One of the things that's most interesting about grad school is all the people who are in it. It's like taking the one or two really motivated high achieving students in each class and putting them all together. Pretty much everyone has something pertinent to add to the conversation and most people understand the readings quite well. However, I find myself thinking that some of them don't belong there, that some just aren't as competent as the others. Of course, that must be the case, but then I started thinking about who it was that I felt wasn't as competent. It seems like it's mostly the other MACSME students, and more specifically the math ones. Admittedly, those are the ones I spend the most time with, so I'd have more opportunity to see flaws. I don't see too much of the science MACSMEs, but I get that vibe from some of them too. Maybe I'd get it more if I had to see more of them.
Now maybe it just looks like the MACSMEs bs more because I'm comparing them to PhD candidates, but I'm starting to wonder if it might be because of my competitive streak. It's never quite manifested like this before, but I shouldn't rule it out. I just don't respect some of them, sometimes to the point of active dislike. For instance, there's one person, Patrick, who never has anything of note to say. I find myself wondering how he got into the program. He's ridiculously boring. It's impossible to get anything remotely interesting out of him when he speaks. I drove in the same car with him for over an hour when we went to the retreat, and we didn't get past small talk. It was really boring small talk at that. When he talks about important things, he just doesn't have anything interesting to say. As we were leaving the retreat, he asked me what I thought and we started discussing what to do in a situation Dan mentioned where one black student says to another black student "Quit acting white" when he answered a question correctly. He didn't know what he would do. I said I'd stop the whole class and discuss it right then and there. In a worst case scenario, I'd gain a little more understanding of the situation and wouldn't stop the class like that again, but that's a situation I don't understand as well as my students might, so I'd just stop all math instruction and start talking about it. I'd butt in whenever I thought I could add in my two cents about how wrong it is to associate success with whiteness. I said that taking 10 or 15 minutes to talk about that was more important than covering my entire lesson plan for the day. From reading his journal, last week he experienced a situation where one of the kids said "that's gay" and it bothered him. Here's a direct quote "I would have told the student not to make those types of comments in my classroom because they were homophobic in nature. If the student questioned the context behind why I banned such language I don’t believe I would have a problem holding a five or ten minute discussion about how hate surfaces in a variety of ways, including our daily language. I know that I would probably fall behind in terms of my agenda, but I prioritize the safety of my classroom over the material that I’m going to cover that day."
It's a less effective, more pretentious version of what I said. Is the imitation flattering me, or just pissing me off? You guess.
What a waste of space. He says nothing interesting in discussion. He just sits there most of the time. He barely even shows emotion. It wouldn't be so bad if it just looked like he felt something. He just looks bored most of the time, but in truth, he mostly just bores me. How am I in the same program as this guy? What sort of an application did he have to have to hide his inherent dullness?
So that's one of the math MACSMEs. Another one (Michael) seems like a pretty nice guy. He's interesting and I have decent conversations with him, but he seems kinda slow. I suppose no one in the program is really slow, but things just seems to take him a while. He mentioned how hard a recent paper was for him and how he hadn't written anything since high school. That's a little weird that he never needed to write anything in college, but I suppose it could happen. So you'd think from that statement that he'd be really good at math, right? I mean, if he wasn't writing and he's in the math program, he was probably doing math. But he's not that good at math. Maybe he's just forgotten a lot, but he doesn't know that many really simple things. For instance, he forgot that a problem could be easily solved by knowing that the ratios of sides on similar triangles are preserved. He forgot about similar triangles in general. He also forgot how to make a perpendicular bisector of a line. Honestly, it understandable that you might forget that. I forgot it too. But I derived it in less than a minute. The concept isn't that hard. He's doing his research project on sudoku, and he bought this book that goes into the math behind sudoku. He was talking about how it applies group theory and such to the solutions of a sudoku. Ok. It's lovely that some mathematician got really excited about sudoku and decided to apply it to his life, but that's bullshit. I can't say for sure since I haven't read it, but I can't imagine how that would be helpful. Sudoku is trial and error. There are a few instances here and there where you need a little bit of logic, but overall, sudokus are pretty mindless. You can have some heuristics that guide where you search and make it a little less random, but overall it's a horribly tedious game. He was practically in awe of this book without even stopping to analyze it and he was doing research on sudoku without really understanding sudoku. He bought this book of really bad sudoku puzzles that will likely bias his data (or at least make the collection difficult) and he doesn't even realize it. The book has easy, medium, and hard rated sudokus that are supposedly better than your average sudoku because they were made by hand instead of by a computer (that way it is challenging throughout, instead of getting past one tricky part and it being smooth sailing from there). The easy problem he gave our research group was way harder than your average easy sudoku. I'd give it a 3 out of 5 in terms of difficulty. We did a hard one together the next day. Or really, he started it, got stuck, and I finished it. But anyway, the hard one was of almost comparable difficulty to me anyway. Let's just say I don't buy the hype of that little book.
In general, I find myself wondering about this guy's critical skills. Does he just accept everything without questioning it? He's a grad student now- he shouldn't be accepting everything at face value. Also, he should really learn his math inside and out if he wants to be a teacher. If you've forgotten a few of the basics, I guess that's ok. He could relearn them quickly enough, and there are plenty of teachers worse off than he is, so he's good by comparison at least. I guess I'm just a little surprised since I expected more of someone going to grad school at Berkeley. He seems often flustered. He tells me things he just discovered that I already realized weeks ago like they're super enlightening (ie "I started out by reading everything and that was very time consuming. Now I just skim." Yeah, dumbass. Thanks for the advice). The other day, he was talking about converting binary numbers to base 10. I don't remember the exact words, but the conversation went something like this: (he's talking to me and John, this ridiculously smart math undergrad that I took a ling class with a few years ago):
Him: Here's something really cool- changing the base of numbers really quickly. Do you know how to do that?
Me: Yeah.
Him: Oh. Really?
Me: Well, I know how to change the base of numbers? I guess I don't know how to do it quickly. (For once I was thinking he might have something valuable to contribute)
Him: (takes binary number) You take each digit and multiply it by 2 to a power.
Me: Yeah... (expectantly)
Him: And that's it.
Me: But that's true in any base, including base 10. It's just your ones plus your tens plus your hundreds, etc.
Then I started talking to John about how you would go from base 2 to base 5 without switching to base 10 in the middle. That's about where we lost Michael.
I don't mean to sound too harsh, but I just don't respect his intellect. I omitted a lot of him being really impressed with his change of base formula, which honestly just follows from a real, rich understanding of what a number is. It probably doesn't follow for someone who wasn't a math major, but it ought to have been relatively obvious upon a few moments thought for him. I think I learned the simple formula back in high school. It's not terribly fast as he was implying. Nor is it something to bring out to show off to other mathematicians (or mathematically minded folk). It's something you show off to someone who's never seen the stuff before, like high school kids, but it really wasn't the time for it. He probably saw a bunch of people excited about math and wanted to contribute, but he just isn't equipped to do so. He was excited by the math, so that will be really good when he's a teacher, but I feel like he's a few steps behind the rest of us all the time.
I should really cut him some slack though. I mean, he remembers things almost as soon as I tell him (or at least he says he does). And admittedly, I am really bratty sometimes, especially with respect to math. I guess it's just that in the math classes I took over the summer (specifically the upper div math class), I realized how brilliant some of the math majors at Cal are. I struggled to keep up with some of them, and I have no small opinion of my own intellect (arrogant, but not ill-deserved). I just can't imagine Michael staying afloat in that situation. He must have done his undergrad someplace less rigorous than Cal. There are some real geniuses here in our math department. I wonder how far he would have gone with math if he realized how middle of the pack he is. Though in all fairness, he's probably in like the 98th percentile. I'm just snobby because I've seen how good that 99th percentile is.
Sigh. I really need to get over myself and not be so mean to him just because I don't respect his intelligence. I don't hold most other people to that standard of math. I guess I just have a ridiculously high standard for people within my program. Some of the people meet it. Just not really the first years. Well, the other math first year seems pretty intelligent. Just not these two.
Oh well. I'd love to keep soliloquizing, but I'm starting to get really tired. The energy for further ranting is fading. I have to wake up in like 5 and a half hours. Wah.
Oh but before I go, I want to briefly revisit my initial concern. Why am I being so harsh on my peers? Does it make me feel like I'm in a less prestigious program than I thought MACSME was because the people in it are not super brilliant mathematicians? Is it me being threatened and thus getting defensive and competitive in an attempt to continue to stand out in an environment where the expectations are a lot higher? Or are they really just not that impressive? Are people applying to a masters program in general not the smartest tier of people (self selecting)? Sigh. I don't know. But I do know these people were supposed to be experts and they just aren't, at least not compared to some of the other people I've seen.
Friday, October 5, 2007
Friday, September 28, 2007
a strange solution to a difficult kid
One of the other MACSMEs has this one difficult kid she was telling us about. She tries to explain the math and he argues with her saying that he's right. He does it publicly in front of the class which makes her pretty uncomfortable. He's always challenging her. So while I'm reading what she wrote about how difficult this kid is, I found myself imagining what I would do in that situation. I've got an idea of a possible scenario, but I'm not sure if that would be handling it really well or really poorly. It's a very strange response, so I assume it would be one of those two extremes.
If he challenged me repeatedly in front of the class, trying to get attention and publicly show me up, I'd probably elevate it even higher than that. You know, make it really public. Something along the lines of stopping the class and saying "Ladies and gentlemen! We have a challenger! XXX has challenged me, the math teacher. This is an insult upon my honor! XXX, I challenge you to a math duel! The terms are this: together we will choose an impartial judge to write a few math problems that we will both work on. We will be judged on both accuracy and speed, with more emphasis on accuracy. If I win, you behave a little better in class. If you win, you get an automatic A on your next test. The class can observe us during our duel to make sure no cheating occurs. Do you accept the challenge?"
Would that just shame the student? Or would it give him a chance to let out some of that aggression in a more channeled way? If I won (which I assure you I would), he would probably live up to his end of the bargain and behave since he had more of a choice in that than with the classic "behave!" command. If he didn't accept the challenge then he would have backed down during his best opportunity to show he had the skills and thus wouldn't have much credence with the class anymore. If by some freak chance of nature he won, then he'd deserve an A on the next test (I mean, if he can do it better than the teacher, then that seems like A material to me). Though I do worry that defeating him in front of the class would just make him embarrassed and withdrawn for the rest of the year, which isn't what I want either. I would probably end with, "Well I kinda thought I would win. I do this for a living. I mean, this is all I do all day. You couldn't have really expected to do better. Which is why I didn't like it when you kept challenging me and saying I was wrong. I don't hold it against you, but I'd really appreciate if you let me help you instead of challenging me every time I make a suggestion."
Still, I see a lot of problems with my solution. But in some respects, I think it could work. I'd have to see the classroom dynamic for myself to see if it was really merited, but in theory, I think it's a pretty cool idea. Perhaps it would just be smarter to call his parents.
Any comments on whether or not you think it would work?
If he challenged me repeatedly in front of the class, trying to get attention and publicly show me up, I'd probably elevate it even higher than that. You know, make it really public. Something along the lines of stopping the class and saying "Ladies and gentlemen! We have a challenger! XXX has challenged me, the math teacher. This is an insult upon my honor! XXX, I challenge you to a math duel! The terms are this: together we will choose an impartial judge to write a few math problems that we will both work on. We will be judged on both accuracy and speed, with more emphasis on accuracy. If I win, you behave a little better in class. If you win, you get an automatic A on your next test. The class can observe us during our duel to make sure no cheating occurs. Do you accept the challenge?"
Would that just shame the student? Or would it give him a chance to let out some of that aggression in a more channeled way? If I won (which I assure you I would), he would probably live up to his end of the bargain and behave since he had more of a choice in that than with the classic "behave!" command. If he didn't accept the challenge then he would have backed down during his best opportunity to show he had the skills and thus wouldn't have much credence with the class anymore. If by some freak chance of nature he won, then he'd deserve an A on the next test (I mean, if he can do it better than the teacher, then that seems like A material to me). Though I do worry that defeating him in front of the class would just make him embarrassed and withdrawn for the rest of the year, which isn't what I want either. I would probably end with, "Well I kinda thought I would win. I do this for a living. I mean, this is all I do all day. You couldn't have really expected to do better. Which is why I didn't like it when you kept challenging me and saying I was wrong. I don't hold it against you, but I'd really appreciate if you let me help you instead of challenging me every time I make a suggestion."
Still, I see a lot of problems with my solution. But in some respects, I think it could work. I'd have to see the classroom dynamic for myself to see if it was really merited, but in theory, I think it's a pretty cool idea. Perhaps it would just be smarter to call his parents.
Any comments on whether or not you think it would work?
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
I like bark!
When I was younger, I always liked the shape of leaves and what flowers trees had, but now I've discovered I really like bark. It has so much variety. Each tree has a unique pattern. It's really beautiful and fun to feel. Yay bark!
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Ack!
A few days ago, someone sent out an email to people in my program asking if anyone was interested in being a student representative for this retreat on race in teaching programs. The topic is very interesting to me and I'll admit that a nice excuse to miss class sounded somewhat appealing (it's a several day long retreat). Only two of us said we were interested, and so they managed to find enough funds for both of us to go. I think to myself, oh this sounds nice. It should be informative and fun. I think most people there will be a lot older than me, but that's ok. I figure it's going to be renting out a large room somewhere with a bunch of folding chairs and maybe a powerpoint on a projector. A few crummy lunches, maybe airline quality, (but also free, so who am I to complain) would be tossed in there too. Probably renting rooms at some cheap hotel nearby. They said it was in Sonoma in the countryside, so I was pretty much expecting it to be the boonies.
Well wasn't I wrong.
This is no cheap boonies excursion. This thing is SWANKY! They just sent me the information today. Perhaps it's just an overly flowery writer talking the place up too much, but this sounds like it's high class. I mean super high class. I mean, guy in the bathroom asking if you want him to wipe you ass high class.
Well maybe not that high class.
But Jesus! I'll actually have to wear nice things! They can't make me shave though. There's no way they're making me shave.
Before I go, let me just give a few brief examples of the swank:
This is the Westerbeke estate, where the Westerbeke family has lived for over 70 years.
And here's a direct quote: "Our gourmet chefs bring unique gifts of grace, skill and invaluable culinary knowledge to our kitchen. Everything is prepared with special emphasis on herbs and natural flavors. No outside food or beverages are allowed without prior approval."
No hard liquor allowed. They have wine and beer (probably at exorbitant prices) and they charge a $6 corking fee for a bottle of wine and a $6 fee per six pack of beer or soda which you wish to bring into the ranch.
...
What have I gotten myself into? This is (was) a private home that can fit 51 people! Ack!
Well wasn't I wrong.
This is no cheap boonies excursion. This thing is SWANKY! They just sent me the information today. Perhaps it's just an overly flowery writer talking the place up too much, but this sounds like it's high class. I mean super high class. I mean, guy in the bathroom asking if you want him to wipe you ass high class.
Well maybe not that high class.
But Jesus! I'll actually have to wear nice things! They can't make me shave though. There's no way they're making me shave.
Before I go, let me just give a few brief examples of the swank:
This is the Westerbeke estate, where the Westerbeke family has lived for over 70 years.
And here's a direct quote: "Our gourmet chefs bring unique gifts of grace, skill and invaluable culinary knowledge to our kitchen. Everything is prepared with special emphasis on herbs and natural flavors. No outside food or beverages are allowed without prior approval."
No hard liquor allowed. They have wine and beer (probably at exorbitant prices) and they charge a $6 corking fee for a bottle of wine and a $6 fee per six pack of beer or soda which you wish to bring into the ranch.
...
What have I gotten myself into? This is (was) a private home that can fit 51 people! Ack!
Realizations about grad school
The reading doesn't really matter. This is not entirely accurate. It's important insofar as it develops a background that you can draw upon for research. Research is really all that's important. You can do a half-assed reading and bs it. You can skim something once and never worry about it again. It's not going to be tested. You might also pick something up and never put it down for hours. It's all about seeing something and going for it, head first. I don't think I realized before how suited I am to grad school. Well, in a sense. As an undergrad, I read most of what was assigned to me. There were few classes where I skimped on the reading (most of them pass/no pass classes I was taking for fun). Now, even though these are letter graded classes, I realize that it's not always that important for me to do the reading. In my problem solving class, there's a fair amount of reading each week. Nothing too extravagant. Part of our grade is how much we participate in the discussion of the reading in class, but it's a small part of the grade. Most of our grade is a project of original research (actually, I could just duplicate someone else's findings if I felt like being boring). Now this is where I decided that grad school suits me. If I get an idea in my head, I get very excited about it. I start thinking of ways to implement it, if it were possible, what it would tell me, etc. This research project came to me in a flash and now I can't get my mind past it. I have to do something that models problem solving. I want to tape people playing Tetris Attack. Think of how it will benefit mankind! Actually, when you think about it, you could model cognitive abilities quite well using Tetris Attack. I would say my hypothesis is that improvement is based upon search mechanisms. As you improve, you must develop more effective and efficient methods of searching. At first as a novice, it is challenging just to search for three tiles to match up. As you progress past novice, you are able to find three in a row with little difficulty and are even able to search for higher combos of more than three in a row. The next step (chains) is the hardest where your search must include tiles far away from where the original action takes place. As you improve more and more, your search becomes more inclusive of the whole screen. Speed also plays a vital role. This area of cognition could be very fascinating to read into. I hope the prof thinks this project could be feasible. I can't wait!
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Solutions
My first reply will be an existence proof. Perhaps I shall include two existence proofs just for the heck of it. There are a lot of them
My second reply will be a hint to the construction problem.
My final reply will be one possible solution that happens to be very elegant. It may take me a while to post though since it's harder to be clear with just text.
My second reply will be a hint to the construction problem.
My final reply will be one possible solution that happens to be very elegant. It may take me a while to post though since it's harder to be clear with just text.
The beauty of math
You are given the triangle on the in the figure below. A friend of mine claims that she can inscribe a square in the triangle -- that is, that she can find a construction, using straightedge and compass, that results in a square, all four of whose corners lie on the sides of the triangle. Is there such a construction -- or might it be impossible? Do you know for certain there's an inscribed square? Do you know for certain there's a construction that will produce it?


Note that there are several steps to this problem. The first is to prove such a thing exists (hint: It does!). It is also interesting to prove if this holds for all triangles. The next step, finding if/how you could construct this square using only a compass and straightedge, is more complicated, but it is an example of the true beauty of math. It leads to enlightenment and turns out to be a better high than most drugs. Solutions will be posted in the next post, but I'll put them in the reply section so as not to ruin anything for anyone. The solution is beautiful even without struggling with the problem and trying to solve it yourself, but you will appreciate its beauty more if you engage with the problem a little ahead of time. Also, you may find an alternate solution to the one I will post (there are many), which is also satisfying, (though I think you would be hard pressed to find something more elegant that this one which someone else came up with in class).


Note that there are several steps to this problem. The first is to prove such a thing exists (hint: It does!). It is also interesting to prove if this holds for all triangles. The next step, finding if/how you could construct this square using only a compass and straightedge, is more complicated, but it is an example of the true beauty of math. It leads to enlightenment and turns out to be a better high than most drugs. Solutions will be posted in the next post, but I'll put them in the reply section so as not to ruin anything for anyone. The solution is beautiful even without struggling with the problem and trying to solve it yourself, but you will appreciate its beauty more if you engage with the problem a little ahead of time. Also, you may find an alternate solution to the one I will post (there are many), which is also satisfying, (though I think you would be hard pressed to find something more elegant that this one which someone else came up with in class).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)