's something incredibly sickening about feeling your body go from 65 mph to 0 in an instant. Imagine running as fast as you can and then tripping. Imagine how much it sucks to face plant right in the dirt. You probably weren't running more than 10 mph. And you didn't drop to 0 immediately. You probably skidded a bit. It might rip up your skin, but you wouldn't really feel it in your gut. When you're in a car and you stop suddenly (no skidding, no nothing), you still have momentum. Even if the car has a good safety rating and airbags deploy to keep you in one place, there's still a massive amount of force pushing you forward. I felt my insides surging forward because my body couldn't.
There's no real way to describe that feeling of incredible force working on your body. You don't feel it when you're driving regularly. It feels like you might as well be sitting at a table at home. The only difference is that the scenery outside your window is changing. But that force is there. It's an amazing marvel that we can harness such forces. By burning a little gasoline, we can propel our bodies through space at an alarming rate. And perhaps even more marvelous, this feat is commonplace, so commonplace that people don't think twice about it. To be honest, people usually don't think once about it.
And that's why I hate driving. Yes, it's necessary, and yes, I'll continue to do it when I have to, but I'm never going to stop hating it. And I'm never going to stop being scared when I have to do it. Just yesterday the thought occurred to me, "I'm not going to get over this, am I?" I figured it would fade and I'd become complacent once again. I wished that I would. But I can see that I'm not going to. That's something I just have to accept. There are people all over the world who must live with their fears. And, at least when I'm driving, I am one of them.
Whenever I see someone who likes to drive, I think to myself, "Do you also like to sit still for long periods of time? And while you're sitting still you have to be paying constant attention? Oh and don't forget that you have about a million rules to be keeping in mind at once. And of course, if you fail to adhere to those rules and if you fail to pay attention and focus properly, you could die." I see driving as the most physical control that I have to have over my body at any point during the day. And if I don't have total control, there could be terrible consequences. If I even do something as minor as turning my steering wheel 15 degrees to the left while on the freeway, I'm likely to die. Even if I do nothing, I'm likely to die. All the road has to do is turn a little without me turning with it and I will crash into the median or, even worse, another car. How can you relax when there's always something to do? And not doing that something could be the last thing you don't do.
But that's not even the worst of it. You could be perfectly aware and alert, obeying the rules of the road, not fidgeting even when you really want to, and it still wouldn't be enough. One careless driver in the lane next to you is all it takes for you to die. Sure they'll be at fault, but that won't matter to you much when you're dead. So not only do you have to perfect, you have to trust every other person on the road to also be perfect, and honestly, I don't trust random people that much, especially not with my life.
I never particularly liked driving, but I didn't dislike it this much before my accident. I wonder how many people who enjoy driving have been in a huge car accident. My guess is very few. Most people don't realize the seriousness of driving. I certainly didn't. You don't really understand the forces at work until you feel them on your body. There's something incredibly sickening about feeling your body go from 65 mph to 0 in an instant. Imagine running as fast as you can and then tripping. Imagine how much it sucks to face plant right in the dirt. You probably weren't running more than 10 mph. And you didn't drop to 0 immediately. You probably skidded a bit. It might rip up your skin, but you wouldn't really feel it in your gut. When you're in a car and you stop suddenly (no skidding, no nothing), you still have momentum. Even if the car has a good safety rating and airbags deploy to keep you in one place, there's still a massive amount of force pushing you forward. I felt my insides surging forward because my body couldn't.
There's no real way to describe that feeling of incredible force working on your body. You don't feel it when you're driving regularly. It feels like you might as well be sitting at a table at home. The only difference is that the scenery outside your window is changing. But that force is there. It's an amazing marvel that we can harness such forces. By burning a little gasoline, we can propel our bodies through space at an alarming rate. And perhaps even more marvelous, this feat is commonplace, so commonplace that people don't think twice about it. To be honest, people usually don't think once about it.
And that's why I hate driving. Yes, it's necessary, and yes, I'll continue to do it when I have to, but I'm never going to stop hating it. And I'm never going to stop being scared when I have to do it. Just yesterday the thought occurred to me, "I'm not going to get over this, am I?" I figured it would fade and I'd become complacent once again. I wished that I would. But I can see that I'm not going to. That's something I just have to accept. There are people all over the world who must live with their fears. And, at least when I'm driving, I am one of them.
Friday, June 20, 2008
More cutesy, nerdy stuff involving Steven
So I said something (I forget what) and Steven replied:
Steven: I was just thinking that!
Me: Yeah we think alike a lot. It's uncanny. Like the X-Men.
Steven: Actually, I think it's incredible.
Me: Like the Hulk.
Steven: Also fantastic.
Me: Like the four.
Teehee!
Steven: I was just thinking that!
Me: Yeah we think alike a lot. It's uncanny. Like the X-Men.
Steven: Actually, I think it's incredible.
Me: Like the Hulk.
Steven: Also fantastic.
Me: Like the four.
Teehee!
Saturday, June 14, 2008
Butting heads
I am a scrappy little thing. Well, sometimes I am. For whatever reason, I can't seem to help myself when I'm around Sabira. I get extra aggressive and mean. Actually, I think I might know the reason. Sabira is workshift manager now and she has a very particular way of doing things and her very particular way is very different from my own. During summer, she decided that she was not going to pro rate weeks. In other words, even if someone was only here for one day during the week, they would still owe hours as if they were there for the whole week, so they would owe all three hours. It's pretty unlikely that they'd even be able to do three hours in one day like that. It means people going out of town would be guaranteed to go down hours. Sabira claimed that she wasn't willing to pro rate weeks because it was too much work, but I know that it's not that hard. In fact, it's really easy. You go to a specific page and turn the 3 into a 0, 1, or 2. It's as simple as that and takes about a minute from the time you read the email to the time the change is made. I thought her policy was absolute bull shit and had no idea why she was being such a ridiculous hardass, but I didn't want to be mean and bring a motion to overturn her or tread on her toes. But I still thought it was a ridiculous policy and wanted her to change it. I thought the best policy would be to just talk to her in person and see if I could reason her out of it, especially since her reasons for doing it didn't make sense. I was sitting with her and said I wanted to talk to her about workshift. I said, "So about pro rating..." and she immediately cut me off with a no before I had even finished the sentence. Ok. I think you're a bitch, but I'm going to plow on. "I know it's your policy not to pro rate, but I don't think it makes a lot of sense. I mean, if someone's here for just one day, they're not going to be able to do three hours. It's like going out of town for less than a week means that you're guaranteed to go down hours." She said no one else had approached her and said it was a problem, so she didn't think it was. I said that I knew of at least one other person (since he said at the first meeting, "wait why are you doing that?" when she first mentioned her policy), and there were probably others as well. She said she'd think about it. A short while later, she came up to my room and suggested a policy of owing one hour for every day a person was there. So if someone was here for three days, it would be the same as if they were there for 7. I said I thought that was fair and that it was pretty much exactly the same policy I had when I was workshift manager, so I certainly wasn't going to have any problems with it. I could tell as soon as I said it that that was a bad thing to say because she immediately told me that mine was a lot different because people owed one hour a day up to five hours with my plan, so being here 5 days was the same as being around all 7. She really wanted to do something different and saying she was similar to me was a mistake for her ego. Whatever. I agreed limply (thinking to myself that she was being ridiculous) because I just wanted her to go through with it. Then it could have been her idea and I wouldn't have been usurping her power by suggesting it at a meeting. She said she'd think about it and she left.
I was really hoping for more than an "I'll think about it." Honestly, this was going to happen whether she wanted it or not and I wanted to know if I should bring a motion. I don't think my mind was set on bringing the motion before I spoke with her though. I mean, her proposal that I said was fine would have meant that I never would have gotten my hours reduced (I'll probably be in Stebbins four days a week for most of the summer), but that was actually the proposal I was going to suggest to her. I was thrilled when she proposed it because I knew she'd be much more likely to accept it if she came up with it herself. I didn't really care about getting my hours reduced. I just thought she was being too much of a hardass. Then after speaking with her (and becoming subsequently annoyed), I wanted it to happen more. I could see that she realized it was at least a little reasonable and thought she could be convinced, so I wanted to run with it.
Then I saw Sabira post the new policy on the workshift board with a note saying it would be discussed at the next meeting. This made me pretty hopeful. It would be discussed and the house would be overwhelmingly in favor of it (since the current plan was ridiculous) and I wouldn't feel bad about overthrowing her power, and Sabira wouldn't lose any face if it passed because she'd be the one bringing up the discussion and she'd look better by starting out strict and then easing up a little. Because honestly, owing hours for the whole week when you're here only 3 days is pretty strict, but the house would have accepted it (giving it legitimacy and ensuring it was never challenged again) if she had presented it as a more lenient and flexible policy. Their reference points were in this very strict place and they wouldn't have questioned a less strict place even if it was still unfair, especially the new people.
So as long as Sabira started a discussion at the house meeting and proposed her new idea, everyone would have been happy. Unfortunately, she did not. She brought it up and said that someone had mentioned it to her and if anyone else felt the same, they should email her. And that was it. That was her discussion. She started moving on, and I had to interrupt her. I asked why we couldn't just discuss it now with everyone here. Sigh. The usurping had begun. I didn't want to, but that was sketchy. She knew people wouldn't remember to email her. Maybe one or two people would. And she would have told them they'd discuss it at the next meeting probably, unless the response was huge, which it would not have been. No one's going to remember a glossed over point that was rushed through followed by 45 minutes of talking about other stuff. It was pretty clear she didn't want other people's opinions. I don't really blame her. It's the workshift manager's job to try to get more hours for the house and I think she knew the house wouldn't go along with her original plan if they thought they had a choice. Her best bet was to make it harder for people to give input and then claim that it must not have been important to the house so she shouldn't act. That is certainly frustrating and I couldn't let it go. I felt a little like a jerk for having to be the one to propose the discussion. That meant it was going to be a battle between Sabira and the house instead of a discussion (and a battle that she would lose at that), but I think Jesse would have spoken up if I hadn't. I think that since as soon as Sabira said "Sure" uncertainly to my proposal of a discussion, Jesse agreed and proposed everyone owing a half hour for every day they were here. Ouch. It sure hurt her cause that she wasn't able to propose her stricter policy first. Sabira tried to recover by saying she wasn't willing to do that (she gets points for being being extra adamant) and then proposed "her" idea of an hour a day, but I think people's reference points had changed. Though I think Jesse was going to propose his idea whether she went first or not, and people would have gone along with that over her proposal. She was probably doomed from the start. If she had gone with the flow instead of fighting against it, she might have been able to change its course a little, but that's not the position she wanted to take.
So Sabira was strongly against Jesse's idea of a half hour a day and gave some pretty pathetic reasons for why that was the case. She said that there were very few half hour or hour and a half shifts over the summer so people would be left with an extra half hour. I couldn't let a ridiculous argument like that slide. It made no sense. I said so what if someone ends the semester up a half hour? If they're down a half hour, they can just do an hour and be up a little. It's not a big deal. She said, but we're not talking about the end of the semester - this would be every week! Ummm... I'll admit that I don't respect Sabira all that much, but now I have to add stupid to the list of adjectives. Ok maybe that's a little harsh, but her argument didn't make any sense. In fact, her whole understanding of the workshift system seemed kind of flawed. Though admittedly, she hasn't been using it for that long so it makes sense she's not that familiar with it. I didn't really get a chance to retort (probably for the best since I'm not sure I could have been nice about it) because Jesse said that they could just do a half hour a day rounded up to the nearest hour. The house became very confused by this statement and we spent the next few minutes clearing it up (omg I hate people). So one hour for one or two days; 2 hours for 3 or 4 days; and 3 hours for 5 or more days. Sabira stated again that she was not willing to do that and she absolutely would not. I got a little frustrated by this dictatorial attitude. It's not really her choice. It's the house's decision. It's like her saying she's not willing to do her job or listen to her constituents. I said it was the house's decision and she said we'd need a 3/4 vote to overturn any of the workshift manager's decisions. Sigh. This was one of the things I was afraid of with Sabira in a manager position. She's kind of a power hog who wants to push her weight around and sound tough. She wants things to be her decision because she knows best. She's one of those "I know best" personalities that are frustrating to deal with in your peers, but horrific to deal with in a superior or person in any position of power. As a workshift manager, I never threatened people with that 3/4 rule. I think anyone who does doesn't really deserve to be a manager. You should listen to what the house wants. They elected you. You're not there to boss them around or be mean to them. You're there to make sure the house runs smoothly. You stop people from making decisions that would benefit them at the expense of the whole house. You keep people's information up to date and try to get things running smoothly. You are the servant of the house, not it's boss. That's what it means to be a manager. Sabira didn't get that. She wanted to be the house's boss and tell us what she was willing to let us decide. At this point I was feeling less bad about usurping her and didn't feel at all guilty about bursting her bubble. She clearly had not read the bylaws because the workshift manager can be overturned by a simple majority vote in almost all situations. Here's a passage from our bylaws:
A workshift manager's allocation of hours to a particular workshift may only be overturned by a 3/4 vote by the house. This provision only applies to a workshift manager's determination of how many hours a workshift shall be worth. In the case of a dispute with a member over how long a workshift actually took to complete, or other such issues, the house shall retain its power to overturn the workshift manager's actions by majority vote.
So if Sabira says a shift is worth 1 hour and someone else says it should be worth 4, it would take 3/4 of the house to overturn her. In this situation, that was not the case. It's one thing to throw your weight around. It's quite another thing to throw your weight around when you don't have the authority to back it up. I will never understand why people will quote the bylaws without actually having read them. They're not that long really. And the parts that pertain to your specific job are definitely not that long. It's easy to gloss over room bids and things like that. And when people misquote the bylaws, they look extra stupid. I think it's that quoting the bylaws is an extremely persuasive argument (you can't really argue with that and it gives you a lot of authority), but the idea of reading 14 pages of "the managers shall do this" and "it is the responsibility of the workshift manager to do that" can be daunting to people. So they don't bother to actually read it, but when they start to feel cornered, they start to quote it and hope their bull shit can slide. And maybe Sabira didn't even realize that it was bull shit. She had heard that 3/4 rule before. It is easily the most misquoted rule in all the bylaws. A lot of people think it applies to every decision the workshift manager makes instead of the extremely limited situations it actually applies to. And this is another reason that it's bad to mention the 3/4 rule - you are way too likely to get overturn and look like an ass.
So to make a long story less long, when we voted on Jesse's revised proposal, Sabira was the only one to vote against it (though there were a handful of abstentions). In fact, I think 3/4 of the house might have actually overturned her, not that it matter. Then a lengthy discussion of whether or not to apply it retroactively came up and was narrowly voted down. I spearheaded that discussion. I wanted my old hours back since this was the policy now. I'm tired of being down hours when I shouldn't be. I probably made a lifelong enemy of Sabira by fighting for that. Whatever. As long as I mind my p's and q's, there's nothing she can do about it. And that's not really the way her mind works anyway. Anyway, I had already tread on her toes by fighting for the new policy and contradicting her when she said the extra amount of work it would create for her would be unreasonable. And then contradicting her again by clarifying the 3/4 rule. So I might as well go for broke and push even harder.
With Jesse's policy, I'm only going to owe 2 hours a week for most of the summer (summer school is only 4 days a week for me and this policy convinces me that it's not worth it to come back Sunday night). This is better than I expected, so I'm pretty happy about the situation. And honestly, there's nothing Sabira can do about it. There have been some cases in the past when someone was frequently not in the house and wanted to know if they could owe less than 5 hours a week. I think I would have been ok with it, but that's against the USCA bylaws, so I had to say no. If I only owe 2 hours all summer long and she argues with me about it, I have the leverage to overturn her. Because in summer, the minimum number of hours someone can owe weekly is not 3; it's 2. Stebbins is actually more strict with its hour requirements over summer. And if the house knew that, they might overturn that as well. And Sabira does not want that. Not that I think she's really going to give me trouble. I'm just prepared if she does.
I was wondering a little why I'm so mean to Sabira, but after writing this, I think I've changed my mind. She's a power hungry idiot. She strikes me as one of those people who was really awkward as a kid and didn't really have any friends. She could have been one of those kids that everyone picked on. When I look at her, I see someone who doesn't really get it. She could have easily changed the course of that conversation. She could have set the tone. It didn't even need to be a discussion. If she had just proposed a vote over her policy, it's possible that no one would have spoken up (I wouldn't have) with another policy before the vote was over. And then if someone spoke up, she could just say, well we just voted, so I think the house is ok with this. Then she could have said "let's talk after the meeting" or something else to defer discussion and it would have all gone away. I know Jesse wouldn't have followed through and talked with her after the meeting. He even said partway through the discussion "I don't know why I'm even fighting for this. I'm here all the time. It doesn't apply to me." He just thought her original policy was unfair. If she had addressed his concerns herself by offering a counter proposal (even the slightly unfair one of one hour per day), it probably wouldn't have been worth his effort to suggest the half hour a day rate. And if she had been less adamant against it and had not fought kicking and screaming, she might have been able to convince people by sounding rational and offering legitimate reasons why she thought the one hour a day rule made sense. She wants power (she's run for manager positions so many times - she says she needs the money, but it's so much easier to just get a part time job), but she doesn't know how to use it effectively. And now that she's been overturned once, it makes it that much easier for her to be overturned again. And chances are, she won't be able to reverse the pattern since she doesn't really know what she's doing. She could have gotten her way if she just knew how to handle people and meet them half way. Jesse's compromise of rounding up to the nearest hour is not what she wanted at all. Of course everyone else in the room felt like the people on opposite sides had met halfway just because neither one's original proposal was accepted. The made the rounding up policy all the more attractive because it looked like a moderate position. The truth is, it doesn't make much of a difference. Jesse's policy wasn't changed very much. It was still totally unacceptable to Sabira. Well tough shit. I'd feel bad about arguing with her and overturning her, but she was a fool to take such a hard-and-fast position on something she was guaranteed to lose. She tried to avoid the confrontation (asking people to email her) and tried to force the house into submission (bringing up the misquotation of the 3/4 rule), but that's not how you get your way. And if that's the way you think, you probably shouldn't get your way. I think she knew the house didn't like her policy, but she wanted to have it anyway. Oh well. You can't force your views on someone else just because you manage their workshifts. Maybe she'll realize that and maybe she won't. At least she's only workshift manager for the summer.
I was really hoping for more than an "I'll think about it." Honestly, this was going to happen whether she wanted it or not and I wanted to know if I should bring a motion. I don't think my mind was set on bringing the motion before I spoke with her though. I mean, her proposal that I said was fine would have meant that I never would have gotten my hours reduced (I'll probably be in Stebbins four days a week for most of the summer), but that was actually the proposal I was going to suggest to her. I was thrilled when she proposed it because I knew she'd be much more likely to accept it if she came up with it herself. I didn't really care about getting my hours reduced. I just thought she was being too much of a hardass. Then after speaking with her (and becoming subsequently annoyed), I wanted it to happen more. I could see that she realized it was at least a little reasonable and thought she could be convinced, so I wanted to run with it.
Then I saw Sabira post the new policy on the workshift board with a note saying it would be discussed at the next meeting. This made me pretty hopeful. It would be discussed and the house would be overwhelmingly in favor of it (since the current plan was ridiculous) and I wouldn't feel bad about overthrowing her power, and Sabira wouldn't lose any face if it passed because she'd be the one bringing up the discussion and she'd look better by starting out strict and then easing up a little. Because honestly, owing hours for the whole week when you're here only 3 days is pretty strict, but the house would have accepted it (giving it legitimacy and ensuring it was never challenged again) if she had presented it as a more lenient and flexible policy. Their reference points were in this very strict place and they wouldn't have questioned a less strict place even if it was still unfair, especially the new people.
So as long as Sabira started a discussion at the house meeting and proposed her new idea, everyone would have been happy. Unfortunately, she did not. She brought it up and said that someone had mentioned it to her and if anyone else felt the same, they should email her. And that was it. That was her discussion. She started moving on, and I had to interrupt her. I asked why we couldn't just discuss it now with everyone here. Sigh. The usurping had begun. I didn't want to, but that was sketchy. She knew people wouldn't remember to email her. Maybe one or two people would. And she would have told them they'd discuss it at the next meeting probably, unless the response was huge, which it would not have been. No one's going to remember a glossed over point that was rushed through followed by 45 minutes of talking about other stuff. It was pretty clear she didn't want other people's opinions. I don't really blame her. It's the workshift manager's job to try to get more hours for the house and I think she knew the house wouldn't go along with her original plan if they thought they had a choice. Her best bet was to make it harder for people to give input and then claim that it must not have been important to the house so she shouldn't act. That is certainly frustrating and I couldn't let it go. I felt a little like a jerk for having to be the one to propose the discussion. That meant it was going to be a battle between Sabira and the house instead of a discussion (and a battle that she would lose at that), but I think Jesse would have spoken up if I hadn't. I think that since as soon as Sabira said "Sure" uncertainly to my proposal of a discussion, Jesse agreed and proposed everyone owing a half hour for every day they were here. Ouch. It sure hurt her cause that she wasn't able to propose her stricter policy first. Sabira tried to recover by saying she wasn't willing to do that (she gets points for being being extra adamant) and then proposed "her" idea of an hour a day, but I think people's reference points had changed. Though I think Jesse was going to propose his idea whether she went first or not, and people would have gone along with that over her proposal. She was probably doomed from the start. If she had gone with the flow instead of fighting against it, she might have been able to change its course a little, but that's not the position she wanted to take.
So Sabira was strongly against Jesse's idea of a half hour a day and gave some pretty pathetic reasons for why that was the case. She said that there were very few half hour or hour and a half shifts over the summer so people would be left with an extra half hour. I couldn't let a ridiculous argument like that slide. It made no sense. I said so what if someone ends the semester up a half hour? If they're down a half hour, they can just do an hour and be up a little. It's not a big deal. She said, but we're not talking about the end of the semester - this would be every week! Ummm... I'll admit that I don't respect Sabira all that much, but now I have to add stupid to the list of adjectives. Ok maybe that's a little harsh, but her argument didn't make any sense. In fact, her whole understanding of the workshift system seemed kind of flawed. Though admittedly, she hasn't been using it for that long so it makes sense she's not that familiar with it. I didn't really get a chance to retort (probably for the best since I'm not sure I could have been nice about it) because Jesse said that they could just do a half hour a day rounded up to the nearest hour. The house became very confused by this statement and we spent the next few minutes clearing it up (omg I hate people). So one hour for one or two days; 2 hours for 3 or 4 days; and 3 hours for 5 or more days. Sabira stated again that she was not willing to do that and she absolutely would not. I got a little frustrated by this dictatorial attitude. It's not really her choice. It's the house's decision. It's like her saying she's not willing to do her job or listen to her constituents. I said it was the house's decision and she said we'd need a 3/4 vote to overturn any of the workshift manager's decisions. Sigh. This was one of the things I was afraid of with Sabira in a manager position. She's kind of a power hog who wants to push her weight around and sound tough. She wants things to be her decision because she knows best. She's one of those "I know best" personalities that are frustrating to deal with in your peers, but horrific to deal with in a superior or person in any position of power. As a workshift manager, I never threatened people with that 3/4 rule. I think anyone who does doesn't really deserve to be a manager. You should listen to what the house wants. They elected you. You're not there to boss them around or be mean to them. You're there to make sure the house runs smoothly. You stop people from making decisions that would benefit them at the expense of the whole house. You keep people's information up to date and try to get things running smoothly. You are the servant of the house, not it's boss. That's what it means to be a manager. Sabira didn't get that. She wanted to be the house's boss and tell us what she was willing to let us decide. At this point I was feeling less bad about usurping her and didn't feel at all guilty about bursting her bubble. She clearly had not read the bylaws because the workshift manager can be overturned by a simple majority vote in almost all situations. Here's a passage from our bylaws:
A workshift manager's allocation of hours to a particular workshift may only be overturned by a 3/4 vote by the house. This provision only applies to a workshift manager's determination of how many hours a workshift shall be worth. In the case of a dispute with a member over how long a workshift actually took to complete, or other such issues, the house shall retain its power to overturn the workshift manager's actions by majority vote.
So if Sabira says a shift is worth 1 hour and someone else says it should be worth 4, it would take 3/4 of the house to overturn her. In this situation, that was not the case. It's one thing to throw your weight around. It's quite another thing to throw your weight around when you don't have the authority to back it up. I will never understand why people will quote the bylaws without actually having read them. They're not that long really. And the parts that pertain to your specific job are definitely not that long. It's easy to gloss over room bids and things like that. And when people misquote the bylaws, they look extra stupid. I think it's that quoting the bylaws is an extremely persuasive argument (you can't really argue with that and it gives you a lot of authority), but the idea of reading 14 pages of "the managers shall do this" and "it is the responsibility of the workshift manager to do that" can be daunting to people. So they don't bother to actually read it, but when they start to feel cornered, they start to quote it and hope their bull shit can slide. And maybe Sabira didn't even realize that it was bull shit. She had heard that 3/4 rule before. It is easily the most misquoted rule in all the bylaws. A lot of people think it applies to every decision the workshift manager makes instead of the extremely limited situations it actually applies to. And this is another reason that it's bad to mention the 3/4 rule - you are way too likely to get overturn and look like an ass.
So to make a long story less long, when we voted on Jesse's revised proposal, Sabira was the only one to vote against it (though there were a handful of abstentions). In fact, I think 3/4 of the house might have actually overturned her, not that it matter. Then a lengthy discussion of whether or not to apply it retroactively came up and was narrowly voted down. I spearheaded that discussion. I wanted my old hours back since this was the policy now. I'm tired of being down hours when I shouldn't be. I probably made a lifelong enemy of Sabira by fighting for that. Whatever. As long as I mind my p's and q's, there's nothing she can do about it. And that's not really the way her mind works anyway. Anyway, I had already tread on her toes by fighting for the new policy and contradicting her when she said the extra amount of work it would create for her would be unreasonable. And then contradicting her again by clarifying the 3/4 rule. So I might as well go for broke and push even harder.
With Jesse's policy, I'm only going to owe 2 hours a week for most of the summer (summer school is only 4 days a week for me and this policy convinces me that it's not worth it to come back Sunday night). This is better than I expected, so I'm pretty happy about the situation. And honestly, there's nothing Sabira can do about it. There have been some cases in the past when someone was frequently not in the house and wanted to know if they could owe less than 5 hours a week. I think I would have been ok with it, but that's against the USCA bylaws, so I had to say no. If I only owe 2 hours all summer long and she argues with me about it, I have the leverage to overturn her. Because in summer, the minimum number of hours someone can owe weekly is not 3; it's 2. Stebbins is actually more strict with its hour requirements over summer. And if the house knew that, they might overturn that as well. And Sabira does not want that. Not that I think she's really going to give me trouble. I'm just prepared if she does.
I was wondering a little why I'm so mean to Sabira, but after writing this, I think I've changed my mind. She's a power hungry idiot. She strikes me as one of those people who was really awkward as a kid and didn't really have any friends. She could have been one of those kids that everyone picked on. When I look at her, I see someone who doesn't really get it. She could have easily changed the course of that conversation. She could have set the tone. It didn't even need to be a discussion. If she had just proposed a vote over her policy, it's possible that no one would have spoken up (I wouldn't have) with another policy before the vote was over. And then if someone spoke up, she could just say, well we just voted, so I think the house is ok with this. Then she could have said "let's talk after the meeting" or something else to defer discussion and it would have all gone away. I know Jesse wouldn't have followed through and talked with her after the meeting. He even said partway through the discussion "I don't know why I'm even fighting for this. I'm here all the time. It doesn't apply to me." He just thought her original policy was unfair. If she had addressed his concerns herself by offering a counter proposal (even the slightly unfair one of one hour per day), it probably wouldn't have been worth his effort to suggest the half hour a day rate. And if she had been less adamant against it and had not fought kicking and screaming, she might have been able to convince people by sounding rational and offering legitimate reasons why she thought the one hour a day rule made sense. She wants power (she's run for manager positions so many times - she says she needs the money, but it's so much easier to just get a part time job), but she doesn't know how to use it effectively. And now that she's been overturned once, it makes it that much easier for her to be overturned again. And chances are, she won't be able to reverse the pattern since she doesn't really know what she's doing. She could have gotten her way if she just knew how to handle people and meet them half way. Jesse's compromise of rounding up to the nearest hour is not what she wanted at all. Of course everyone else in the room felt like the people on opposite sides had met halfway just because neither one's original proposal was accepted. The made the rounding up policy all the more attractive because it looked like a moderate position. The truth is, it doesn't make much of a difference. Jesse's policy wasn't changed very much. It was still totally unacceptable to Sabira. Well tough shit. I'd feel bad about arguing with her and overturning her, but she was a fool to take such a hard-and-fast position on something she was guaranteed to lose. She tried to avoid the confrontation (asking people to email her) and tried to force the house into submission (bringing up the misquotation of the 3/4 rule), but that's not how you get your way. And if that's the way you think, you probably shouldn't get your way. I think she knew the house didn't like her policy, but she wanted to have it anyway. Oh well. You can't force your views on someone else just because you manage their workshifts. Maybe she'll realize that and maybe she won't. At least she's only workshift manager for the summer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)