It feels much better now.
I don't generally have a stick up my butt. At least I don't think so. But it's a bit of a different story when it comes to teaching. I came into it thinking (and with good cause) that as a teacher you have to act a certain way. It is largely true. I can't really swear or make dirty jokes. I can't give the kids a playful punch (most of the people I playfully punch probably wish I felt that way about them). I can't wear what I want. There are a lot of restrictions on how you can act. You have to have a certain level of propriety.
But there's more to it than that. It's more than just the things you're not allowed to do. There are also the things you have to do, like write and grade tests, discipline students, fail students. Being the person in charge changes you. When the responsibility is on your shoulders and it's your job to make other people do things they don't want to do, it warps you a little bit, even if you're doing it for their own good. It's interesting- bosses or managers at a normal workplace aren't assigning work for their employees' benefits, but neither are they so vested in their employees' performance. Of course a manager cares if their employees do well, but if an employee consistently fails, they just fire that employee and get another one. There's a certain point where the responsibility just isn't yours anymore. That's true of teaching too, but the line isn't drawn in exactly the same place. I carry more responsibility for my students than a manager does for his employees. If a student never takes it upon themselves to study, it's not my fault, but I am supposed to take measures to prevent such a thing. Perhaps a manager is supposed to do that too. I don't know.
Anyway, I've rambled away from my point from earlier. Being in charge changes you and the way you act. Even if I didn't have any restrictions on how I could act, the relation between a teacher and student can never be like an interaction between two people who don't have control over each other's life. I remember reading in my history textbook in high school that slavery warped owners as well as slaves. At the time I thought it interesting, but also sort of wrote it off. No more than a paragraph was devoted to the ill effects slavery had upon slavers (and for very good politically correct reason). I'm not sure I would go so far as to say "warped" myself, but I do know from experience that it changes you, and not for the better. You have a job to do, and you want to get it done. Your job is to control the actions of people. That's a pretty tough job. It takes a special personality and a lot of skill to control people effectively. If you don't know what you're doing, at best, people will chafe under you and perpetrate small acts of vengeance. At worst there will be an open rebellion and you'll get a painful dose of just how ineffective you really are.
I've had everything from chafing to open rebellion this semester. I wasn't exactly managing effectively. I had in my mind all these rules and regulations and artificial systems, as well as all these ideas about how to effectively teach, how to differentiate, how to write a test, how to grade, etc. Rules, like regulating bathroom passes and requiring students to change seats, can be useful and important, but if you don't have the background and understanding needed, you won't know when the rules should bend and when they should be disregarded. Add to that the fact that I've been something of a pompous ass (I don't generally put others down or anything, nor do I get particularly jealous if someone does happen to best me, but I am rather prideful and do have myself on something of a pedestal. Can you blame me? I'm amazing!), and it's no surprise that I haven't been managing effectively.
I think it all comes from the biggest dread of management- to be ignored. I was ignored at first as well. I think a full out riot is worse (and much harder to stop), but being ignored is really frustrating. If someone doesn't stop talking when you tell them to, then why should anybody stop talking? And then why should anyone bother listening to you? If your bark has no bite, then you're the worst kind of manager. But you don't need bite when talking to your friends. I barely even use bite with my enemies - I prefer avoidance to confrontation. So my "warping" began when I discovered the need for bite, and developed it.
It starts off with Threats. Threats are an unpleasant thing to have to do. I never Threaten people usually. I think I'd be pretty intolerable to others if I did, and I'd probably be a little intolerable to myself as well. But heaven forbid I be ignored! Therefore I must Threaten.
But as any manager can tell you, Threats are not enough. You have to back them up every so often. And so there must be Consequences. Fortunately for me, the Consequences in high school are not too severe. They mostly involve standing outside (in effect, punishment by boredom, plus a little suspense) and waiting for a talking to, which can also be unpleasant. Most high school students are not particularly well defended against or adept at one on one confrontation. The most successful ones will just start yelling or possibly cussing you out. Alternatively, they just clam up and remained clammed up for a while (thus achieving your purpose). Other more serious Consequences could be calling home or a referral, but that's about as severe as they get. The severity is important in the altering of personality, but simple willingness to inflict Consequences is the biggest change. Once you have have exercised Consequences, you are now a person of power, someone to be wary of. Everyone's demeanor towards you changes. Immediately, that change is for the better. You are no longer ignored. You can now get your job done effectively, which is quite gratifying. The Consequence wasn't nearly as difficult to dish out as you might have imagined. It was not questioned or fought against as you may have feared. You also see the wariness as a type of respect. All this together makes the next Consequence a lot easier. Give it one or two more instances, and you have become not only a person who Threatens, but also a person with the power and, more importantly, the willingness to inflict Consequences.
But consequences aren't really what gets a student (or any other sort of employee) to work. It keeps them settled and in line and it prevents the dreaded ineffectiveness that results from being ignored, but it isn't really an effective motivator. It is still necessary. If no one will listen to you, how can you motivate? But something else is necessary as well. Several somethings else, in fact. Caring about your students is an oft quoted one. It probably is the most effective way to get people to work for you. If you can convince them that your motives are their own personal welfare, they're far more likely to listen and go along with what you say. This is one place where teachers have a leg up on the average manager. Our charges really are our primary concern.
Even though caring about your students is probably the most important thing a teacher needs to do to get through, there are other necessary actions and stances as well. The most contradictory of these is that you must take what your students say with a grain of salt. You have to care about them and regard them as smart, thinking individuals (they really are), but you also have to recognize just how ignorant they are. And you can't hold it against them! Normally arrogant people earn only my scorn (I like to think my own brand of arrogance is simply confidence. And I do recognize my own limitations fairly realistically for the most part. Yes, I am a little hypocritical, but I am pretty good about respecting those around me and keeping my opinion of myself to myself.), but with arrogant teenagers, you have to accept it and like them anyway. It's who they are. They are only just beginning to gain (regain?) some confidence and most of them don't know how to go about it properly. So you get a lot of posturing and certainty about things they can't possibly know. Don't take them seriously, especially when it comes to your own job. I certainly won't claim to know what I'm doing, but I am also reasonably certain at this point that I know far more than they.
So you must care for and respect, but also not respect, your charges. It is difficult, but it's something you get the hang of. The next important thing to keep in mind is the rules. You have to know them inside and out. And what I mean by that primarily, is that you have to know which ones are really serious, which ones are tertiary, and which ones you would be better off ignoring. Someone in my cohort uses the Go Green system. He turns a card every time a student does something they shouldn't. It's a fine system, especially for beginners as a scaffold, but it is generally pretty meaningless and excessively rigid. Our advisor Dan said that most veteran teachers don't use it. It's difficult to be consistent. If you respond the same way every time, you'll interrupt the flow of a lecture. You also aren't going to catch everything that everyone does, and then he people who were caught will start to complain. It solves a lot of problems (transparency and appropriate response to appropriate crime for example), but it can raise a lot of them also. When you don't know anything, when you don't know how to react to the million of little things that can go on, it's very reassuring to have a rigid system where everything is set up.
I never used Go Green, but I recently had a similar realization about the rigidity of my own posturing. I was a proper teacher who didn't step out of line and who loved all things even remotely mathematical and who would certainly never tease her students. Forcing myself to be something I wasn't was very draining. I went to class every day and left it exhausted and needing to watch Star Trek or something to get me back to myself. The rigidity was useful to me. It helped me know how I should behave in novel situations where I had only a second to decide what my course of action should be. I would ask, "How should a teacher react?" and then I would do what I felt I should. I'm not entirely sure how I broke out of that. Probably just experience. I still fit into the mold more than is optimal in all likelihood, but I have broken free to a much greater extent. I remember the first time I finished class and thought it was fun. It wasn't that long ago. The other day, I felt like I had more energy upon leaving the class instead of less. It takes a lot of energy to put up a false persona. I realized that the first time in high school and began striving to be as honest with myself as possible. I've realized it again only recently, when I got that "proper teacher" stick out of my ass. I'm beginning to realize I will be a most improper teacher. I still won't do anything inappropriate or violate any of my restrictions, but I will tease my students. I will throw a tantrum and toss my whiteboard marker on the floor when people stop paying attention. I will brush off and ignore someone who is hassling me instead of explaining my reasoning and wasting class time (students will often make demands in front of the class that it really isn't wise to respond to). It's quite liberating to be the softhearted grouch I consider myself to be.
I will conclude this entry with a warning to all people of the world who think they can do better than the people in charge: the bosses, the managers, the teachers, etc. You can't. At least not at first. In the beginning, everyone will be wary of you and you will have an initial rush that just maybe you do have a knack for this managing thing. With everyone on their toes, you realize that you are just as good and fair minded as you thought you were. People will listen to you because of how reasonable you are. You won't ever have to force people down like the cads before you. Then someone will ignore you. Then several someones. Then you will go down the same path of Threats and Consequences that every other human being in power has ever done and become just as big an oaf as any superior you ever disliked. The sheer inevitability of it this semester has really struck me. If you really care, you'll get past it. I think I will be a fine manager of students one day. I'm even not that bad today, but it has been a slow and arduous process, one damaging to my own self image more than anything else. I am pleased at the lessons I've learned (care, don't listen to what people say too closely, recognize rules for what they are, be yourself). Some of them may seem obvious even to the point of being trite (I'm looking at you "be yourself"), but they were hard learned and painfully won. I know I have a lot more progress to make. I'm no expert by any means. I'm just happy at this point to have that stick out my rear.
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
Wednesday, December 24, 2008
Typing whiz!
I am a typing whiz!
I mean I have enough practice. I'm writing lengthy journals, blogs, and emails all the time. I've always enjoyed writing (specifically on the computer I might add).
The interesting thing is my progression. I do remember taking a few elementary typing courses in 7th grade. I struggled with them a lot. I could never move fast enough for them and I often had to keep looking at the keyboard. It was incredibly stressful, and considering how little I used those programs (and how they weren't tested at all), it's not surprising that I never learned to type properly. Our computer class was only once a week and I would be very surprised if it was taught by anyone credentialed. He basically was just someone decently proficient in computer use who gave us a few programs and let us fly. He knew html and gave us a run through of the basic commands. That's about all there was to my early computer class. It culminated in us making a webpage. So many animated gifs. I was so impressed by how fancy they looked. To this day, I have a well hidden impression that the key to good web page design is more animated gifs. The more sensible part of me realizes that that's not really the most pleasant thing to look at, but the little kid in me kind of gets a kick out of it. And if left to my own devices creating a webpage, I would probably sneak what animated gifs I could into it (assuming no one else was going to view my shamefully animated webpage).
But I digress. That was the sum of my early typing experience. I typed so clumsily and with so many errors, that the correct way of typing was not appealing. I still had to type things for class, but I was the worst of the hunt-and-peckers. I remember once getting stuck for a significant length of time on "q." It just hadn't come up before. I remember thinking, "Wait this can't be this hard... it must be here somewhere..." Kids don't often have the sense to search methodically, so I didn't think to start at the top left for a while. Ah, the trials of hunt and peck.
So I never properly learned where all the keys were, and I never properly learned the find the little bumps on the f and the j. I just looked intently. It worked well enough. It certainly wasn't any slower for me than the proper way, and it was quite a bit more accurate.
Over time, I came to spend a lot more time typing. During high school, I wrote lengthy journals which I only trusted that no one would find if I wrote them on my computer. I had them in my email account (one of the most massive saved drafts ever), which I felt was a more secure password than any flimsy key on some cheap diary lock. Honestly, no one was looking, but teenagers can be incredibly secretive, and I was one of the worst.
So began my history of writing lengthy journals by typing them. Over time, I found how much writing helped to organize my thoughts and grew pretty dependent on journals. I spent so much time writing aside from classwork, that a one or two page paper was quite trivial when it was assigned. I did have a lot of trouble refining those papers. My rough drafts were always some of the better ones, but I was very reluctant to edit or incorporate suggested changes. I may have had an advantage writing due to my extra experience with my journals, but I definitely did not have any additional experience editing. The most I do with these sorts of journals is correct grammar and spelling of the previous paragraph. I rarely do a thorough reread. That's not really the purpose the journals serve. They give me a point of reference, a solid record of where I was, before a ramble takes me so far afield I can't remember my original intent. Edits just aren't useful as long as what I wrote gave me the gist of where I was.
Regardless of my lack of experience editing, I gained quite a bit of experience typing. Discovering instant messages in college helped with that also, but my IMing career was quite sort lived in comparison. Over time, my hunt and peck style began to get quite sophisticated. What began as two fingers (a very literal hunt and peck), evolved into five: both middle and index fingers and my left thumb. Occasionally my pinky on my left hand would also come into play for the sake of capitalization. Looking at the keyboard served to stabilize my hands and tell them where to move around so that they wouldn't overshoot their destination keys, but my eyes played less and less of a role. My hands got to the point where the knew where all the keys were. Often, my hands would be blocking my view of the keys, yet I still knew about how far my hands had to move to be correctly positioned. I also got to know familiar letter combinations and the patterns formed by certain words. I never explicitly learned this, but after enough typing, you just get to know this sort of stuff. Now, every so often, I'll notice a few other fingers (ring fingers) jumping into the fray. It seems that my typing evolution is actually coming interestingly close to the correct style. I tested myself a little earlier today to see how well I could type without looking at the keyboard. It wasn't as smooth as when I do look, but it was much smoother than I might have expected. Occasionally I'd be off by a space and type "[;" instead of "pl" before I noticed my error and readjusted my hands, but in general, when I'd guess where the letters should be, I was right. Once my hands were positioned correctly, my fingers knew how to take it from there. It was really pretty fascinating.
So could I learn the correct method? Yes, I would have a reduced accuracy and speed initially, but would it pay off in the end? Right now, my typing speed is about 50 words a minute with very high accuracy. Do I really need to try something new? Is it worth it for me to improve? I seem to be unconsciously optimizing my hunt and peck all the time.
The truth of the matter is that I certainly don't need it. I've clearly gotten by fine without and will continue to get along just fine. I also think it's pretty interesting how my unorthodox style has had such excellent results. That said, I always like to improve. I revel in learning new things. As much as I like my strange style of typing, it might be worthwhile to go about things more efficiently, if only to show that I could. I don't know. I never really thought of myself as an excellent typist (though I've always known I get by). I guess I've just been thinking of this a lot ever since I tried my dad's typing software. I'm feeling a little puffed up at the discovery of a new talent I've been developing for years and yet somehow didn't know I had. I kind of just want to type for a while, just to actually confirm that I'm good at it. It's pretty interesting, like a new game. I've never really had any way to measure my typing before, so this typing software my dad has been using to learn is pretty fun.
Even though I've got typing on the brain, I think I'm going to end this blog entry. I realize it's probably one of my more dull entries. I mean, typing isn't exactly riveting. But I can't help it! I can't think of anything else right at the moment. I'm going to go use the typing software some more!
I mean I have enough practice. I'm writing lengthy journals, blogs, and emails all the time. I've always enjoyed writing (specifically on the computer I might add).
The interesting thing is my progression. I do remember taking a few elementary typing courses in 7th grade. I struggled with them a lot. I could never move fast enough for them and I often had to keep looking at the keyboard. It was incredibly stressful, and considering how little I used those programs (and how they weren't tested at all), it's not surprising that I never learned to type properly. Our computer class was only once a week and I would be very surprised if it was taught by anyone credentialed. He basically was just someone decently proficient in computer use who gave us a few programs and let us fly. He knew html and gave us a run through of the basic commands. That's about all there was to my early computer class. It culminated in us making a webpage. So many animated gifs. I was so impressed by how fancy they looked. To this day, I have a well hidden impression that the key to good web page design is more animated gifs. The more sensible part of me realizes that that's not really the most pleasant thing to look at, but the little kid in me kind of gets a kick out of it. And if left to my own devices creating a webpage, I would probably sneak what animated gifs I could into it (assuming no one else was going to view my shamefully animated webpage).
But I digress. That was the sum of my early typing experience. I typed so clumsily and with so many errors, that the correct way of typing was not appealing. I still had to type things for class, but I was the worst of the hunt-and-peckers. I remember once getting stuck for a significant length of time on "q." It just hadn't come up before. I remember thinking, "Wait this can't be this hard... it must be here somewhere..." Kids don't often have the sense to search methodically, so I didn't think to start at the top left for a while. Ah, the trials of hunt and peck.
So I never properly learned where all the keys were, and I never properly learned the find the little bumps on the f and the j. I just looked intently. It worked well enough. It certainly wasn't any slower for me than the proper way, and it was quite a bit more accurate.
Over time, I came to spend a lot more time typing. During high school, I wrote lengthy journals which I only trusted that no one would find if I wrote them on my computer. I had them in my email account (one of the most massive saved drafts ever), which I felt was a more secure password than any flimsy key on some cheap diary lock. Honestly, no one was looking, but teenagers can be incredibly secretive, and I was one of the worst.
So began my history of writing lengthy journals by typing them. Over time, I found how much writing helped to organize my thoughts and grew pretty dependent on journals. I spent so much time writing aside from classwork, that a one or two page paper was quite trivial when it was assigned. I did have a lot of trouble refining those papers. My rough drafts were always some of the better ones, but I was very reluctant to edit or incorporate suggested changes. I may have had an advantage writing due to my extra experience with my journals, but I definitely did not have any additional experience editing. The most I do with these sorts of journals is correct grammar and spelling of the previous paragraph. I rarely do a thorough reread. That's not really the purpose the journals serve. They give me a point of reference, a solid record of where I was, before a ramble takes me so far afield I can't remember my original intent. Edits just aren't useful as long as what I wrote gave me the gist of where I was.
Regardless of my lack of experience editing, I gained quite a bit of experience typing. Discovering instant messages in college helped with that also, but my IMing career was quite sort lived in comparison. Over time, my hunt and peck style began to get quite sophisticated. What began as two fingers (a very literal hunt and peck), evolved into five: both middle and index fingers and my left thumb. Occasionally my pinky on my left hand would also come into play for the sake of capitalization. Looking at the keyboard served to stabilize my hands and tell them where to move around so that they wouldn't overshoot their destination keys, but my eyes played less and less of a role. My hands got to the point where the knew where all the keys were. Often, my hands would be blocking my view of the keys, yet I still knew about how far my hands had to move to be correctly positioned. I also got to know familiar letter combinations and the patterns formed by certain words. I never explicitly learned this, but after enough typing, you just get to know this sort of stuff. Now, every so often, I'll notice a few other fingers (ring fingers) jumping into the fray. It seems that my typing evolution is actually coming interestingly close to the correct style. I tested myself a little earlier today to see how well I could type without looking at the keyboard. It wasn't as smooth as when I do look, but it was much smoother than I might have expected. Occasionally I'd be off by a space and type "[;" instead of "pl" before I noticed my error and readjusted my hands, but in general, when I'd guess where the letters should be, I was right. Once my hands were positioned correctly, my fingers knew how to take it from there. It was really pretty fascinating.
So could I learn the correct method? Yes, I would have a reduced accuracy and speed initially, but would it pay off in the end? Right now, my typing speed is about 50 words a minute with very high accuracy. Do I really need to try something new? Is it worth it for me to improve? I seem to be unconsciously optimizing my hunt and peck all the time.
The truth of the matter is that I certainly don't need it. I've clearly gotten by fine without and will continue to get along just fine. I also think it's pretty interesting how my unorthodox style has had such excellent results. That said, I always like to improve. I revel in learning new things. As much as I like my strange style of typing, it might be worthwhile to go about things more efficiently, if only to show that I could. I don't know. I never really thought of myself as an excellent typist (though I've always known I get by). I guess I've just been thinking of this a lot ever since I tried my dad's typing software. I'm feeling a little puffed up at the discovery of a new talent I've been developing for years and yet somehow didn't know I had. I kind of just want to type for a while, just to actually confirm that I'm good at it. It's pretty interesting, like a new game. I've never really had any way to measure my typing before, so this typing software my dad has been using to learn is pretty fun.
Even though I've got typing on the brain, I think I'm going to end this blog entry. I realize it's probably one of my more dull entries. I mean, typing isn't exactly riveting. But I can't help it! I can't think of anything else right at the moment. I'm going to go use the typing software some more!
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Journals
I have my students do a somewhat unusual assignment. I collect journals from them every week. I require it to be at least two sentences, so it's not too strenuous. It's basically a way for me to check in with them, to give them a forum to complain that's not in front of the class, and a way for me to get to know them a little better.
I originally started requiring it because some of the MACSMEs from last year did it. They said it was pretty interesting to hear from their students. I'm not sure if they responded to them all (and almost certainly not to the extent which I respond to all of my students' journals), but it sounds like it was basically the same thing. It doesn't have to be about math and it's meant to be low key and easy.
I've gone back and forth on the idea over the semester of whether or not I'll do it again. For a while, I thought I wouldn't do it again for a few years, at least until I get my bearings. Though now as the semester is nearing its end and I feel like I have my bearings more than I did, I'm starting to think it's a really good assignment. Yes, I do have students who haven't been doing them and it's brought their grade down (that is very depressing, when they're working hard on the math and they just can't get it together enough to do a journal). That completely defeats the purpose of assigning it and frustrates me a lot. But some of the benefits of it have been pretty nice. I have gotten to know my students a lot better and I really do like the opportunity to find out what's going on with them. I find it fascinating more often than not and it gives me a good pulse on how students are feeling. They tend to be pretty honest overall, so I get a good sense of how they feel towards me. Also, I can find out if something is wrong and maybe help deal with that, or make allowances for it by going easy on them in some other way. It also give me an opportunity to explain what's going on or why I'm doing something they ask about. I have a lot more transparency. Transparency is always a good thing when teaching. I don't want to be some mysterious figure doing mysterious things. I want them to see that assigning homework, for instance, is something that will help them learn the material because one day, they won't have a teacher hounding them to make them do the homework. They'll have to get off their butts themselves because no one will make them. Now I don't think most of my students realize that what I'm doing is forcing them to be good students/learners, but I think transparency makes it a little easier for them to realize this. Some of the intricacies of learning are probably a little hard for them to recognize right now, but I like to think that I'm at least keeping the door open for that.
Mostly, I've found that teaching the class goes a lot better with the students on my side, when I'm comfortable with them. When I'm relaxed and when I joke around with them a bit, I feel better and have more fun and I think it goes a little smoother for them also. And it's hard to feel relaxed around a bunch of strangers. Getting to know your students is a really important part of teaching, at least it is for me. So I think I will continue with the journals. They probably end up being worth the effort.
I originally started requiring it because some of the MACSMEs from last year did it. They said it was pretty interesting to hear from their students. I'm not sure if they responded to them all (and almost certainly not to the extent which I respond to all of my students' journals), but it sounds like it was basically the same thing. It doesn't have to be about math and it's meant to be low key and easy.
I've gone back and forth on the idea over the semester of whether or not I'll do it again. For a while, I thought I wouldn't do it again for a few years, at least until I get my bearings. Though now as the semester is nearing its end and I feel like I have my bearings more than I did, I'm starting to think it's a really good assignment. Yes, I do have students who haven't been doing them and it's brought their grade down (that is very depressing, when they're working hard on the math and they just can't get it together enough to do a journal). That completely defeats the purpose of assigning it and frustrates me a lot. But some of the benefits of it have been pretty nice. I have gotten to know my students a lot better and I really do like the opportunity to find out what's going on with them. I find it fascinating more often than not and it gives me a good pulse on how students are feeling. They tend to be pretty honest overall, so I get a good sense of how they feel towards me. Also, I can find out if something is wrong and maybe help deal with that, or make allowances for it by going easy on them in some other way. It also give me an opportunity to explain what's going on or why I'm doing something they ask about. I have a lot more transparency. Transparency is always a good thing when teaching. I don't want to be some mysterious figure doing mysterious things. I want them to see that assigning homework, for instance, is something that will help them learn the material because one day, they won't have a teacher hounding them to make them do the homework. They'll have to get off their butts themselves because no one will make them. Now I don't think most of my students realize that what I'm doing is forcing them to be good students/learners, but I think transparency makes it a little easier for them to realize this. Some of the intricacies of learning are probably a little hard for them to recognize right now, but I like to think that I'm at least keeping the door open for that.
Mostly, I've found that teaching the class goes a lot better with the students on my side, when I'm comfortable with them. When I'm relaxed and when I joke around with them a bit, I feel better and have more fun and I think it goes a little smoother for them also. And it's hard to feel relaxed around a bunch of strangers. Getting to know your students is a really important part of teaching, at least it is for me. So I think I will continue with the journals. They probably end up being worth the effort.
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
Teaching is like Angband
This comparison came to me not long ago and ever since I've been thinking about the parallels. There are more of them than I would have expected actually.
The similarity that originally struck me was the learning curve. When I first began playing Angband, it was such a slow and painful process. Ever minute or so, I had to ask someone how to do something. I might not have continued playing the game if I wasn't playing it in the same room as several other Angband enthusiasts that I could routinely ask for help. But everyone around me was playing it and they seemed to be having fun, so I stuck with it and grappled with all the different commands I had to learn (I want to drink... what do I do? Quaff???). Learning all the commands and getting to be fluid with them was actually a pretty slow process as I remember. In fact, it was so slow and subtle that I didn't even realize when I stopped pausing every few seconds to ask someone what I should do. And questions still came up from time to time as the game progressed (What's elvenkind?), but the mechanics of the game started to become much more automated for me. I didn't have to think about them so much (I need to drink? q. Move on.). I wasn't even aware how natural it had gotten until it hit me all of a sudden. It was about the same time that I realized I was having fun.
I had that same surprising realization recently with teaching. I can't think of any other time I've had this same exact feeling. It's sort of a surprised "Wait... I like this?" That's not too surprising actually. Very rarely do we persist in something that's not fun for an extended period of time. Things with a steep learning curve spend a lot of time being just not fun. They're initially hard, strenuous, frustrating, and depressing. I can't say I got too depressed over Angband (though losing a character you've worked on for days just because you stopped paying attention for a second is really annoying), but teaching has been a strain on me. There have been times when I've wallowed for hours after class because I had a really bad day. At least once this semester (if not more), I seriously considered quitting and trying something less painful. The job was so hard and, more often than not, not particularly rewarding. Often you get smacked on your ass by a student who wants to be difficult just because they can, or an angry parent will start to yell at you because everything is not perfect for their child. Or worse yet, you just confuse everyone and then you have to go through the painful process of grading a bunch of tests that make everyone's grades drop. Sometimes the test is the first indication I have that something is wrong, and by then it's too late. That's a really frustrating situation to be in.
There are a lot of frustrating situations. Teaching is just one long string of frustrating situations. I was doing it because it was something really important and I thought I could make a difference, but it was a constant struggle.
Then, almost imperceptibly, I struggled a little less. Of course, I still flopped quite heartily quite often. I flopped enough that I don't think I realized I was struggling less.
Then, after enough time spent flopping and struggling and messing up, a day goes smoothly. You feel good about a day well done.
Then you flop the next day and forget all about it.
Then another smooth day goes by. Then, slowly yet surely, the good days start to outnumber the flops. You start to make predictions about how certain things will go. You start asking students questions that don't confuse them as much. You get a sense for how long certain activities will take. You get the knack of designing a worksheet in 10 minutes. Then you start to get the knack of making that worksheet accomplish something good.
Then you suddenly realize it. You don't realize, "oh I'm good at this." That's not what I realized about Angband. It wouldn't have been true either. I couldn't legitimately get past level 40 or 50 as I recall. The real realization you come across is, "Oh! That was fun!" There is a sense of accomplishment about actually knowing how to maneuver yourself through an ASCII world or a classroom of teenagers, but that in itself isn't fun. It's satisfying certainly, and maybe that can give a feeling of fun, but I'm not sure it's quite the same. I actually enjoyed class today. I'm not going to say that's never happened before, but today was one of the first days when it really struck me, when I realized with a start that what had been a chore and a difficult yet necessary job in my mind for so long actually left me feeling happy. That doesn't happen often, in part because I'm a strict self critic when it comes to teaching and in part because I'm so used to being in the top 10% of things I do that being considerably worse than that is really frustrating.
But today I felt went really well. And it felt like I had something to do with it going well. I made good choices. I asked the right questions. I set up the right problems for them to work on. The kids weren't just having a good day, though that may have also been true. It went well and it was more than just luck. I did things right, and I got to see the benefits of that.
And the benefits are good. :D
The similarity that originally struck me was the learning curve. When I first began playing Angband, it was such a slow and painful process. Ever minute or so, I had to ask someone how to do something. I might not have continued playing the game if I wasn't playing it in the same room as several other Angband enthusiasts that I could routinely ask for help. But everyone around me was playing it and they seemed to be having fun, so I stuck with it and grappled with all the different commands I had to learn (I want to drink... what do I do? Quaff???). Learning all the commands and getting to be fluid with them was actually a pretty slow process as I remember. In fact, it was so slow and subtle that I didn't even realize when I stopped pausing every few seconds to ask someone what I should do. And questions still came up from time to time as the game progressed (What's elvenkind?), but the mechanics of the game started to become much more automated for me. I didn't have to think about them so much (I need to drink? q. Move on.). I wasn't even aware how natural it had gotten until it hit me all of a sudden. It was about the same time that I realized I was having fun.
I had that same surprising realization recently with teaching. I can't think of any other time I've had this same exact feeling. It's sort of a surprised "Wait... I like this?" That's not too surprising actually. Very rarely do we persist in something that's not fun for an extended period of time. Things with a steep learning curve spend a lot of time being just not fun. They're initially hard, strenuous, frustrating, and depressing. I can't say I got too depressed over Angband (though losing a character you've worked on for days just because you stopped paying attention for a second is really annoying), but teaching has been a strain on me. There have been times when I've wallowed for hours after class because I had a really bad day. At least once this semester (if not more), I seriously considered quitting and trying something less painful. The job was so hard and, more often than not, not particularly rewarding. Often you get smacked on your ass by a student who wants to be difficult just because they can, or an angry parent will start to yell at you because everything is not perfect for their child. Or worse yet, you just confuse everyone and then you have to go through the painful process of grading a bunch of tests that make everyone's grades drop. Sometimes the test is the first indication I have that something is wrong, and by then it's too late. That's a really frustrating situation to be in.
There are a lot of frustrating situations. Teaching is just one long string of frustrating situations. I was doing it because it was something really important and I thought I could make a difference, but it was a constant struggle.
Then, almost imperceptibly, I struggled a little less. Of course, I still flopped quite heartily quite often. I flopped enough that I don't think I realized I was struggling less.
Then, after enough time spent flopping and struggling and messing up, a day goes smoothly. You feel good about a day well done.
Then you flop the next day and forget all about it.
Then another smooth day goes by. Then, slowly yet surely, the good days start to outnumber the flops. You start to make predictions about how certain things will go. You start asking students questions that don't confuse them as much. You get a sense for how long certain activities will take. You get the knack of designing a worksheet in 10 minutes. Then you start to get the knack of making that worksheet accomplish something good.
Then you suddenly realize it. You don't realize, "oh I'm good at this." That's not what I realized about Angband. It wouldn't have been true either. I couldn't legitimately get past level 40 or 50 as I recall. The real realization you come across is, "Oh! That was fun!" There is a sense of accomplishment about actually knowing how to maneuver yourself through an ASCII world or a classroom of teenagers, but that in itself isn't fun. It's satisfying certainly, and maybe that can give a feeling of fun, but I'm not sure it's quite the same. I actually enjoyed class today. I'm not going to say that's never happened before, but today was one of the first days when it really struck me, when I realized with a start that what had been a chore and a difficult yet necessary job in my mind for so long actually left me feeling happy. That doesn't happen often, in part because I'm a strict self critic when it comes to teaching and in part because I'm so used to being in the top 10% of things I do that being considerably worse than that is really frustrating.
But today I felt went really well. And it felt like I had something to do with it going well. I made good choices. I asked the right questions. I set up the right problems for them to work on. The kids weren't just having a good day, though that may have also been true. It went well and it was more than just luck. I did things right, and I got to see the benefits of that.
And the benefits are good. :D
Friday, August 15, 2008
Finally Blogging
I haven't blogged in a while and I've missed it. I've been itching to blog for week without really getting much of an opportunity to do so. It seems like my every spare moment has been taken up with math or the many distractions in my new house. Math 104 just ended yesterday and it was certainly hard. I did have to spend a lot of time studying for that class. It wouldn't have been so bad if I hadn't moved right before the second midterm. I didn't have a lot of time to study for that test and did pretty average on it (in that I scored the mean), so I felt like I had to study extra hard for the final I took yesterday. It was hard to focus too. The day before my final, there was happy nerdiness going on all day long. Two games of Puerto Rico were played, and video games were on the rest of the time. I was very hard to keep focused, especially with Aaron insisting that I play. He was little too insistent for my tastes, and I was a little annoyed since it was the day before my final, but I'll appreciate him as another player in games on some other day.
I feel like I've skipped some background here. If you're paying attention to the bits and pieces I've been mentioning, you know that I live in a new place and that nerdiness happens there, but those are just general senses of what going on. I'd like to get a little more in to the nitty gritty of it all.
So let's talk a little about moving. I finally live with Steven now and it's great. Before we moved in together, we were really chafing about having to part ways every Sunday. It just wasn't enough to see him only on the weekends. I remember there were a few weeknights where we just had to see each other and I went over to his place for the night. It was really inconvenient since I had to wake up early to go to class the next day, but sometimes we just couldn't stand being apart. And without exception Sunday nights were a bitter experience. I remember when I had to go to manager meetings on Sundays. I was so cranky and grouchy and bit everyone's heads off. I remember our president Roxy would try to get the meetings started with cute little games. Another time of the week and I might have appreciated it, but Sunday nights I never did. I feel like I was part of the reason that she didn't like being president. Not that she held it against me I don't think. And to be honest, I'm not even sure she disliked being president. I remember her saying once that she probably wouldn't run again and didn't think it was really for her. She's one of those people who is really pure. She likes to do sweet things and take care of children. She does well around children, but not necessarily around people who make dirty jokes and ask her to show off her cleavage. And she's also the sort of person who wouldn't get mad about stuff like that, but you could tell she didn't appreciate it. I often felt like she was repressing herself a little to act appropriately in the face of some of Stebbins' darker elements when she was actually pretty bothered. But who knows. I think she enjoyed herself most of the time, so it was actually probably pretty easy for her to ignore the stuff she didn't like. She did still try to do cute little games, which children probably would have appreciated a lot more than busy college students, even as I shot her down. I feel bad about it a little, but the idea was pretty misplaced. Sure it's great if you've got nothing else better to do and everything's great for you, but when things aren't great, you want to get down to business, not play a little game. I was a little mean, she was a little shortsighted; it all evens out. I don't regret it.
Nor do I regret my non-manager status. I never really enjoyed being a manager. I took satisfaction in doing my job well, and I liked seeing it done well, and I especially hated seeing it done poorly, but I was still glad that it wasn't my responsibility. I was glad that I was able to pull up stakes and leave two thirds of the way through the summer to live with Steven. Yes, I had my frustrating moments through the summer when I disagreed with Sabira's policies and had to fight them, but even then the fight was kind of fun. Overall, I would rather not have to fight about things, but it is satisfying to win. And fighting her policies didn't really take that long. Certainly it took longer than being workshift manager, which is compensated pitifully during summer. Even when I increased the summer comp, it was still pretty pitiful. So maybe I shouldn't be too surprised that Sabira was the only one who ran, and when there's no competition, there's often low quality close behind. But I can't complain too much. She was a lot better than Matt Jones or Jon Hung. Better than Even by a wide margin too. This actually makes me think that maybe I'm too picky about the job and how I think it should be run. The only other workshift manager in my memory was Aron Bothman. I didn't experience him much first hand. I came in late and he didn't assign me any permanent workshifts, so I went down a bunch of hours. I guess in that sense he wasn't so hot. But that sort of thing is a pain, especially under the old system of workshift. I don't fault him too much. Apparently he was pretty on top of things in his day (which was before my time). But he was an incumbent for too long and got kind of lazy. At least that's what I've heard. I was only around for the very tail end of his regime, so I can't really make any of these comments from personal experience.
As much as I do love to ramble, I'd like to put this digression back on track: our new place. We did some house hunting online, but when it came down to actually looking at places, we only looked at two. Did we get the best deal we could? Who knows. Given how much time we were willing to put in to it, I think we did fine. As it stands, I love our place, and it's hard to put a price tag on satisfaction. It's a really cute place in a really convenient location. It has a nice kitchen and a two car garage. It looks really really spacious (and actually does have a pretty large square footage - 1380), and there's lots of storage space. Though some of the things I love the most about are things I would love about any house. I love being able to keep our stuff in common space without fear of it getting stolen. I love having nice things and not worrying about them getting destroyed by drunk Stebbinites. I love living in a house where I know I get along with everybody. A couple people warned me that a couple living in a house with one other person would result in a lot of third wheeling and awkwardness, but it hasn't happened yet. I think Susan and Steven and I are all getting along great. I really like our dynamic. It's going to be a really fun year I think. :)
One of the things facilitating the fun is all of our common interests. We're all a bunch of nerds. We've got Star Trek dvds on the table, Magic cards in the corner, more video game consoles than I could carry, and a handful of nerdy board games (which we actually have enough players around to play on a regular basis!). I love being immersed in all the nerdiness. Living in Stebbins, and in Berkeley in general, nerdiness is more a point of pride than one of shame, but there are people who do look down on nerdy things. It's a real downer when you come across one of those. They're generally people who have believed what others have told them without investigating for themselves. For instance, most people who dislike video games haven't actually played much of them. I don't mind them having their own opinions, but it seems like more often than not, people who dislike video games will look down on those who do. I don't look down on people who like to boat, even though it holds no interest for me. I don't look down on people who fish. I don't look down on people who go to museums. None of these things are my favorite activities. I've never fished, or been on a boat recreationally, and I rarely visit museums (and can often find myself bored when I do go). But that doesn't mean I don't see any worth in it. If it makes someone happy, then go for it. It's not hurting anyone; it's just how you choose to spend your free time. So don't be so judgmental about how I spend mine.
But realistically, everyone agrees with the statement I just made. No one thinks they're judgmental, or if they do end up judging something, they just say that that something merits it. And I think a lot of people aren't really aware that they look down on video games. They really don't think about it that often. I had difficulty coming up with examples of things I don't think about often just a moment ago. It's hard to think about something that you don't consider much. It's just that when video games do present themselves, when people do come across someone with a controller in their hands, it's like a knee jerk reaction to react negatively. I remember whenever Sabira entered a room with people playing video games, she would always leave as soon as she could because she claimed that video games were antisocial. If the type of social they keep away is Sabira's company, I don't think I mind too much. As it is, I feel very social when playing video games most of the time. Even one player games are fun to watch.
I don't know why I'm defending video games or even complaining about the disrespect they receive. It's not like it's going to change matters. I won't change anyone's opinions, but I will admit it is something of a sore spot for me. It makes it easy to rant and ramble whenever I think about it.
But back to some of the main things I was talking about. I feel like I've gone over the new house a little. Sure, there's more to tell, but perhaps now it's time to move on to a different topic, another one that was covered briefly in my introduction paragraph. Math 104 was a very difficult class for me. Everyone always said it was going to be crazy hard, and I believed them, but sometimes you have to experience something yourself to really understand it. There was some pretty crazy stuff there near the end. But the thing is, I felt like I could have understood all of it given more time. Taking this class over the summer was really hard. It's not like I had any choice in the matter, but nonetheless, I wish I had been able to take it in the fall or spring. Part of me is just glad to have it done, but I feel like I would have learned it a lot better if I had been able to go at a slower pace. I just don't feel like I got much out of this course. I felt like I was cramming the whole time. Trying to squeeze all that complicated information into my head at once makes me feel like none of it is going to stick. Even now, one day later, I don't feel like I can remember all of the little details I knew a day ago. I feel like I took this class for a reason, not just to have taken it, but given how much I took from the class, I don't know that I achieved its purpose. I was supposed to gain some insight into calculus, and maybe I did. But I really don't feel like a lot more enlightened now than I was at the beginning of summer. After taking abstract algebra and linear algebra last summer, I really felt like I knew a lot about algebra and numbers in general leaving those classes. I really learned a lot. For this class, I crammed a lot. I showed good test taking skills. But do I have some intuitive grasp on calculus? Not really. I guess I do understand some concepts better this time around than I did the first time I learned them in high school (and I learned them pretty well in high school), and I guess that will be useful (it's always important for the teacher to know a little more than she has to teach), but I worked really hard and I just don't feel like I got the same payout. It's a little embittering, especially considering all the painful stuff I had to go through. To give an idea of how crazy tough our final was, about three fourths of the way through, the guy next to me started to cry. I felt really awful. I couldn't focus on him that much because I had a test of my own to take, but I remember rooting for him silently for a second or two. "Just keep it together for another half hour! You're almost there!" There's nothing like feeling miserable to ensure that you really bomb a test though. You get into this spiral of unproductivity. You just think a lot slower when you're fighting off tears, and you know that you're moving slower and that makes you even more frustrated and makes you want to cry more. I've never broken down like that during a test, but I've had my breakdowns before. I know how he felt and I felt really bad for him. Our teacher admitted at the end that it was an exceptionally hard final and he felt bad about a few of the questions, but I could tell he didn't feel too bad about it. He always said the whole time, "It all comes out in the wash," meaning everyone else had to go through it too, so comparatively, you don't look so bad. But why make everyone go through such hardship? I know you want to differentiate the students and you don't want to give two people who differ by only a few points two different grades. You also don't want to dock someone who worked hard for making a stupid mistake if they know the concepts. But is a crazy hard test really the way to do that? I don't know if I can feel positively about something that creates that much misery. Also, how do you the sheer impossibility of a test won't just discourage someone who knows the material? I've known people who seem like they know what's going on turn around and bomb a test. One of my better students last semester did much worse than her peers who weren't as smart and didn't work as hard. Some of that might just be test anxiety (it's hard to compare a middle school student to college students in an upper div math class), but I think it just shows another example that tests are not always the most accurate measure of skill. The guy next to me seemed like he had his shit together the whole class. He was probably crying because he thought he wouldn't be above the mean, not because he thought he would fail. But what if he had thought that other people would find the test equally hard instead of thinking about how he didn't get it? Thinking one of those two thoughts over the other isn't exactly indicative of mathematical skill. But the person who thought other people were struggling too would have done better on that test than someone who started to despair, even if they had the same mathematical skills. More than once during that test I looked at a question and thought "Ummm... well this isn't happening," but at the same time I also thought that it wasn't happening for a lot of other people either. And so I just kept flipping pages until I found a problem that was happening. I've yet to see how I did. I could believe anything from a little below the mean to an SD above. I really didn't know what was going on, and there's no way to judge how it went for other people. I guess I'll find out in the next couple days when the grades get posted. Whatever my grade is, even if it's an A, I'm a little dissatisfied. I don't think I, or anyone else in the calss, learned the material that well. We certainly didn't learn it well enough to have any sort of hope on that final. And I know you're not supposed to do well on upper division math finals, but it really is disheartening to be so thoroughly trounced and feel like you didn't really learn a lot. I'm not as down about the whole thing as I'm coming off, but I do feel like it wasn't the most valuable use of my time. It is a little disappointing to work hard and suffer for not much payout. I did work hard. I did suffer. And what have I got to show for it?
Sorry to end on a bit of a low note, but that all for this blog entry. I've got a few more topics in mind for blog entries though that should be a little cheerier. To give a little spoiler of things to come, they will be titled "Comic-con is super amazing fantastic!" and "Pruning". The first one sounds more exciting than the second, but I'm a little more personally interested in the second one. It's not quite what it sounds like. Ok. That's enough of a teaser for now. More to come in a little while (not so long a dry spell as last time, in other words)!
I feel like I've skipped some background here. If you're paying attention to the bits and pieces I've been mentioning, you know that I live in a new place and that nerdiness happens there, but those are just general senses of what going on. I'd like to get a little more in to the nitty gritty of it all.
So let's talk a little about moving. I finally live with Steven now and it's great. Before we moved in together, we were really chafing about having to part ways every Sunday. It just wasn't enough to see him only on the weekends. I remember there were a few weeknights where we just had to see each other and I went over to his place for the night. It was really inconvenient since I had to wake up early to go to class the next day, but sometimes we just couldn't stand being apart. And without exception Sunday nights were a bitter experience. I remember when I had to go to manager meetings on Sundays. I was so cranky and grouchy and bit everyone's heads off. I remember our president Roxy would try to get the meetings started with cute little games. Another time of the week and I might have appreciated it, but Sunday nights I never did. I feel like I was part of the reason that she didn't like being president. Not that she held it against me I don't think. And to be honest, I'm not even sure she disliked being president. I remember her saying once that she probably wouldn't run again and didn't think it was really for her. She's one of those people who is really pure. She likes to do sweet things and take care of children. She does well around children, but not necessarily around people who make dirty jokes and ask her to show off her cleavage. And she's also the sort of person who wouldn't get mad about stuff like that, but you could tell she didn't appreciate it. I often felt like she was repressing herself a little to act appropriately in the face of some of Stebbins' darker elements when she was actually pretty bothered. But who knows. I think she enjoyed herself most of the time, so it was actually probably pretty easy for her to ignore the stuff she didn't like. She did still try to do cute little games, which children probably would have appreciated a lot more than busy college students, even as I shot her down. I feel bad about it a little, but the idea was pretty misplaced. Sure it's great if you've got nothing else better to do and everything's great for you, but when things aren't great, you want to get down to business, not play a little game. I was a little mean, she was a little shortsighted; it all evens out. I don't regret it.
Nor do I regret my non-manager status. I never really enjoyed being a manager. I took satisfaction in doing my job well, and I liked seeing it done well, and I especially hated seeing it done poorly, but I was still glad that it wasn't my responsibility. I was glad that I was able to pull up stakes and leave two thirds of the way through the summer to live with Steven. Yes, I had my frustrating moments through the summer when I disagreed with Sabira's policies and had to fight them, but even then the fight was kind of fun. Overall, I would rather not have to fight about things, but it is satisfying to win. And fighting her policies didn't really take that long. Certainly it took longer than being workshift manager, which is compensated pitifully during summer. Even when I increased the summer comp, it was still pretty pitiful. So maybe I shouldn't be too surprised that Sabira was the only one who ran, and when there's no competition, there's often low quality close behind. But I can't complain too much. She was a lot better than Matt Jones or Jon Hung. Better than Even by a wide margin too. This actually makes me think that maybe I'm too picky about the job and how I think it should be run. The only other workshift manager in my memory was Aron Bothman. I didn't experience him much first hand. I came in late and he didn't assign me any permanent workshifts, so I went down a bunch of hours. I guess in that sense he wasn't so hot. But that sort of thing is a pain, especially under the old system of workshift. I don't fault him too much. Apparently he was pretty on top of things in his day (which was before my time). But he was an incumbent for too long and got kind of lazy. At least that's what I've heard. I was only around for the very tail end of his regime, so I can't really make any of these comments from personal experience.
As much as I do love to ramble, I'd like to put this digression back on track: our new place. We did some house hunting online, but when it came down to actually looking at places, we only looked at two. Did we get the best deal we could? Who knows. Given how much time we were willing to put in to it, I think we did fine. As it stands, I love our place, and it's hard to put a price tag on satisfaction. It's a really cute place in a really convenient location. It has a nice kitchen and a two car garage. It looks really really spacious (and actually does have a pretty large square footage - 1380), and there's lots of storage space. Though some of the things I love the most about are things I would love about any house. I love being able to keep our stuff in common space without fear of it getting stolen. I love having nice things and not worrying about them getting destroyed by drunk Stebbinites. I love living in a house where I know I get along with everybody. A couple people warned me that a couple living in a house with one other person would result in a lot of third wheeling and awkwardness, but it hasn't happened yet. I think Susan and Steven and I are all getting along great. I really like our dynamic. It's going to be a really fun year I think. :)
One of the things facilitating the fun is all of our common interests. We're all a bunch of nerds. We've got Star Trek dvds on the table, Magic cards in the corner, more video game consoles than I could carry, and a handful of nerdy board games (which we actually have enough players around to play on a regular basis!). I love being immersed in all the nerdiness. Living in Stebbins, and in Berkeley in general, nerdiness is more a point of pride than one of shame, but there are people who do look down on nerdy things. It's a real downer when you come across one of those. They're generally people who have believed what others have told them without investigating for themselves. For instance, most people who dislike video games haven't actually played much of them. I don't mind them having their own opinions, but it seems like more often than not, people who dislike video games will look down on those who do. I don't look down on people who like to boat, even though it holds no interest for me. I don't look down on people who fish. I don't look down on people who go to museums. None of these things are my favorite activities. I've never fished, or been on a boat recreationally, and I rarely visit museums (and can often find myself bored when I do go). But that doesn't mean I don't see any worth in it. If it makes someone happy, then go for it. It's not hurting anyone; it's just how you choose to spend your free time. So don't be so judgmental about how I spend mine.
But realistically, everyone agrees with the statement I just made. No one thinks they're judgmental, or if they do end up judging something, they just say that that something merits it. And I think a lot of people aren't really aware that they look down on video games. They really don't think about it that often. I had difficulty coming up with examples of things I don't think about often just a moment ago. It's hard to think about something that you don't consider much. It's just that when video games do present themselves, when people do come across someone with a controller in their hands, it's like a knee jerk reaction to react negatively. I remember whenever Sabira entered a room with people playing video games, she would always leave as soon as she could because she claimed that video games were antisocial. If the type of social they keep away is Sabira's company, I don't think I mind too much. As it is, I feel very social when playing video games most of the time. Even one player games are fun to watch.
I don't know why I'm defending video games or even complaining about the disrespect they receive. It's not like it's going to change matters. I won't change anyone's opinions, but I will admit it is something of a sore spot for me. It makes it easy to rant and ramble whenever I think about it.
But back to some of the main things I was talking about. I feel like I've gone over the new house a little. Sure, there's more to tell, but perhaps now it's time to move on to a different topic, another one that was covered briefly in my introduction paragraph. Math 104 was a very difficult class for me. Everyone always said it was going to be crazy hard, and I believed them, but sometimes you have to experience something yourself to really understand it. There was some pretty crazy stuff there near the end. But the thing is, I felt like I could have understood all of it given more time. Taking this class over the summer was really hard. It's not like I had any choice in the matter, but nonetheless, I wish I had been able to take it in the fall or spring. Part of me is just glad to have it done, but I feel like I would have learned it a lot better if I had been able to go at a slower pace. I just don't feel like I got much out of this course. I felt like I was cramming the whole time. Trying to squeeze all that complicated information into my head at once makes me feel like none of it is going to stick. Even now, one day later, I don't feel like I can remember all of the little details I knew a day ago. I feel like I took this class for a reason, not just to have taken it, but given how much I took from the class, I don't know that I achieved its purpose. I was supposed to gain some insight into calculus, and maybe I did. But I really don't feel like a lot more enlightened now than I was at the beginning of summer. After taking abstract algebra and linear algebra last summer, I really felt like I knew a lot about algebra and numbers in general leaving those classes. I really learned a lot. For this class, I crammed a lot. I showed good test taking skills. But do I have some intuitive grasp on calculus? Not really. I guess I do understand some concepts better this time around than I did the first time I learned them in high school (and I learned them pretty well in high school), and I guess that will be useful (it's always important for the teacher to know a little more than she has to teach), but I worked really hard and I just don't feel like I got the same payout. It's a little embittering, especially considering all the painful stuff I had to go through. To give an idea of how crazy tough our final was, about three fourths of the way through, the guy next to me started to cry. I felt really awful. I couldn't focus on him that much because I had a test of my own to take, but I remember rooting for him silently for a second or two. "Just keep it together for another half hour! You're almost there!" There's nothing like feeling miserable to ensure that you really bomb a test though. You get into this spiral of unproductivity. You just think a lot slower when you're fighting off tears, and you know that you're moving slower and that makes you even more frustrated and makes you want to cry more. I've never broken down like that during a test, but I've had my breakdowns before. I know how he felt and I felt really bad for him. Our teacher admitted at the end that it was an exceptionally hard final and he felt bad about a few of the questions, but I could tell he didn't feel too bad about it. He always said the whole time, "It all comes out in the wash," meaning everyone else had to go through it too, so comparatively, you don't look so bad. But why make everyone go through such hardship? I know you want to differentiate the students and you don't want to give two people who differ by only a few points two different grades. You also don't want to dock someone who worked hard for making a stupid mistake if they know the concepts. But is a crazy hard test really the way to do that? I don't know if I can feel positively about something that creates that much misery. Also, how do you the sheer impossibility of a test won't just discourage someone who knows the material? I've known people who seem like they know what's going on turn around and bomb a test. One of my better students last semester did much worse than her peers who weren't as smart and didn't work as hard. Some of that might just be test anxiety (it's hard to compare a middle school student to college students in an upper div math class), but I think it just shows another example that tests are not always the most accurate measure of skill. The guy next to me seemed like he had his shit together the whole class. He was probably crying because he thought he wouldn't be above the mean, not because he thought he would fail. But what if he had thought that other people would find the test equally hard instead of thinking about how he didn't get it? Thinking one of those two thoughts over the other isn't exactly indicative of mathematical skill. But the person who thought other people were struggling too would have done better on that test than someone who started to despair, even if they had the same mathematical skills. More than once during that test I looked at a question and thought "Ummm... well this isn't happening," but at the same time I also thought that it wasn't happening for a lot of other people either. And so I just kept flipping pages until I found a problem that was happening. I've yet to see how I did. I could believe anything from a little below the mean to an SD above. I really didn't know what was going on, and there's no way to judge how it went for other people. I guess I'll find out in the next couple days when the grades get posted. Whatever my grade is, even if it's an A, I'm a little dissatisfied. I don't think I, or anyone else in the calss, learned the material that well. We certainly didn't learn it well enough to have any sort of hope on that final. And I know you're not supposed to do well on upper division math finals, but it really is disheartening to be so thoroughly trounced and feel like you didn't really learn a lot. I'm not as down about the whole thing as I'm coming off, but I do feel like it wasn't the most valuable use of my time. It is a little disappointing to work hard and suffer for not much payout. I did work hard. I did suffer. And what have I got to show for it?
Sorry to end on a bit of a low note, but that all for this blog entry. I've got a few more topics in mind for blog entries though that should be a little cheerier. To give a little spoiler of things to come, they will be titled "Comic-con is super amazing fantastic!" and "Pruning". The first one sounds more exciting than the second, but I'm a little more personally interested in the second one. It's not quite what it sounds like. Ok. That's enough of a teaser for now. More to come in a little while (not so long a dry spell as last time, in other words)!
Thursday, July 17, 2008
Who to Teach?
When I first got interested in teaching, one of the reasons I wanted to do it is because a lot of people don't see how math is relevant to their lives, and I think that makes their lives a lot worse. People who can use math fluently can adapt to their surroundings better, can manipulate their environment, are less likely to get cheated by deals they don't understand, etc. I really think it not only makes your life better, but it makes your life better by a huge amount.
Now there's a lot of people who don't see how math is relevant, but they're still good at it. They probably won't ever credit math with their successes in life, but I honestly don't worry about them that much. They'll be able to figure things out when they need to. But there are a lot of people who really can't handle math related things. There are people who fundamentally don't understand credit cards and end up poor the rest of their life because of it. There are people who get suckered in to signing up for premium packages even though they utilize about a tenth of the resources. There are people who think they'll be in the top 10% of the nation, when they don't even have a chance, or understand what that means. In fact, most people think they're above average. People who aren't capable of sitting down and reasoning through their situations are at a severe disadvantage. If everything goes well in their life and difficult decisions never come up, then it's not such a big issue. It is feasible that you could get by without math in an ideal situation. However most people will be faced with difficult choices. Do I chose place X for $500 a month, or place Y for $700 a month? Each of those choices has many repercussions on the rest of your life. Do I get a car loan, or do I take the bus? A friend of my mom's bought an SUV a few years ago. She liked the idea of being able to spontaneously go into the mountains. Not my kind of thing really, since I'm so indoorsy, but I can see that being a nice thing to have. So we know the benefits. What are the costs? And how do you best compare them to weigh your options? Do you compare the money spent on renting a car vs paying off one you own? How about factoring in flexibility (you have to pay for the car you own- you don't have to rent a car if you can't afford it)? And how do you account for environmental concerns? And even if those aren't important to you, what about other lasting factors? How will your credit score be affected if you're pushing yourself to pay for a car? What if you, like my mom's friend, pay only the minimum balance on the car every month? My mom's friend didn't even realize she had bad credit until she applied for a loan to buy a house. That must have hurt to find out that paying the minimum balance every month was making it harder and harder to own a home. She thought she was paying what she owed and so should have great credit. She didn't realize that she was never touching the principle and that when applying to get a loan, it appeared that she already had a large debt.
Are all of these concerns math related? Not directly. Some of it is just misinformation leading to misfortune. But what caused that level of misinformation? When you sign a contract for a credit card, all the rules are spread out and described. Of course, if you can't understand percentages or compound interest, it might not mean much to you. If your grasp over mathematics is so poor that you can't understand contracts that you sign yourself into, then maybe you'll have trouble figuring out how to work within the system. Maybe you'll have a harder time calculating the costs and benefits of something you wish to purchase. Maybe you won't save up the money you need for retirement and will have to keep working until eventually your company fires your for being unfit to work and you've destroyed your health just trying to make ends meet. Most people do not have enough money for retirement. Would it have been any different if they had sat down and calculated their earnings at an earlier stage of life? Would they have still decided to buy the fancier car or the larger house or get the hundreds of DVDs for their collection? Why do people buy things that they cannot afford? Is it because they don't see the consequences? Or is it because they don't understand them? It is a difficult mathematical calculation to even decide what it is that you can and cannot afford. It takes further understanding to realize what the repercussions are for going over the limit, or even for not going positive enough. I want to help people use math so their lives are better. Even if people don't see these as mathematical calculations, if someone is good at math, they'll be able to figure things out on their own. It grants them a certain independence and makes me confident that they'll go on to do fine. It's the students who struggle with even simple computations who worry me. What decisions will they make when the stakes are higher? Where instead of getting grades, they get debt? I worry for them a lot. And that why I want to teach. I figure that's the best way to help these people and the best way to target ignorance.
However certain signs indicate to me that that might not be the path I take when teaching. Several people in my program have commented to me that I would really excel at teaching the higher level calculus classes, especially when I comment about having difficulties with my lower achieving class. I keep thinking to myself, "But those kids are fine! They'll get by just fine without me. They'll go to college and make some realizations and maybe they'll get burned at times, but they'll learn from it and figure out a way to come back." It's the other kids who I worry might not bounce back so easily. I want to help them so that they won't be at such a disadvantage. But I don't know sometimes. Was I really a help to my last class? I don't really think so. It's true that I don't know where they would have been without me, but I have to say I wasn't happy with where they ended up. Most of them quit trying, or were unhappy about trying when everyone else just copied from them. I didn't get across any of the idea that were really important to me, some of the ideas that took several paragraphs up above. But I've been thinking about it recently- those ideas aren't simple. It's true that the struggling students don't understand a lot of what I just wrote about, but I'm not so sure the advanced students do either. None of them have credit cards- why should they understand credit debt? But they might be in a better position to understand some of those things. I just assumed that they'd figure it out as they went though life, but who's to say that they would? I know a lot of bright people who got turned off to math and then never touched it again. Will I be able to do more good helping remedial kids (against nearly overwhelming odds, I might add), or helping the already gifted who have a better chance of actually showing some improvement because of me? Is this a case of helping the wealthy (in knowledge) get wealthier? Will I really enact any change this way? I would like to help the most needy, but of course, those are the hardest to help. I don't know what to do.
Truthfully, I'm just going to have to try different things and see what feels most rewarding to me. It's not like I have to choose one or the other. I think I can try both, even at the same time. It's just hard for me to consider changing my original reason for getting into teaching, to shift my target group from the students of early math to the students who have already mastered (or gotten past at least) the basics. It's a tough decision and even after writing for a while, I don't feel like I have any answers.
Now there's a lot of people who don't see how math is relevant, but they're still good at it. They probably won't ever credit math with their successes in life, but I honestly don't worry about them that much. They'll be able to figure things out when they need to. But there are a lot of people who really can't handle math related things. There are people who fundamentally don't understand credit cards and end up poor the rest of their life because of it. There are people who get suckered in to signing up for premium packages even though they utilize about a tenth of the resources. There are people who think they'll be in the top 10% of the nation, when they don't even have a chance, or understand what that means. In fact, most people think they're above average. People who aren't capable of sitting down and reasoning through their situations are at a severe disadvantage. If everything goes well in their life and difficult decisions never come up, then it's not such a big issue. It is feasible that you could get by without math in an ideal situation. However most people will be faced with difficult choices. Do I chose place X for $500 a month, or place Y for $700 a month? Each of those choices has many repercussions on the rest of your life. Do I get a car loan, or do I take the bus? A friend of my mom's bought an SUV a few years ago. She liked the idea of being able to spontaneously go into the mountains. Not my kind of thing really, since I'm so indoorsy, but I can see that being a nice thing to have. So we know the benefits. What are the costs? And how do you best compare them to weigh your options? Do you compare the money spent on renting a car vs paying off one you own? How about factoring in flexibility (you have to pay for the car you own- you don't have to rent a car if you can't afford it)? And how do you account for environmental concerns? And even if those aren't important to you, what about other lasting factors? How will your credit score be affected if you're pushing yourself to pay for a car? What if you, like my mom's friend, pay only the minimum balance on the car every month? My mom's friend didn't even realize she had bad credit until she applied for a loan to buy a house. That must have hurt to find out that paying the minimum balance every month was making it harder and harder to own a home. She thought she was paying what she owed and so should have great credit. She didn't realize that she was never touching the principle and that when applying to get a loan, it appeared that she already had a large debt.
Are all of these concerns math related? Not directly. Some of it is just misinformation leading to misfortune. But what caused that level of misinformation? When you sign a contract for a credit card, all the rules are spread out and described. Of course, if you can't understand percentages or compound interest, it might not mean much to you. If your grasp over mathematics is so poor that you can't understand contracts that you sign yourself into, then maybe you'll have trouble figuring out how to work within the system. Maybe you'll have a harder time calculating the costs and benefits of something you wish to purchase. Maybe you won't save up the money you need for retirement and will have to keep working until eventually your company fires your for being unfit to work and you've destroyed your health just trying to make ends meet. Most people do not have enough money for retirement. Would it have been any different if they had sat down and calculated their earnings at an earlier stage of life? Would they have still decided to buy the fancier car or the larger house or get the hundreds of DVDs for their collection? Why do people buy things that they cannot afford? Is it because they don't see the consequences? Or is it because they don't understand them? It is a difficult mathematical calculation to even decide what it is that you can and cannot afford. It takes further understanding to realize what the repercussions are for going over the limit, or even for not going positive enough. I want to help people use math so their lives are better. Even if people don't see these as mathematical calculations, if someone is good at math, they'll be able to figure things out on their own. It grants them a certain independence and makes me confident that they'll go on to do fine. It's the students who struggle with even simple computations who worry me. What decisions will they make when the stakes are higher? Where instead of getting grades, they get debt? I worry for them a lot. And that why I want to teach. I figure that's the best way to help these people and the best way to target ignorance.
However certain signs indicate to me that that might not be the path I take when teaching. Several people in my program have commented to me that I would really excel at teaching the higher level calculus classes, especially when I comment about having difficulties with my lower achieving class. I keep thinking to myself, "But those kids are fine! They'll get by just fine without me. They'll go to college and make some realizations and maybe they'll get burned at times, but they'll learn from it and figure out a way to come back." It's the other kids who I worry might not bounce back so easily. I want to help them so that they won't be at such a disadvantage. But I don't know sometimes. Was I really a help to my last class? I don't really think so. It's true that I don't know where they would have been without me, but I have to say I wasn't happy with where they ended up. Most of them quit trying, or were unhappy about trying when everyone else just copied from them. I didn't get across any of the idea that were really important to me, some of the ideas that took several paragraphs up above. But I've been thinking about it recently- those ideas aren't simple. It's true that the struggling students don't understand a lot of what I just wrote about, but I'm not so sure the advanced students do either. None of them have credit cards- why should they understand credit debt? But they might be in a better position to understand some of those things. I just assumed that they'd figure it out as they went though life, but who's to say that they would? I know a lot of bright people who got turned off to math and then never touched it again. Will I be able to do more good helping remedial kids (against nearly overwhelming odds, I might add), or helping the already gifted who have a better chance of actually showing some improvement because of me? Is this a case of helping the wealthy (in knowledge) get wealthier? Will I really enact any change this way? I would like to help the most needy, but of course, those are the hardest to help. I don't know what to do.
Truthfully, I'm just going to have to try different things and see what feels most rewarding to me. It's not like I have to choose one or the other. I think I can try both, even at the same time. It's just hard for me to consider changing my original reason for getting into teaching, to shift my target group from the students of early math to the students who have already mastered (or gotten past at least) the basics. It's a tough decision and even after writing for a while, I don't feel like I have any answers.
Monday, July 14, 2008
Indoor Skydiving
Doesn't sound like a good idea, does it? Well it is! It's also not quite what it sounds like. It approximates skydiving in that it's quite windy, but it doesn't really involve the sky at all. Or diving for that matter. Really it's all false advertisement except for the indoor part.
To put it simply, there's an enormous fan blowing air straight up into a small wind tunnel. The force of the wind is actually enough to suspend you in the air. It's supposed to feel pretty similar to skydiving. I wouldn't know since I've never skydived, but I can say that indoor skydiving is a blast! I went last weekend and it was really fun. It was very short and very pricey ($55 for 2 minutes!), but Steven and I had been wanting to try it for a while, and in a bad economy like this one, I fear things like indoor skydiving might have some difficulty surviving. Silly me though. The place was packed! And the receptionists were on the phone constantly taking reservations for future appointments. Crazy.
So we shelled out the bucks and got to fly around in the wind tunnel for a little while. There was an instructor with us and once we started getting the hang of the tunnel, he started spinning us around in the air. It was pretty cool. One word of caution though: the wind blows so hard that it was a little hard for me to breathe through my nose. What option did that leave? Breathing through my mouth, which of course meant keeping my mouth open. Which, as it turns out, meant getting my saliva blown onto my face where it pretty much instantly dried. Not a problem if you have nice breath. But let's just say my experience inspired me to eat some mints.
It was a lot of money for a short time, but I have to say I'm tempted to go back. The second time is cheaper and you're able to control your own movements more (instead of having the instructor position you). If you get good enough, you eventually move up to the really high speed winds and can do barrel rolls and other really crazy flips. I think the second visit is $40 and it gets even cheaper from there, but that's still a lot, especially considering how little time you're actually in there.
Perhaps one day I'll go back, but for now I'll just call it another interesting experience under my belt and move on. I do have one extra special memory from it though: after we were done, Steven told me that I looked so cute in the wind tunnel with my little wind blown smile (getting spit on my face and not really caring) that he fell in love with me all over again. He's a real romantic that one. I told him as much, and he just said that he says what he's feeling. And that's why he's such a romantic. He's the best.
To put it simply, there's an enormous fan blowing air straight up into a small wind tunnel. The force of the wind is actually enough to suspend you in the air. It's supposed to feel pretty similar to skydiving. I wouldn't know since I've never skydived, but I can say that indoor skydiving is a blast! I went last weekend and it was really fun. It was very short and very pricey ($55 for 2 minutes!), but Steven and I had been wanting to try it for a while, and in a bad economy like this one, I fear things like indoor skydiving might have some difficulty surviving. Silly me though. The place was packed! And the receptionists were on the phone constantly taking reservations for future appointments. Crazy.
So we shelled out the bucks and got to fly around in the wind tunnel for a little while. There was an instructor with us and once we started getting the hang of the tunnel, he started spinning us around in the air. It was pretty cool. One word of caution though: the wind blows so hard that it was a little hard for me to breathe through my nose. What option did that leave? Breathing through my mouth, which of course meant keeping my mouth open. Which, as it turns out, meant getting my saliva blown onto my face where it pretty much instantly dried. Not a problem if you have nice breath. But let's just say my experience inspired me to eat some mints.
It was a lot of money for a short time, but I have to say I'm tempted to go back. The second time is cheaper and you're able to control your own movements more (instead of having the instructor position you). If you get good enough, you eventually move up to the really high speed winds and can do barrel rolls and other really crazy flips. I think the second visit is $40 and it gets even cheaper from there, but that's still a lot, especially considering how little time you're actually in there.
Perhaps one day I'll go back, but for now I'll just call it another interesting experience under my belt and move on. I do have one extra special memory from it though: after we were done, Steven told me that I looked so cute in the wind tunnel with my little wind blown smile (getting spit on my face and not really caring) that he fell in love with me all over again. He's a real romantic that one. I told him as much, and he just said that he says what he's feeling. And that's why he's such a romantic. He's the best.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)